‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Sports

Warren Over Metcalf, Goedert as a Sleeper and Fade the Quarterbacks: Abby's Fantasy Plan for Steelers-Eagles

Joe Milton starts for the 2-7 Eagles against a stingy Pittsburgh defense, Michael Pittman Jr. nears a return and Nick Herbig's status hangs over the 6-3 Steelers.

By ABBY LAWSONStaff Correspondent · PENNSYLVANIA · Nov 20, 12:15 PM · 4 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic still life on a kitchen table on a gray November Sunday morning: a leather football, a notepad with blank lineup boxes and a pencil, a tablet with a blurred glowing screen, a steaming mug of coffee…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

If you are looking for a shootout to carry your fantasy week, Sunday's meeting between the 6-3 Pittsburgh Steelers and the 2-7 Philadelphia Eagles is probably not it. Philadelphia is trying to snap a seven-game losing streak with young quarterback Joe Milton under center, Pittsburgh's defense has been stingy all year, and the experts expect a grind.

That does not mean there is nothing here for your lineup. It means you have to be choosy. Here is how I would handle every relevant player in this one.

The quarterbacks: look elsewhere

Eagles coach Nick Sirianni has named Milton his Week 11 starter. NBC Sports' fantasy desk advises avoiding him in most leagues because of the matchup, noting that Pittsburgh has allowed the eighth-fewest fantasy points and the seventh-fewest passing touchdowns to opposing quarterbacks this season. FantasyLife ranks Milton as its QB18 and lists him as a sit.

Milton may still have some value in deeper leagues or 2QB and superflex formats, where any starting quarterback carries a usable floor. In a standard 12-team league, though, he should be on your bench.

The same goes for Aaron Rodgers. NFL.com lists Pittsburgh's veteran as a sit this week and projects the game as a low-scoring, run-first affair. Rodgers can still make every throw, but a game script built around the run is not where you want to chase quarterback points.

My call: sit both quarterbacks unless you are desperate in a two-quarterback league.

Running backs: Jaylen Warren is the play

If you are going to invest in one player from this game, make it Jaylen Warren. FantasyLife ranks the Steelers running back as its RB12 and lists him as a start. If the game unfolds the way most analysts expect, with both teams leaning on the ground game, Pittsburgh's lead back should see plenty of work as both a runner and a receiver.

On the other side, FantasyLife also lists Saquon Barkley as a start, though at a more modest RB20. Barkley is still the most talented player on the Philadelphia offense, but he is part of an offense on a seven-game losing streak. I would treat him as a solid RB2 rather than a locked-in star this week.

Pass catchers: one sleeper, a lot of caution

The tight end I like here is Dallas Goedert. FantasyLife calls him a sleeper at TE17, and in a game where the Eagles may need short, safe throws to move the chains, Goedert is the kind of target a young quarterback leans on. If you are streaming tight ends, he is a reasonable choice.

DeVonta Smith is on track to play after appearing on this week's injury report, according to Bleeding Green Nation. If he is active, he is a flex option at best given the matchup and the quarterback situation. Dontayvion Wicks missed the three games before the Eagles' bye with an ankle injury, though Sirianni sounded optimistic about getting him back this week, according to PhillyVoice. Even if Wicks plays, I would leave him on the bench.

For Pittsburgh, FantasyLife ranks DK Metcalf as its WR31 and leans toward sitting him. I agree: he is a boom-or-bust flex in deeper leagues, not a must-start. FantasyLife does like the slot matchup for Germie Bernard, which makes him an interesting dart throw in deeper formats.

Then there is Michael Pittman Jr. He returned to full practice on Thursday, but he is still on injured reserve with his 21-day practice window open, so the Steelers have not activated him yet. Still Curtain called it a good bet he will be activated and play Sunday. If he is on your bench, hold him. Just do not start him until the activation is official.

Defenses and IDP: watch Nick Herbig

The biggest injury question in this game is on Pittsburgh's defense. Outside linebacker Nick Herbig missed a second straight practice on Thursday with hip and rib injuries. If he cannot go, Jack Sawyer would likely step into his role, with T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith also expected to take on more snaps. IDP managers who roster Herbig should have a backup plan ready.

On the Eagles' side, linebacker Zack Baun did not practice Thursday because of a back injury, according to PhillyVoice. If you start him in an IDP league, keep an eye on Friday's final report.

As for team defenses, the Steelers are my favorite streaming option from this game. A young quarterback on a seven-game skid, facing a unit that has made life hard for opposing passers all year, is a recipe for sacks and turnovers, even if Herbig sits.

Abby's bottom line

Start Warren. Consider Barkley and Goedert. Stream the Steelers defense if you need one. Sit both quarterbacks, keep Metcalf and the Eagles' receivers on your bench in most leagues, and hold Pittman until he is activated.

Final injury designations come out Friday afternoon, so check back before you lock anything in. And if you have not joined one yet, the free Liberty Bell Fantasy games are waiting at /fantasy. Good luck this week, and play it smart.

Sources

  1. NBC Sports: Joe Milton announced as Eagles' Week 11 starter (link)
  2. FantasyLife: Philadelphia Eagles vs. Pittsburgh Steelers Fantasy Football Matchup Breakdown For Week 11 (link)
  3. NFL.com: NFL Fantasy 2026 Start 'Em, Sit 'Em: Quarterbacks for Week 11 (link)
  4. Still Curtain: Steelers get welcome Michael Pittman Jr. update, but Nick Herbig is another story (link)
  5. Bleeding Green Nation: Eagles Injury Report: DeVonta Smith on track to play against Steelers (link)
  6. PhillyVoice: Eagles-Steelers Week 11 injury report, with analysis (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageSportsTurn the pagePaid to Stay Home: The 7-2 Broncos Lock Up Cornerback Riley…