Pushback
A Pause, Not a Final Word: What Montana's Sex-Definition Ruling Decided, and Why the State Is Right to Keep Defending the Law
A Missoula judge put SB 437 on hold while the case goes on. The law's plain definitions line up with recent U.S. Supreme Court rulings and federal policy, and the final answer is still ahead.
By HAROLD WHITMOREStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 22, 1:15 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
A Missoula County district judge has temporarily blocked Montana from enforcing a 2025 law that writes definitions of "male," "female," "sex" and "gender" into state code, and the state says it will keep defending the law. Here is what the ruling decided, what it did not, and why the case for SB 437 is far from finished.
What the Court Did
Judge Leslie Halligan granted a preliminary injunction last Tuesday in a lawsuit brought by Upper Seven Law on behalf of transgender, intersex and Two Spirit Montanans, the Montana Free Press reported. The order stops enforcement of Senate Bill 437 while the case continues.
SB 437 amended wide-ranging sections of Montana law to define sex according to biological features, including reproductive organs, and to treat gender as having the same meaning as sex rather than relying on gender identity, according to reports on the case. Halligan found the plaintiffs are likely to succeed on claims that the law violates the rights to privacy and equal protection under the Montana Constitution, and she wrote that the state had not shown why such a broad definition was needed when a narrower one could work, the Daily Montanan and KPAX reported.
The 2025 law is similar to a 2023 measure that state courts struck down twice. The state argued that SB 437 is different and does not demand access to anyone's private information; the judge answered that identical wording is not required and that the question is whether the differences change the constitutional analysis, the Daily Montanan reported.
What It Did Not Decide
A preliminary injunction is a prediction, not a verdict. The order does not declare SB 437 unconstitutional; it holds the law in place while the case is argued in full. That distinction matters, because the final ruling, and any appeal to the Montana Supreme Court, will turn on a complete record rather than an early look.
The state has made its position clear. In a statement reported by the Daily Montanan, it said the law codifies a long-recognized, commonsense, immutable and biologically based definition of sex, and that the State of Montana will defend the law its Legislature enacted.
Why the Law Stands on Solid Ground
Defining terms is the ordinary work of a legislature. Statutes on prisons, locker rooms, athletics and vital records all depend on words like "male" and "female." SB 437 gives those words the meaning nearly every generation of Montanans has understood them to carry. Asking lawmakers to leave such basic terms undefined does not protect anyone; it simply hands the definitions to whoever litigates hardest.
The legal landscape has also moved decisively in the law's direction. In June 2025, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld Tennessee's ban on gender-transition drugs for minors in United States v. Skrmetti, ruling 6-3 that the law did not trigger heightened scrutiny under the federal Equal Protection Clause. This June, in the combined cases Little v. Hecox and West Virginia v. B.P.J., the Court ruled 6-3 that states may determine eligibility for girls' and women's sports by biological sex without violating the Equal Protection Clause or Title IX, SCOTUSblog reported.
Federal policy now uses the same plain approach. President Trump's January 2025 executive order directs federal agencies to define sex as "an individual's immutable biological classification as either male or female".
To be fair to the court, Halligan ruled under the Montana Constitution, not the federal one, so the national precedents do not settle the case on their own. But a state constitution that protects privacy should not be read to forbid a state from saying what "male" and "female" mean in its own code. Where the judge worried about breadth, the remedy is careful line-drawing, not a ban on definitions altogether.
What Comes Next
The case now moves toward a full hearing on the merits, with the state committed to defending SB 437. Whatever happens in Missoula, the question is likely to reach the Montana Supreme Court. Montanans who believe the law should say what it means will be watching, and they have the weight of recent national rulings on their side.
Sources
- Montana Free Press: Judge blocks enforcement of Montana's sex-definition bill (link)
- Daily Montanan: Court halts enforcement of law defining sex in Montana code (link)
- KPAX: Missoula judge blocks Montana law defining sex as binary, citing likely constitutional violations (link)
- SCOTUSblog: Court rules that states can exclude transgender athletes from girls' and women's sports teams (link)
- Supreme Court of the United States: United States v. Skrmetti, opinion of the Court (link)
- The White House: Defending Women From Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government (link)
— 30 —


