Sports
Patience, With a Plan: The 7-2 Chiefs Work Out Matt Prater as Andy Reid Keeps Faith in Harrison Butker
Seven missed field goals have Kansas City looking at kickers again, but the job still belongs to Butker as Arizona comes to Arrowhead on Sunday.
By DARNELL HAYESStaff Correspondent · MISSOURI · Nov 17, 9:20 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
The Kansas City Chiefs brought in another veteran kicker on Tuesday, working out 42-year-old Matt Prater as Harrison Butker's hard season drags on. The tryout does not mean a change has been made. No deal was reported, and for now the job still belongs to Butker.
Still, the message from Arrowhead is hard to miss. With a 7-2 record and a share of first place in the AFC West, the Chiefs are not going to let one position sink a season that has real January promise.
How It Got Here
Butker has missed seven field goals this year, the most of his career. Bleacher Report counts him at 12 of 19, and KCTV5 noted that a success rate of about 63 percent puts him near the bottom among the league's active kickers.
The low point came on Nov. 8 at Arrowhead against the Jets. Butker missed a 56-yard try just before halftime, got a second chance when New York was flagged for being offside, and then missed again from 51 yards. The home crowd booed, and the next day Andy Reid declined to commit to his kicker beyond the short term.
Kansas City had already started building a safety net. Veteran Justin Tucker has been on the practice squad since late October. Now Prater, who has not kicked for any team this season but made 18 of his 20 field goal attempts for Buffalo in 2025, has had his turn in front of the coaches. That gives the Chiefs two experienced options sitting just off the active roster, and it tells you how seriously the front office is taking the problem.
Reid Stands by His Man
For all the noise, Reid has not blinked in public. Before last Sunday's trip to Atlanta, the coach said plainly, "I'm gonna stick with Butker this week", and he kept his word.
It turned out to be a quiet afternoon for the kicking unit. Patrick Mahomes threw five touchdown passes, completing 22 of 35 throws for 348 yards, and every one of Kansas City's points came on a touchdown in a 35-13 rout of the Falcons. The win lifted the Chiefs to 7-2 and pulled them into a tie with Denver for the division lead.
That standing is the backdrop for Tuesday's workout. A contender cannot afford to lose a playoff game on a missed kick, and Kansas City's coaches know it. But a tryout and a game are two different things. Splitting the uprights on a quiet weekday is one test; making a 50-yarder with the crowd on its feet and the season on the line is another, and no workout can settle that question.
Darnell's Take
There is something old-fashioned and right about the way Reid is handling this. He has not thrown his kicker under the bus, and he has not pretended the misses aren't happening. He is giving a proven professional the chance to work his way out of a slump, while doing the responsible thing and making sure the team is ready if that doesn't happen.
That is how good organizations treat people. Loyalty and accountability are not opposites; the best locker rooms hold both at the same time. A coach who stands by a man in a hard stretch tends to get that loyalty paid back, and Butker has earned a measure of patience from the people who know his work best.
But patience has limits, and the Chiefs' moves show exactly where they are. With Tucker on the practice squad and Prater's workout now on tape, Butker knows the margin for error is thin. The best answer he can give is the simplest one: a clean afternoon or two.
What Comes Next
The Chiefs host Arizona on Sunday. Watch the first long field goal attempt closely. If Butker drills it, the conversation quiets down for a week. If he misses, Reid will face the same question again, this time with two veteran options in plain view.
Either way, Kansas City sits at 7-2 and in the thick of the AFC race. A kicker's slump is a real problem, but in Kansas City it is the kind of problem a lot of teams around the league would gladly trade for.
Sources
- Bleacher Report: Matt Prater Has Chiefs Tryout Amid Harrison Butker's Struggles, Justin Tucker Contract (link)
- Newsweek: Chiefs Work Out Kicker Amid Harrison Butker's Ongoing Struggles (link)
- KCTV5: Reid non-committal on Butker's future after another missed field goal (link)
- ESPN: Chiefs sticking with struggling Butker as kicker vs. Falcons, Reid says (link)
- KSHB: 5 takeaways: Chiefs clip Falcons' wings, improve to 7-2 with victory in Atlanta (link)
- ESPN: Mahomes throws 5 TD passes and rookie Johnson runs for 101 yards as Chiefs overwhelm Falcons 35-13 (link)
— 30 —


