Pushback
Washington State Fined Meta $35 Million Over Political-Ad Paperwork. The First Amendment Deserves the Last Word
The state calls its law a tool for transparency. Its own record shows the burden helped push political ads off the platforms, and the Supreme Court now has a chance to weigh in.
By LAUREN PIERCEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 19, 7:00 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Meta, the parent company of Facebook and Instagram, has asked the U.S. Supreme Court to hear its challenge to a Washington state law that requires social media companies to answer public requests for information about the political advertisements shown on their platforms, The Hill reported. In a petition docketed Wednesday, the company called the law "virtually unprecedented" and argued that it violates the First Amendment.
The stakes are not small. A King County judge found that Meta violated the law 822 times and that the violations were intentional. The court imposed the $10,000 maximum for each violation and tripled it, producing about $24.7 million in penalties, and then added about $10.5 million in attorney's fees and costs, for a total of roughly $35 million.
What Washington Says
State officials have defended the law as a matter of election transparency, arguing that voters deserve to know who is paying for political ads and whom those ads are aimed at. That is a reasonable goal. Disclosure has a long and honorable place in American campaign law, and the Supreme Court has upheld many disclosure rules over the years.
Then-Attorney General Bob Ferguson brought the case and sought the maximum penalty. Washington's Supreme Court upheld the judgment this year, ruling that the law did not place an undue burden on Meta.
What the Record Shows
The problem is not disclosure itself. It is who is being forced to do it, and what happened when they were.
Washington's rule reaches past the campaigns themselves. It turns the platforms that carry political speech into on-demand records offices, obligated to answer requests from any member of the public about the ads they ran. Meta argues that a third-party regime that burdensome does not produce more disclosure at all; it shuts down channels for political speech.
The state's own history with the company supports that point. After Washington first sued Facebook in 2018, the company said it would stop selling political ads in the state rather than try to comply, GeekWire reported. The state later accused Facebook of continuing to sell ads to political committees anyway, which led to the second lawsuit and the penalty now on appeal.
Whatever one thinks of Meta, and conservatives have plenty of reasons to be wary of Big Tech, that sequence should worry anyone who cares about open debate. When a law makes it more attractive for a platform to refuse political ads than to carry them, the people who lose most are not trillion-dollar companies. They are school board candidates, local ballot campaigns and grassroots groups that cannot afford television.
What Other Courts Have Said
Washington is not the first state to try this. In 2019, a unanimous panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, in an opinion by Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson III, ruled against a Maryland law that required online platforms to publish information about political ad buyers and keep records for state inspection. The court said Maryland's aims were important but that the state had gone about them in a way that burdened political speech too heavily, and it raised serious concerns about forcing publishers to speak.
The challengers in that case included The Washington Post and other newspapers. The First Amendment's protection for political speech does not depend on whether the publisher is a newspaper or a website.
Washington's own high court was not unanimous either. The justices could not form a majority on how the penalty was calculated, and three of them concluded that the penalty violated the Eighth Amendment's ban on excessive fines, Courthouse News reported.
What Comes Next
Meta is asking the Supreme Court to rule that the law cannot survive First Amendment scrutiny, and it is also challenging the size of the penalty under the Excessive Fines Clause. The state will have a chance to respond before the justices decide whether to take the case.
If they do, the question will be one that matters well beyond one company: can a state make the carriers of political speech do the government's disclosure work, under threat of crushing fines, when the predictable result is less political speech? The Fourth Circuit's answer in 2019 was no. Voters in Washington and every other state deserve a clear answer from the Supreme Court, and the Constitution points toward the same one.
Sources
- The Hill: Meta brings fight over Washington state campaign ad law to Supreme Court (link)
- Courthouse News Service: Washington Supreme Court upholds $35 million penalty against Meta (link)
- Washington State Office of the Attorney General: AG Ferguson seeks maximum $24.6M penalty against Facebook parent Meta (link)
- GeekWire: Facebook parent Meta fined $24.6M for violating Washington state's political ad disclosure law (link)
- Justia: The Washington Post v. McManus, No. 19-1132 (4th Cir. 2019) (link)
- Yakima Herald-Republic: Meta asks U.S. Supreme Court to toss Washington's campaign finance law (link)
— 30 —


