‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

Voters Beat the Billionaire Without Rewriting the First Amendment: Why Padilla's Plan to Undo Citizens United Misreads the Midterms

The California Democrat promises a democracy where the ultra-wealthy can't buy elections. Elon Musk's own costly midterm shows voters already have the final say.

By BENJAMIN STONEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 19, 10:40 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic still life on a dark wooden desk: an aged parchment document under soft museum light, a simple wooden ballot box with a slot, a brass desk lamp and a small American flag, with the U.S. Capitol dome…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Sen. Alex Padilla of California has a plan for the next Congress, and it starts with the First Amendment. In a post on X on Wednesday, the Democrat promised that his party will do everything it can to deliver "a democracy where the ultra-wealthy can't buy elections," framing the goal as Elon Musk's worst nightmare.

Benzinga reported that Padilla also wants to overturn the Supreme Court's 2010 Citizens United decision, and that his post followed a Senate hearing where he questioned nominees to the Federal Election Commission about enforcing campaign finance law. Padilla warned that the commission has lacked the quorum it needs to enforce those laws since May 2025, according to Benzinga.

That is the claim, stated fairly: big money is buying American elections, and Congress should step in to stop it. The trouble is that the election Americans just held is the best evidence against it.

The Midterms Already Answered the Question

Musk was the biggest name in political giving this cycle. Benzinga cited a New York Times tally estimating his political spending in the midterms at about $474 million, while National Review put the figure at roughly $446 million. Either way, it was a fortune.

And by his own account, it did not buy much. National Review reported that Musk now regrets spending that money to so little effect, and the magazine drew the obvious lesson in its headline: money still can't buy elections. Even the left-leaning New Republic has framed Musk's political spending as a failure to buy elections.

Think about what that means. The richest man in the world spent hundreds of millions of dollars, and voters decided anyway. Democrats, the party Padilla belongs to, will hold both chambers of Congress in January. If the ultra-wealthy could simply purchase outcomes, that is not how this election would have ended. The voters were in charge, as they should be.

What Citizens United Actually Said

Critics often describe Citizens United as a ruling that let corporations buy politicians. That is not what the Court held.

The case began when a nonprofit group was barred from promoting and airing a film critical of a presidential candidate close to an election. In its 2010 opinion, the Supreme Court ruled that the government may not suppress political speech because the speaker is a corporation, and it struck down limits on independent spending by corporations and unions on political messages. The decision did not allow corporations to give unlimited sums directly to candidates; limits on direct contributions remained in place.

The principle at stake is simple. Americans do not lose their right to speak about politics when they band together, whether in a church, a union, a business or an advocacy group. The First Amendment says Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech, and the Court read that command as protecting speech about candidates and elections, the very speech the Founders cared about most.

That protection cuts both ways. The same ruling that protects a conservative group's film protects a liberal group's ads. Restricting it would not just silence one billionaire. It would give whoever holds power in Washington the authority to decide which citizens and groups may spend money to make their case to voters.

A Standard That Only Points One Direction

Townhall noted that Padilla's warning about the ultra-wealthy is aimed squarely at Musk, and argued that the same concern never seems to apply to Democratic megadonors such as the Soros family. That is a fair question for any senator who wants to rewrite the rules of political speech. A principle that only applies to the other side's donors is not a principle. It is a strategy.

There is also a constitutional reality Padilla's post does not mention. Congress cannot overturn a Supreme Court ruling on the meaning of the First Amendment by passing a bill. Only the Court itself or a constitutional amendment can do that, and an amendment requires two-thirds of both houses of Congress and ratification by three-fourths of the states. That high bar is by design. The Founders made the Bill of Rights hard to change so that no temporary majority could trim the freedoms of the minority.

What Comes Next

Padilla's immediate focus, the Federal Election Commission, is a legitimate concern. An agency that cannot reach a quorum cannot enforce the laws already on the books, and confirming qualified commissioners from both parties is a reasonable goal for the Senate.

But enforcing existing law is very different from rewriting the First Amendment. When the new Congress convenes, expect proposals to limit political spending, and expect conservatives, civil liberties groups and the courts to push back.

The best answer to Padilla came from the voters themselves. They heard the ads, weighed the arguments and made up their own minds. That is not a democracy for sale. It is a democracy working exactly as designed.

Sources

  1. Benzinga: Alex Padilla Vows to Make Elon Musk's 'Worst Nightmare Come True' in Next Congress, Targets Billionaire Election Spending and Citizens United (link)
  2. Townhall: Forget Affordability, Sen. Padilla Says the Next Congress Is Going to Do This Instead (link)
  3. National Review: Good News: Money Still Can't Buy Elections (link)
  4. The New Republic: Elon Musk Spirals Over His Failure to Buy Elections (link)
  5. Supreme Court of the United States: Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, 558 U.S. 310 (2010) (link)
  6. Sen. Alex Padilla on X: Post on Elon Musk and the next Congress (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageA Repair Check Is Not a Public Safety Plan: Seattle Keeps…Turn the pageA Court Order Shouldn't Come With an Expiration Date: Why…