Sports
Back to the Sophomore: Michigan Reportedly Turns to Bryce Underwood Again for Senior Day Against Unbeaten UCLA
After freshman Tommy Carr went 1-3 as the starter, the 5-5 Wolverines will start Underwood against the 10-0, fourth-ranked Bruins at 3:30 p.m. Eastern, according to multiple reports.
By WADE MCALLISTERStaff Correspondent · MICHIGAN · Nov 21, 12:20 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Michigan is going back to the young man it built its future around. With unbeaten, fourth-ranked UCLA coming to Ann Arbor for Senior Day, the Wolverines will start sophomore Bryce Underwood at quarterback, CBS Sports reported, citing sources. ESPN also reported, citing sources, that Michigan is expected to turn back to Underwood for Saturday's game.
Kickoff at Michigan Stadium is set for 3:30 p.m. Eastern on CBS.
How Michigan Got Here
Underwood lost the starting job after the Penn State game, and freshman Tommy Carr has started every game since, going 1-3 in that stretch, according to CBS Sports. Head coach Kyle Whittingham declared the job open again this week, with the offense also adjusting to a change at coordinator after Jason Beck's departure, CBS Sports reported.
The numbers explain why the competition never really settled. Underwood and Carr have combined to throw nine interceptions against seven touchdown passes this season, Field Level Media noted in its preview. Michigan arrives at 5-5 after back-to-back losses to Michigan State and Oregon.
There is one note of caution in the reporting. Yahoo Sports, citing The Victors Report, said Underwood is set to take back the starting role, but that it is not yet clear whether he will take most of the snaps or whether Carr will rotate in. Newsweek described the week as another turn in a quarterback story that has moved back and forth all season. Michigan had not made a public announcement in the reports, so the first snap will be the real answer.
The Bruins Bring a Perfect Record
UCLA has no such questions. The Bruins are 10-0 and ranked fourth, and Ty Dieffenbach will start again at quarterback, according to Field Level Media, which noted that half of UCLA's 10 wins have come with him under center. That is the mark of a team that has learned to win more than one way, and with more than one quarterback.
For UCLA, a trip to the Big House is not a trap game in the usual sense. It is a chance to prove, in one of the sport's most famous buildings, that a perfect record belongs in the national title conversation. Lose here, and every doubter of the Bruins' schedule gets a fresh talking point. Win, and the doubters run out of room.
Wade's Take: Let the Young Man Play
I like this decision, and I would like it even if it does not work on Saturday.
Quarterbacks grow up by playing. Underwood has taken his lumps this season, and Michigan's offense around him has not always helped. But there is a difference between protecting a young player and parking him on the bench while the season slips away. At 5-5, Michigan is one win from bowl eligibility. There is no better time to find out what a talented sophomore has learned than a Senior Day afternoon against an unbeaten team, with the home crowd behind him.
There is also something to be said for how Carr handled a tough assignment. A freshman asked to steady a program in a rough November deserves credit for stepping in, and nothing in the reporting suggests he will not have a role going forward.
What Michigan needs most from Underwood is simple: take care of the football. Nine interceptions between two quarterbacks is the kind of number that loses big games. If Underwood can avoid the giveaways, lean on a strong home crowd and make a few plays with his arm and his legs, the Wolverines have a chance to spoil a perfect season.
If he cannot, Michigan still learns something important about its future, and that is worth knowing before the offseason arrives.
What Comes Next
For UCLA, a win keeps the perfect season alive and strengthens a playoff resume heading into the final stretch. For Michigan, a win would mean bowl eligibility, a much-needed jolt after two straight losses and, perhaps, the answer to the question that has hung over the program all season.
Either way, the sophomore gets his shot. In college football, that is how futures are made.
Sources
- CBS Sports: Michigan goes back to Bryce Underwood: Wolverines make QB change ahead of showdown with No. 4 UCLA (link)
- ESPN: Sources - Michigan expected to start Bryce Underwood vs. UCLA (link)
- Yahoo Sports: Michigan Makes New Bryce Underwood QB Decision (link)
- Field Level Media: No. 4 UCLA looks to remain perfect against struggling Michigan (link)
- Michigan Athletics: Michigan Monday: Game 11 vs. No. 4 UCLA (link)
- Newsweek: Michigan's QB Situation Takes Another Turn Ahead Of UCLA Game (link)
— 30 —


