‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

Their Voices Were Left Out: Victims' Families Take the Fight Over Newsom's 548 Commutations to the President and California's High Court

Gov. Gavin Newsom says his blanket clemency is lawful. Prosecutors from about half the state's counties, grieving families and the voters' own record say the process skipped the people who matter most.

By HAROLD WHITMOREStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 20, 6:39 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic dusk scene on the granite steps of a classical columned courthouse in San Francisco's Civic Center, a single white rose and a lit memorial candle resting on the top step, a wooden judge's gavel on a…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Gov. Gavin Newsom announced on Nov. 5 that he would change every death sentence in California to life in prison without the possibility of parole. His office puts the number of people affected at 548, and the commutations would not free anyone or overturn any conviction, Yahoo News reported.

The governor's position is that he is acting within his clemency power. His side has argued that a notice provision meant to let victims weigh in does not apply when a governor acts on his own initiative rather than in response to a clemency application, CalMatters reported.

That is the case for the commutations, stated fairly. Here is why so many Californians, and now the President, are saying no.

The Voters Already Answered

Californians have not been silent on this question. In 2016, voters rejected a measure to repeal the death penalty and, on the same ballot, approved a measure meant to speed up the appeals process, NPR reported at the time. Whatever one thinks of capital punishment, the people of California were asked directly, and they chose to keep it and to make it work.

A blanket commutation of every sentence does not refine that decision. It reverses it, by the act of one official, on his way out of office. In a self-governing republic, that should trouble people on every side of the death penalty debate.

The Constitution Gives the Court a Say

California's constitution does not give any governor unchecked clemency power. For people convicted of more than one felony, the state Supreme Court must approve a commutation, and 382 of those on death row have more than one felony conviction, CalMatters reported. Newsom has asked the justices to make their recommendations by the end of the year so he can act before his term ends.

That timeline matters. A decision this large, touching hundreds of cases and hundreds of grieving families, deserves the careful, case-by-case review the constitution contemplates, not a race against the calendar.

Families Deserve to Be Heard

District attorneys representing about 30 of California's 58 counties, joined by a crime victims' advocacy group, have asked the California Supreme Court to block the blanket commutation, CalMatters reported. They argue the governor acted unlawfully by failing to give the families of victims an opportunity to be heard.

Separately, more than two dozen relatives of murder victims have asked the same court to stop the commutations, arguing the governor did not give the legal notice required before acting, CNN reported. These are mothers, fathers, children and siblings who sat through trials, sentencing hearings and years of appeals. Asking that they be heard before the final word is spoken is not cruelty. It is basic fairness.

Mercy is a Christian virtue, and the clemency power exists for real cases of injustice or genuine repentance. But mercy in the biblical sense looks at the person, the crime and the people who were wronged. Clemency granted in bulk, without hearing a single family, is something else.

To be fair to the governor, legal experts told the Los Angeles Times that the prosecutors' challenge faces long odds. That is a reason to make the arguments clearly, not a reason to stop making them.

The President Steps In

President Trump has called the move a "disaster for justice" and said he hopes it will be overturned. He plans to meet next week with families of victims whose killers' sentences would be commuted, the New York Post reported.

What Comes Next

The California Supreme Court must decide whether to take up the petitions, and it must also act on the governor's request for recommendations in the multiple-felony cases. Newsom's term ends in January, which is why he has pressed the justices for an answer by the end of the year. The families and prosecutors are asking the court not to let a deadline set the pace of justice.

However the court rules, the families have already made their point: when the state speaks for the people, it owes the victims a seat at the table.

Sources

  1. New York Post: Trump to meet with victims of Gavin Newsom's death penalty reversal as he blasts gov (link)
  2. CalMatters: Prosecutors ask California Supreme Court to halt Newsom's death penalty commutations (link)
  3. CNN: Families of California murder victims ask state Supreme Court to block governor's commutation of death sentences (link)
  4. Los Angeles Times: Can prosecutors block Newsom's move to wipe out death sentences? It's unlikely, experts say (link)
  5. Yahoo News: Trump Blasts Newsom's Death Row Commutations as 'Disaster for Justice' (link)
  6. NPR: California Voters Decide To Uphold Death Penalty, Streamline The Process (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous page56 Is Not 60, and That's the Point: Why the Senate's Coming…Turn the pageVoters Are Not a Rough Draft: Seattle Schools Now Back a…