Last night on Border Watch with Cole Brennan
New Jersey Sues Again Over an ICE Detention Center. The Constitution and a Federal Appeals Court Already Say Who Runs It
Trenton wants a judge to force Homeland Security to answer its subpoenas about Delaney Hall, but the Third Circuit struck down the state's last attempt to control federal immigration detention.
Filed November 17, 2026 · 📍 Trenton, NJ 08608
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- New Jersey sued DHS on Tuesday, saying it has ignored state subpoenas about Newark's Delaney Hall since August.
- GEO Group says it cannot release records about federal detainees without DHS authorization.
- In 2025 the Third Circuit struck down New Jersey's ban on immigration detention contracts under the Supremacy Clause.
- DHS has called the state's earlier inspection lawsuit frivolous and says the facility meets required standards.
New Jersey is taking the federal government to court again over Delaney Hall, the immigration detention center in Newark run by the private company GEO Group. Attorney General Jennifer Davenport announced on Tuesday that the state has sued the Department of Homeland Security in federal court, accusing the department of stonewalling a state investigation by refusing to respond to subpoenas the state issued in August [1][3].
The state says it is simply asking for records. The fuller picture shows something else: a state government that has spent years trying to push federal immigration detention out of New Jersey, that has already lost in a federal appeals court, and that is now using a different legal tool to pursue the same fight.
What New Jersey Is Claiming
According to the New Jersey Monitor, the state's August subpoena to GEO Group sought records on detainee medical care, use-of-force incidents, injuries and conditions inside the facility [1]. GEO told the state it could not hand over the records without permission from DHS and said it had forwarded the request to the department [1][2].
The new lawsuit argues that GEO, as a private business operating on its own property, does not need federal permission to comply, and it asks a judge to find that DHS has violated the Administrative Procedure Act by unreasonably delaying a response and to set a deadline for one [1]. The state says its investigation followed reports about conditions at the center and the deaths of detainees in federal custody [1]. A separate state lawsuit filed in June against GEO concerns state health inspectors' access to the building [1].
The Courts Have Already Weighed In
This is not New Jersey's first attempt to control what happens inside federal immigration detention. In 2021, the state passed a law banning new contracts to hold people for civil immigration violations. In July 2025, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit struck that law down in a 2-1 decision, holding that it violated the constitutional rule that states may not discriminate against or directly regulate the federal government's own operations [4].
That principle, known as intergovernmental immunity, flows from the Supremacy Clause in Article VI of the Constitution, which makes federal law the supreme law of the land. The majority found that New Jersey passed its law because it objected to some of Washington's immigration tools, and treated the ban as an attempt to hobble a federal function rather than a neutral rule that applies to everyone [4].
Immigration enforcement and detention are federal responsibilities, assigned by Congress to the executive branch. States may have legitimate concerns about health and safety within their borders, but a subpoena that targets a federal contractor's records about federal detainees in a federal program runs straight into that same constitutional line. When GEO said it needed DHS's authorization, it was acknowledging who is legally responsible for the people in its care.
What the Federal Record Shows
The state's lawsuit also leaves out how much federal oversight already exists. Detention centers that hold ICE detainees are subject to federal detention standards and federal inspections [6]. In June, law professor Jonathan Turley wrote that a federal inspection had reportedly found Delaney Hall in compliance with virtually all applicable standards [6].
DHS has also pushed back on the state's earlier litigation. When New Jersey officials sued over access for health inspectors, the department called the suit frivolous, said state health representatives had in fact been allowed in to inspect, and said the facility complies with required state and local laws [5].
None of that means every concern about detainee care should be dismissed. Every person in government custody deserves humane treatment and proper medical care, and deaths in custody deserve a full and honest review. The question is who conducts it. Federal law gives that job to federal inspectors, the department's inspector general and Congress, which funds and oversees immigration detention.
Who Is Pushing Back and What Comes Next
DHS has repeatedly rejected New Jersey's claims about the center and has not accepted the state's demand for records [1][5]. The Third Circuit's 2025 ruling stands as the clearest statement yet that New Jersey cannot use state power to override federal detention decisions [4].
A federal judge will now decide whether DHS must answer the state's subpoenas and by when [1]. Whatever the outcome, the larger pattern is hard to miss. When a state cannot ban federal detention outright, it tries inspections; when inspections stall, it tries subpoenas; when subpoenas stall, it sues. Americans who want immigration law enforced fairly and consistently, by the government the Constitution put in charge of it, have good reason to hope the court keeps that line clear.
Sources
- [1]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [3]The Center SquareNew Jersey sues Homeland Security over Delaney Hall detaineesOpens in a new tab ↗
- [4]New Jersey MonitorNJ cannot ban companies from detaining immigrants, appeals court rulesOpens in a new tab ↗
- [5]The Post MillennialDHS slams frivolous lawsuit from NJ officials seeking full access to Delaney Hall for health sanitation inspectionOpens in a new tab ↗
- [6]Jonathan TurleyFederal Inspection Reportedly Finds Delaney Hall in Compliance on Virtually All StandardsOpens in a new tab ↗
Have you ever been censored or shadow-banned on social media?
- Yes
- I think so
- No
- I'm not on social media
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.