‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

Oversight Has Limits: The Constitution Won't Let Jeffries Investigate 'Everyone' in MAGA

The incoming speaker promised probes of an undefined movement. The Supreme Court has said for nearly 70 years that Congress investigates to legislate, not to expose or punish.

By BENJAMIN STONEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 19, 6:39 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: An empty wood-paneled congressional hearing room in a House office building, a long witness table with a single microphone and an empty chair, a tall stack of blank file folders under a brass desk lamp, a rolled parchment…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries, chosen by his caucus this week to be the next speaker, says his party is prepared to investigate "everyone" tied to what he described as the MAGA extremist movement once Democrats take control of the House in January, The Hill reported.

Jeffries made the comments Wednesday night in an interview with Jen Psaki on MS NOW, according to a transcript released by his office. He said those who have been part of the movement should be ready to answer questions about the damage he blames on it. Asked about specific figures, he declined to name anyone and said decisions about particular investigations would fall to committee Democrats, including Rep. Jamie Raskin of Maryland on the Judiciary Committee and Rep. Robert Garcia of California on the Oversight Committee. He did not say who counts as a "MAGA extremist".

A Movement Is Not a Target

Let's be fair to the incoming speaker. Democrats won the House, and the gavel comes with real oversight power. Both parties have used it, sometimes well and sometimes badly. Nobody should expect a new majority to sit on its hands.

But "everyone" in a political movement is not an oversight target. It is millions of Americans who went to rallies, knocked on doors, gave to campaigns, posted online and voted. A promise to investigate a movement, with no definition of who belongs to it, is not a plan to fix a law. It is a warning to the other side.

What the Supreme Court Has Said

The Constitution answers this question, and it has for a long time. In Watkins v. United States in 1957, the Supreme Court reviewed the contempt conviction of a labor organizer who refused to tell a House committee about other people's past ties to the Communist Party. The Court threw out his conviction.

Chief Justice Earl Warren's opinion is blunt. Congress has "no general authority to expose the private affairs of individuals" unless the inquiry serves a legitimate function of Congress, he wrote. Congress is not a law enforcement or trial agency, the Court said, and investigations meant to punish the people being investigated cannot be defended. The Court also made clear that the Bill of Rights, including the freedoms of speech and assembly, applies to congressional investigations just as it applies to laws.

Notice who was protected in that case: a man of the left, questioned by a committee hunting for Communists. The principle did not belong to one party then, and it does not belong to one party now. It protects any American hauled before a committee because of his politics.

The Court returned to the subject in 2020 in Trump v. Mazars, when House committees subpoenaed the president's personal financial records. Writing for a 7-2 majority, Chief Justice John Roberts said a congressional subpoena is valid only if it is "related to, and in furtherance of, a legitimate task of the Congress". The Court rejected both the House's claim that its subpoenas deserved the deference given to routine ones and the president's call for a far stricter test, sent the case back and told lower courts to weigh whether Congress really needed the information for legislation, whether the subpoena was broader than necessary, what evidence showed a valid legislative purpose and what burden it placed on the president.

Put those two rulings together and the rule is simple. Congress investigates to legislate. It may not investigate to expose, to punish or to settle political scores.

Who Draws the Line

The White House is already preparing. A memo from the White House counsel requires executive branch agencies to get approval before their employees agree to testify before congressional committees, PBS News reported. That is the opening move in the familiar give-and-take between the branches, and the courts will referee any fight that follows under the Mazars test.

Private citizens who receive a subpoena keep their constitutional rights too, including the ones the Court spelled out in Watkins. A subpoena that cannot be tied to a real legislative purpose is open to challenge.

Jeffries left the details to his committee leaders. They will have to explain, subpoena by subpoena, what law they are trying to write. If they can do that, they will be doing their jobs. If the goal is to make an example of a movement, the Constitution and the courts stand in the way.

Voters handed Democrats the House. They did not hand them a warrant to investigate their neighbors. The best use of a new majority is the one the Founders intended: hearings that lead to laws on the problems families actually face, with the Bill of Rights respected for every American, whatever his politics.

Sources

  1. The Hill: Jeffries warns Democrats ready to investigate 'everyone' in 'MAGA extremist movement' (link)
  2. Office of the House Democratic Leader: Speaker-Designate Jeffries on MS NOW: 'We've got to make meaningful, dramatic, decisive progress' (link)
  3. TheWrap: Hakeem Jeffries Has a Warning for 'MAGA Extremists' After Securing Speaker Nomination (link)
  4. Cornell Law School LII: Watkins v. United States, 354 U.S. 178 (1957) (link)
  5. Cornell Law School LII: Trump v. Mazars USA, LLP (2020) (link)
  6. PBS News: Read the full White House memo requiring agencies to get approval before testifying in front of Congress (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageWashington State Fined Meta $35 Million Over Political-Ad…Turn the pageWhy Federal Law Says No to Keeping 'Gender Support Plans'…