‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

Still Standing: Why Sheriff-ICE Partnerships Keep Growing Even as AP Spotlights a Few Sheriffs Who Lost

The AP reviewed about 250 sheriff races and found ICE agreements played a role in some defeats. The bigger picture is more than 2,700 agreements nationwide and states moving to require them.

By JACK HOLLISTERStaff Correspondent · INDIANA · Nov 21, 7:00 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: A small-town Southern county courthouse and adjoining sheriff's office at golden hour, a county patrol SUV with no lettering parked out front, an American flag and a blank state-style flag on the pole, a steel jail entrance…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

The Associated Press has a new story about sheriffs who partnered with Immigration and Customs Enforcement and then lost their elections. It is worth reading carefully, because the details tell a more measured story than the headline.

What AP Reported

The AP reviewed about 250 elections held this month for sheriffs whose offices had 287(g) agreements with ICE, and it identified races in Indiana, Maryland, North Carolina, Wisconsin and elsewhere where those partnerships played a role in a candidate's defeat. Its lead example is Alamance County, North Carolina, where Shannon Long, a pastor and former deputy, unseated Republican Sheriff Terry Johnson by 3,181 votes on Nov. 3. Johnson's ICE partnership, and critics' accusations that his office targeted Latino residents, were central to the campaign. Johnson has said his office no longer actively takes part in 287(g), though Alamance is still listed in ICE's database of active agreements.

Long has said he will not join the program, but he has also said he will uphold the law and hold offenders accountable. That is a commitment every sheriff should make, and Alamance voters can hold him to it.

The Rest of the Story

AP's own reporting supplies the context that keeps this from being a national verdict. Many other sheriffs on the ballot ran unopposed, and more than 2,700 287(g) agreements are now in place across the country. Defeats in a handful of states, out of roughly 250 races reviewed, do not amount to a referendum on cooperating with federal immigration law.

The program itself is neither new nor exotic. Congress added Section 287(g) to federal immigration law in 1996, and it lets ICE delegate certain immigration enforcement duties to trained state and local officers who work under federal supervision. In the jail model, deputies check the immigration status of people who have already been arrested and booked into a county jail. A task force model, which allows trained officers to make immigration arrests in the field, has spread widely in Florida.

That is the heart of the matter for most communities. A sheriff who checks the status of someone already in custody on criminal charges is not targeting a neighborhood. He is making sure that a person the federal government is looking for is not simply released back onto the street.

The States Are Moving the Other Way

If voters were turning against these partnerships, state capitals would be backing away. Instead, several are writing cooperation into law.

Florida requires every law enforcement agency that runs a detention facility to enter a 287(g) agreement, and the state leads the nation in agreements largely because of that mandate. As of this summer, 272 of Florida's 394 law enforcement agencies held a task force agreement, according to a July report.

Texas lawmakers passed SB 8, which requires sheriff's offices that operate or contract for a county jail to request and enter a 287(g) agreement by Dec. 1, 2026, and which gives the state attorney general power to act against departments that refuse. By mid-September, 202 of the 232 Texas sheriff's offices covered by the law had an agreement in place.

In North Carolina, the same state where Alamance voters made their choice, the legislature overrode a veto this year to require the State Highway Patrol and the State Bureau of Investigation to take part in 287(g). That law took effect June 24 and does not require local sheriffs to participate.

Federalism Working as Designed

This is how the American system is supposed to work. Congress created the tool. States decide whether to require it. Counties elect sheriffs who answer to local voters. Alamance County made one choice, and Texas and Florida have made another. Nobody's rights are violated when a sheriff and a federal agency agree to share information about people already sitting in a jail cell, under rules Congress wrote three decades ago.

What comes next is a test for the new sheriffs who ran against these partnerships. They promised to keep their communities safe and hold offenders accountable. The public should watch closely whether people charged with serious crimes who are in the country illegally are released or handed over.

Meanwhile, Texas' Dec. 1 deadline arrives in 10 days, and more counties are working to finish their agreements before it. The national map of cooperation is not shrinking. In the states that have chosen it, it is becoming the law of the land.

Sources

  1. WTOP: Voters oust some sheriffs who signed pacts to help Trump's immigration enforcement efforts (link)
  2. The NC Beat: Alamance Sheriff Terry Johnson ICE Ties Cost Him The Election (link)
  3. American Immigration Council: The 287(g) Program: An Overview (link)
  4. KXAN: Texas 287(g) deadline nears as counties seek ICE agreements (link)
  5. UNC School of Government: Legislature Overrides Veto on 287(g) Agreements (link)
  6. WUSF: Sheriffs want more local law enforcement to help ICE. Advocates push back (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageAsk Us First: Why Barnham's 257-to-16 Vote Deserves an…Turn the pageThirty States Said Yes. Why Virginia's Parents and Faith…