Pushback
Telling Your Own Story Is Not a Crime: Why Europe's Ex-LGBT Christians Are Right to Say No to a Conversion-Practices Ban
As Brussels weighs urging all 27 EU nations to outlaw 'conversion practices,' a Maltese man tried for three years over an interview about his own life is warning lawmakers what such laws really reach.
By MARGARET CALLAHANStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 21, 11:31 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Matthew Grech spent three years as a defendant because he told an interviewer the story of his own life. Now the Maltese Christian, together with other men and women who once identified as LGBT and later embraced the Christian faith, has gone to Brussels to ask the European Parliament not to repeat Malta's mistake across the whole continent, The Christian Post reported.
What Brussels Is Proposing
It is only fair to begin with what the European Union itself says. The European Commission's LGBTIQ equality strategy for 2026 to 2030, unveiled in October 2025, names protecting LGBTIQ people from "conversion practices" as one of its key areas, and says the Commission will consider measures, including a citizens' initiative that calls for a ban. The Commission is preparing to adopt a recommendation in 2027 urging member states to ban such practices, Harbinger's Daily reported.
Supporters describe these bans as protection against coercive and abusive treatment, and nobody should defend abuse. No one should be shamed, threatened or forced into anything. That is not what the Christians in Brussels are defending.
What These Laws Actually Reach
Grech's case shows the problem. Malta's law put him on trial for three years over an interview about his own experience, the Christian Post reported. He was found not guilty in March 2026 after the long legal battle, the Christian Post reported in earlier coverage. He won, but the process was the punishment: three years of hearings and legal bills for describing his own faith journey in public.
That is the danger of laws written around a vague term like "conversion practices." The words can stretch to cover a pastor's sermon, a counselor's conversation, a mother's prayer or a believer's testimony. The ex-LGBT Christians who spoke in Brussels warned that an EU-wide ban could criminalize pastoral counseling and personal testimony, according to the Christian Post.
Personal testimony is not a side issue for Christians. It is at the heart of the faith. The apostle Paul, writing to the church at Corinth, listed the lives his readers had once lived and then told them, "And such were some of you" (1 Corinthians 6:11). Christians have been telling the story of how God changed them for two thousand years. A law that makes that story a crime is a law against the gospel itself.
America Has Already Answered This Question
Americans do not have to guess how this conflict should be resolved, because our highest court just decided it. On March 31, 2026, the Supreme Court ruled 8-1 in Chiles v. Salazar that Colorado's ban on conversion therapy for minors could not be applied to a Christian counselor's talk therapy without facing the First Amendment's toughest scrutiny, CBS News reported. Justice Neil Gorsuch, writing for the majority, said the state could not escape the First Amendment by relabeling a counselor's speech as treatment, Axios reported. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson was the lone dissenter.
The principle is simple and it is right. Government can punish real abuse and fraud. It cannot pick a side in a conversation between a willing client and a counselor, or silence a citizen describing his own life, because it dislikes the viewpoint being expressed.
Who Is Saying No
The pushback is coming from the people these laws claim to protect. Grech and the others who traveled to Brussels are not activists for someone else's cause. They are telling lawmakers that they made their own choices, that they are at peace, and that they should be free to say so, the Christian Post and Harbinger's Daily reported. Their courage deserves a hearing.
Europe's churches have their own stake in the outcome. A recommendation from Brussels would put pressure on every member state, and laws like Malta's show how quickly the target moves from coercive treatment to ordinary speech and prayer.
What Comes Next
The Commission's move toward a 2027 recommendation gives European lawmakers time to listen. They should start with Matthew Grech, who knows exactly what it costs when the state decides that a man's account of his own faith is a crime.
Americans should watch closely. Ideas that start in European capitals tend to show up in American statehouses a few years later. Thanks to the Supreme Court, the First Amendment stands in the way here. The best way to keep it that way is to remember why it matters: freedom of speech and freedom of religion protect the believer telling his story just as surely as they protect everyone else.
Sources
- The Christian Post: Ex-LGBT Christians warn EU ban could criminalize pastoral counseling, personal testimony (link)
- European Commission: Free love, free be: EU's new LGBTIQ strategy (link)
- Harbinger's Daily: An 'Outrageous' Breach Of Freedoms: Ex-LGBT Christians Urge European Parliament To Oppose 'Conversion Practices' Ban (link)
- The Christian Post: Christian man prosecuted for ex-gay testimony found not guilty after 3-year battle (link)
- CBS News: Supreme Court rules against Colorado's conversion therapy ban on First Amendment grounds (link)
- Axios: Supreme Court rejects Colorado's conversion therapy ban (link)
— 30 —


