‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

No Proof of Payback, a Judge Ruled. Now a Former SPLC Insider's FBI Interview Says Christians and Conservatives Were Pushed Out

The Southern Poverty Law Center and its defenders call the federal fraud case against it political revenge. The court record, and a former director's account to the FBI, point somewhere else.

By ETHAN CALLOWAYStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 17, 6:39 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: A small white country church with a steeple at dawn in rural Alabama, its front doors open and warm light spilling out, a well-worn Bible resting on the front steps, in the far distance the outline of a federal courthouse…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

For months, the Southern Poverty Law Center and its allies have told Americans the same story about the federal case against it: that it is political payback. Now one of the documents filed by the defense itself has opened a window into the group that its supporters may not want the public to see.

What They Claim

The SPLC, the Montgomery, Alabama, nonprofit best known for its "Hate Map," is under federal indictment on fraud charges, along with Heidi Beirich, a former SPLC official who once led its Intelligence Project. Its defenders argue the prosecution is revenge. The legal commentary site emptywheel, for example, argued this month that the Justice Department brought the fraud case to retaliate against the group.

Beirich has pressed the same argument in court. On Nov. 2, her lawyers filed transcripts of FBI interviews with a man identified only as "Individual-1" to support her motion to dismiss the case as politically motivated, The Daily Signal reported. Their point was that prosecutors were present for interviews they say showed an improper purpose.

What the Record Shows

The first problem with the payback story is that a federal judge has already tested it. In August, U.S. District Judge Emily Marks rejected the SPLC's own bid to throw out the indictment as vindictive, finding that the group had not tied any improper motive to the prosecutors who made the charging decisions, Bloomberg Law reported. The judge also refused the SPLC's request to dig through prosecutors' internal records on how the case was built. That ruling did not decide guilt, but it did decide that complaints about the administration's rhetoric are not proof of a corrupt prosecution.

The second problem is what the charges are actually about. According to federal prosecutors, a superseding indictment unsealed in August charges the SPLC and Beirich with conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to make false statements to a federally insured bank. Prosecutors allege that between 2007 and 2023, more than $4 million in donated money was secretly passed to people associated with violent extremist groups. The SPLC's lawyers have defended its paid informant program as work that prevented violence, according to Bloomberg Law. The group and Beirich have pleaded not guilty, The Daily Signal reported, and they are entitled to the presumption of innocence.

Those are questions about donors' money and what donors were told. They are the kind of questions any charity that raises large sums from ordinary Americans should be able to answer, whoever sits in the White House.

The third problem is the defense's own exhibit. According to The Daily Signal, Individual-1 once directed the Intelligence Project, ran its program of paid field sources and supervised Beirich for a time. In his FBI interviews, he described a slow takeover of the organization by figures he saw as very liberal and extreme, one that drove out "the Christians and the conservatives," the outlet reported. He has not been charged.

The same man told agents the SPLC changed its Hate Map over the years in ways that counted a single group as several, according to the Washington Examiner, which reported his claim that the numbers were inflated to win over law enforcement.

Why It Matters

For years, Christian ministries, pro-life groups and mainstream conservative organizations have said the Hate Map lumped them in with violent extremists. Those complaints were often waved away as sour grapes. A former insider describing a purge of Christians and conservatives from the staff, and a map shaped to impress police, gives those complaints a new weight.

America's own law enforcement had already drawn a line. In October 2025, the FBI cut its ties with the SPLC, with Director Kash Patel calling the group a partisan smear machine whose map had been used to defame ordinary Americans, the Associated Press reported. The break came after conservatives objected to the group listing the late Charlie Kirk's organization among hate groups.

Who Is Pushing Back, and What Comes Next

The pushback is coming from the people who were labeled: conservative leaders and organizations who asked the government to stop treating an advocacy group's list as neutral intelligence, and an FBI that listened. Now the matter is in the hands of a federal court in Montgomery, where the evidence, not the press releases, will decide the outcome.

The SPLC and Beirich's lawyers did not respond to The Daily Signal's request for comment before publication. They will have their day in court. So will the donors who trusted them, and so will the truth about how a self-described watchdog came to see so many of its fellow citizens as the enemy.

Sources

  1. emptywheel: DOJ Prosecuted SPLC for Fraud to Exact Revenge for Charlie Kirk (link)
  2. The Daily Signal: Former SPLC Director Describes 'Long-Term Coup,' Says 'Christians and Conservatives' Were Pushed Out (link)
  3. Bloomberg Law: Judge Rejects Effort to Toss Southern Poverty Law Center Charges (link)
  4. U.S. Attorney's Office, Middle District of Alabama: Second Superseding Indictment Adds Defendant and Charges Southern Poverty Law Center (link)
  5. Washington Examiner: SPLC inflated 'Hate Map' data to get law enforcement on its 'side,' FBI interviewee says (link)
  6. WSLS (Associated Press): FBI cuts ties with Southern Poverty Law Center, Anti-Defamation League after conservative complaints (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageEvery Generation Has Remade the People's House. Trump's New…Turn the pageD.C.'s New Delegate Says Statehood Is Coming. The…