‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

Voters Said Protect Girls' Sports. Colorado's New Guidance Shouldn't Turn That Promise Into Words on Paper

The state education department tells schools they need not verify a student's sex to comply with Proposition 134, and warns that even parent affirmations could raise constitutional problems. Here is why families are pushing back.

By REBECCA HARTMANStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 22, 2:03 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: A high school girls' track in Colorado at sunrise, empty starting blocks lined up on a red rubber track with fresh white lane lines, a pair of running spikes and a water bottle resting by lane one, the Rocky Mountain Front…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Colorado voters approved Proposition 134 this month, requiring school sports teams to be designated for boys, girls or both. Now the state's education department has told every school district how to comply, and its answer has left many of the measure's supporters asking how the law is supposed to work at all.

What the State Said

Proposition 134 passed on Nov. 3, and The Associated Press called the race with 52% of voters in favor, Colorado Newsline reported. The measure requires sports teams sponsored by schools and athletic associations to be designated for male, female or co-ed participation.

This past week, the Colorado Department of Education sent districts a guidance document saying a school can show compliance by adopting a policy consistent with the law, The Center Square reported. The guidance does not require schools to verify a student's biological sex, and it discourages what it calls intrusive eligibility checks. According to Chalkbeat, the guidance says physical exams, genetic testing, parent affirmations or medical documentation about a student's sex could violate students' constitutional rights. Colorado Public Radio reported that districts were told not to inspect students' bodies or question them about intimate medical information.

The Center Square noted that the department offered no specific direction on how schools should actually determine eligibility, and that the department declined to comment further. RedState, citing the document, reported that schools will not be required to set up a complaint process for alleged violations. Chalkbeat observed that state officials are plainly not reading Proposition 134 the way its supporters do.

Why the Guidance Misses the Mark

No one in this debate wants coaches inspecting children's bodies, and the guidance is right to rule that out. But there is a wide space between an invasive exam and doing nothing. The department's warning reaches all the way to a simple parent affirmation, a signed statement from a mother or father that most families would consider the least intrusive step imaginable. If a parent's word is off the table, it is fair to ask what is left.

Students who want to play school sports in Colorado already submit a doctor-approved physical before joining a team, according to the guidance excerpt RedState reported. Schools routinely collect emergency contacts and medical clearances. A law that voters passed to keep girls' teams for girls should not be the only rule a school is told it cannot practically check.

The constitutional ground is also firmer than the guidance suggests. In June, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled 6-3 in Little v. Hecox and West Virginia v. B.P.J. that states may determine eligibility for girls' and women's sports by biological sex without violating the Equal Protection Clause or Title IX, SCOTUSblog reported. A state that may draw the line by sex can surely take reasonable, respectful steps to make sure the line holds.

Who Is Pushing Back

The families who carried Proposition 134 to victory are not asking for anything exotic. They are asking that a measure a majority of Colorado voters approved be carried out in good faith. The measure assigns enforcement for school districts to the state commissioner of education, not the Colorado High School Activities Association, according to The Center Square. That puts responsibility squarely with state officials, and it means parents and lawmakers know exactly whom to ask for answers.

During the campaign, supporters had pointed to ways of confirming eligibility, including cheek-swab tests, Chalkbeat reported. Colorado Public Radio said it could not reach a leading supporter of the measure for comment on the guidance. Expect that conversation to grow louder as districts write their policies.

What Comes Next

The law takes effect Jan. 1, 2027, and districts must adopt policies designating teams as male, female or co-ed. Between now and then, school boards have a chance to write policies that respect privacy and still keep faith with voters. Parents should show up at those meetings. The girls who will compete on those teams deserve rules that mean what they say.

Sources

  1. Colorado Newsline: Colorado voters approve anti-trans measures on school sports and surgeries for minors (link)
  2. Chalkbeat: Colorado officials: Schools don't have to check student gender to comply with transgender athlete ballot issue (link)
  3. Colorado Public Radio: Schools don't have to check student gender to comply with transgender athlete ballot issue, Colorado officials say (link)
  4. The Center Square (via KPC News): Colorado officials advise school districts on girls' sports (link)
  5. SCOTUSblog: Court rules that states can exclude transgender athletes from girls' and women's sports teams (link)
  6. RedState: Colorado Schools Told to Enforce Girls' Sports Law Without Checking Biological Sex (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageTax the Choice, Lose the Children: What Britain's VAT on…Turn the pageA Pause, Not a Final Word: What Montana's Sex-Definition…