Pushback
56 Is Not 60, and That's the Point: Why the Senate's Coming Democratic Majority Should Fix the Floor, Not Kill the Filibuster
As Chris Van Hollen challenges Chuck Schumer and calls the 60-vote rule anti-democratic, a bipartisan rules plan from a Democrat and a Republican shows a better way to make the Senate work.
By DOMINIC KANEStaff Correspondent · ARIZONA · Nov 20, 7:00 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
When the new Senate convenes in January, Democrats will hold 56 seats, after Mary Peltola's win in Alaska made her the chamber's 56th Democrat, the Florida Phoenix reported. It is a big majority. It is not 60, the number needed to end debate on most legislation. And that gap has some Democrats talking again about getting rid of the filibuster.
Sen. Chris Van Hollen of Maryland, who is challenging Chuck Schumer to lead Senate Democrats, backs ending the filibuster but says he would not force the change on his caucus, States Newsroom reported. On Thursday he endorsed a narrower, bipartisan rules package while calling the filibuster anti-democratic, Roll Call reported. "I'm in favor of filibuster reform," he said, according to Roll Call. A spokesperson for Schumer declined to comment on the endorsement.
Other Democrats have gone further in recent weeks. Sen. Ed Markey has said ending the filibuster has to be on the table, Fox News reported.
That is the case they are making, fairly stated. Here is why the facts point the other way.
A Rule Both Parties Have Leaned On
The filibuster is not written into the Constitution. It is a Senate rule, and the 60-vote threshold to cut off debate is what forces the majority to win over at least some members of the minority before most bills can pass. Majorities of both parties have chafed against it when it blocked their priorities, and both have relied on it when they were outnumbered.
The recent history is a warning. In 2013, a Democratic majority under Harry Reid changed the rules so most nominations could be confirmed with a simple majority; in 2017, a Republican majority extended that change to Supreme Court nominees, NPR reported. A shortcut taken by one party became a tool for the other within four years.
Democrats have also tested their own caucus on this before. In January 2022, Sens. Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema refused to support changing the rule to pass a voting bill, even though both said they supported the underlying legislation, Fox News reported.
Even Democrats Are Warning Their Own Side
The most telling objection this year has come from inside the Democratic caucus. Sen. Andy Kim of New Jersey has cautioned that scrapping the filibuster could be a double-edged sword that backfires when Republicans regain control, according to Fox News. He is right. A 56-seat majority feels permanent in November. Senate majorities never are.
The filibuster's real value is not that it stops things. It is that it makes durable laws more likely. A bill that passes with votes from both parties is harder to repeal the next time power changes hands, and less likely to swing the country back and forth every two years.
A Better Way: Fix the Floor
There is a serious alternative already on the table, and it comes from both parties. The package Van Hollen endorsed, written by Democratic Sen. Jeff Merkley and Republican Sen. Steve Daines, would eliminate some procedural steps without lowering the 60-vote threshold, Roll Call reported. It would also give qualifying bipartisan bills that come out of committee faster consideration, reducing the power of party leaders to keep them off the floor.
That is reform conservatives can respect. It attacks gridlock without attacking the minority's voice. Daines has said that putting any rules changes in place would require 67 votes, according to Roll Call, which means it would need real support from both sides, exactly as a change to the Senate's rules should.
What Comes Next
Senate Democrats will choose their leader before the new Congress takes office in January, and the filibuster has become part of that contest. Whoever wins will face pressure from activists to use the new majority to rewrite the rules on day one.
The better choice is to keep the 60-vote rule, adopt bipartisan fixes like Merkley-Daines, and earn the votes. The Senate was built to make the majority persuade. That is not a flaw. It is the design.
Sources
- Roll Call: Van Hollen: Senate rules changes a matter for caucus to decide (link)
- States Newsroom: Running for US Senate leader, Van Hollen backs ending filibuster but wouldn't force it (link)
- Fox News: Democrats eye killing Senate filibuster as lawmaker warns move could be a 'double-edged sword' (link)
- Florida Phoenix: Peltola elected to fill Alaska US Senate seat, becomes Senate's 56th Democrat nationally (link)
- NPR: Senate Democrats plan a vote to change the filibuster. So what is it? (link)
- Fox News: Manchin, Sinema join Republicans to block Democrats' filibuster change (link)
— 30 —


