‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

World News

Eisenkot Invites Netanyahu's Likud to 'Marathon' Unity Talks. The Hard Question Is Who Would Lead

With his mandate running out next month, Israel's opposition leader opens the door to the right's flagship party. Likud answered within hours with terms of its own, and the gap at the top has not moved.

By DOMINIC KANEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 21, 8:30 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Dawn over Jerusalem: the Knesset building's stone colonnade glowing in early light with Israeli flags on tall poles moving in the wind, and in the foreground a long empty negotiating table set with two facing leather chairs…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Israel's long search for a government took a new turn on Saturday. Gadi Eisenkot, the former military chief who leads the centrist Yashar party, invited Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's right-wing Likud to what his party called a "marathon series of talks," beginning Sunday, France 24 reported. Yashar said the move reflected a commitment to forming the broadest possible government.

It is a notable offer from a man whose camp has spent weeks trying to replace Netanyahu. It also raises the question that every Israeli voter, and every American friend of Israel, should be asking: can a unity government be built when both sides still insist on leading it?

How Israel Got Here

The Oct. 27 election left neither bloc with the 61 seats needed for a majority in the 120-seat Knesset, Al Jazeera reported, and Arab-led parties lined up behind Eisenkot's bid early in the process. Eisenkot now holds the mandate to try to form a government, and his time runs out next month.

He has already sketched his fallback. The Times of Israel reported that Eisenkot plans to bring a government to a Knesset vote before his mandate ends, even without a majority. France 24 reported he is prepared to put forward a minority national emergency government if efforts at a broad coalition fail.

Likud's Answer

Likud replied the same day with conditions. The Jerusalem Post reported the party wants an end to what it called personal attacks and incitement against Netanyahu, an end to political boycotts of the prime minister and his government, and a joint declaration committing to a unity government without the participation of Arab parties.

The two camps have been here before. Ynet reported that after an earlier round of unity talks, Netanyahu and Eisenkot remained at odds, with each side insisting on leading the next government, while former Prime Minister Naftali Bennett sent an envoy to the table. Ynet also reported claims from Eisenkot's bloc that Netanyahu has demanded a full four-year term and no state commission of inquiry into the Oct. 7 attack. Those claims came from Eisenkot's side. Likud's own published terms, as The Jerusalem Post reported them, center on ending the attacks and boycotts aimed at Netanyahu.

The Hard Questions

The first is the simplest. Who would be prime minister? A unity government with two leaders who each insist on the top job is not a government. It is a standoff with a cabinet. Unless one side yields, or the two agree on a rotation, Sunday's marathon may end where the last round did.

The second is about security. Israel faces Iran and its proxies on several fronts, and its friends in Washington have a stake in a government that can make hard decisions quickly. A minority government leaning on the Arab-led parties that have backed Eisenkot would face a test every time a war vote came up. Likud's demand to keep those parties out of the coalition reflects that worry, and Eisenkot owes voters a clear answer on how a minority government would hold together under fire.

The third is about the voters themselves. Israelis have been asked to go to the polls again and again in recent years. Another election would mean more months of caretaker rule at a dangerous moment. Both men say they want a broad government. Sunday is a chance to prove it.

Americans who stand with Israel do not get a vote in the Knesset, and should not want one. What they can hope for is a government in Jerusalem stable enough to keep its promises, defend its people and stand with its allies. That is a higher bar than winning a negotiation, and it is the one both men should be measured against.

What Comes Next

The negotiating teams are due to meet Sunday. If the talks fail, Eisenkot has signaled he will try his minority option before his mandate runs out. If that fails, Israel's president would have to decide what comes next, and the country could be headed back toward the ballot box.

For now, the door is open. Whether anyone walks through it depends on an answer neither man has been willing to give: who steps back.

Sources

  1. France 24: Eisenkot invites Netanyahu's party for 'marathon' Israeli coalition talks (link)
  2. Ynet News: Netanyahu, Eisenkot remain at odds after first unity talks as Bennett sends envoy (link)
  3. Ynet News: Netanyahu demands full 4-year term, no Oct. 7 inquiry in unity government talks, Eisenkot bloc claims (link)
  4. The Times of Israel: Eisenkot said planning vote on new government before mandate ends, even without majority (link)
  5. The Jerusalem Post: Likud sets unity government terms ahead of Gadi Eisenkot talks (link)
  6. Al Jazeera: Arab parties back Eisenkot: What's the latest in Israel's coalition talks? (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageWorld NewsTurn the pageA Verdict Without a Sheriff: Myanmar Rejects the World…