Elections
The 'Decoy Dan' Probe Moves Up the Ladder: Investigators Turn Toward the Peltola Campaign, the DSCC and a Top Democratic Lawyer
The civil fight over Alaska's count is over, but the criminal case over a look-alike candidate is widening, with target letters, hundreds of subpoenas and dozens of agents.
By SOPHIA REYESStaff Correspondent · ALASKA · Nov 21, 11:31 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
The Justice Department's criminal investigation into the second Dan Sullivan who appeared on Alaska's U.S. Senate ballot is shifting its focus toward Democrat Mary Peltola's campaign and the Democratic operatives around it, Yahoo News reported. The report said investigators are now concentrating on the campaign, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee and outside political consultants, citing a person familiar with the matter.
The development comes days after the department dropped its civil lawsuit over the certification of the race, a case it said had become moot once Peltola won outright. Ending that suit did not end the government's interest in how the ballot came together. If anything, the criminal side is getting bigger.
Target Letters and a Familiar Name
Marc Elias, the longtime Democratic election lawyer whose firm represents the Peltola campaign, received one of about 20 target letters the department has sent in the Alaska investigation, CBS News reported, citing sources. At least one official at the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee was also among the intended recipients, according to CBS and the Election Law Blog.
A target letter tells a person that prosecutors view him as a likely subject of charges. It is not an indictment, and it does not mean charges will follow. No one has been charged in the case.
The Peltola campaign has denied taking part in any effort to recruit spoiler candidates for the Alaska ballot, CBS News reported.
The Size of the Effort
This is not a small inquiry. More than 200 subpoenas have been issued in the investigation into the candidacy of Dan J. Sullivan, who ran against Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan, the Washington Examiner reported. Fox News reported that at least 50 FBI agents and more than a dozen Justice Department lawyers are working the case.
The department had sued Alaska's election officials on Oct. 22, after President Trump ordered the case, seeking to hold up certification while the courts weighed the confusion two Dan Sullivans could cause, Newsweek reported. After Peltola's win, the department moved to drop it, Newsweek reported.
Why It Matters
Alaskans have already had their say at the ballot box, and nothing in this investigation changes the result. Peltola won. But the integrity of how candidates get on a ballot is a separate question from who won, and it matters for every election that follows.
If a campaign, a party committee or paid consultants went looking for a man with the same name as an incumbent senator and put him on the ballot to siphon votes, that is not clever politics. It is an attempt to win by confusing voters rather than persuading them. Both parties should want that question answered, and answered by evidence rather than by press releases.
That cuts both ways. Democrats are right that a target letter is not a conviction, and everyone named deserves the presumption of innocence. Republicans are right that the scale of the effort, more than 200 subpoenas and dozens of agents, signals that investigators believe there is something to find. The fair course is to let the process run, in court, under the rules.
What Comes Next
The questions now are whether the investigation produces charges, against whom, and how quickly. The people who received target letters may be invited to answer questions before a grand jury or to offer their side to prosecutors. Elias, who has spent years in court fighting Republican election rules, now finds himself on the other side of an investigation.
For Alaska voters, the lesson is already clear. Read the ballot carefully, and expect the people who run campaigns in your state to compete on ideas. Whatever the investigators find, the state's voters deserve elections where the names on the ballot belong to real candidates running real campaigns, not to decoys.
Sources
- Yahoo News: DOJ Alaska Senate race investigation shifts focus toward Peltola campaign and Democratic operatives (link)
- CBS News: Democratic attorney and Trump foe Marc Elias is a target of DOJ's Alaska ballot investigation, sources say (link)
- Fox News: DOJ investigation into Sen.-elect Mary Peltola spans 50 FBI agents (link)
- Washington Examiner: DOJ issues more than 200 subpoenas in Alaska 'Decoy Dan' investigation as Peltola wins (link)
- Newsweek: Trump DOJ Abruptly Drops 'Two Sullivans' Alaska Fight After Peltola Win (link)
- Election Law Blog: Justice Department Sending Target Letters in Alaska Criminal Probe, Including to DSCC and Democratic Lawyer Marc Elias (link)
— 30 —


