‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

Let the Students Listen: Why Rutgers Republicans Had Every Right to Host Greg Bovino, and Why the Governor Should Have Said So

New Jersey Gov. Mikie Sherrill said hosting the former Border Patrol commander was the wrong decision. Then protesters shouted him down. A public university's duty to free speech is not a close call.

By REBECCA HARTMANStaff Correspondent · ILLINOIS · Nov 16, 11:25 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: An empty wooden lectern with a microphone under a single spotlight in a historic university hall with tall arched windows at night, rows of empty chairs, an American flag standing beside the stage, a copy of the Constitution…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

The Rutgers University College Republicans did something college clubs have done for generations: they invited a newsworthy speaker to campus to explain his work and take questions. Their guest on Monday night was Greg Bovino, the former Border Patrol commander who led President Trump's immigration enforcement surges in Chicago and Minneapolis.

Before he arrived, New Jersey's governor weighed in. Gov. Mikie Sherrill, a Democrat, said she was disappointed in the club's decision and said the state would work with Rutgers to protect students if the event went forward, Fox News and Patch reported. The Post Millennial reported her message to the club: "Giving him a platform is the wrong decision". She also urged those attending to ask Bovino why he chose cruelty over humanity, according to Patch.

Then came the night itself. Anti-immigration-enforcement protesters disrupted Bovino's talk, calling him a Nazi and a fascist, and at one point he was escorted out of the room, The Washington Times reported.

What the Governor Got Wrong

Sherrill has every right to disagree with Bovino. Plenty of Americans do. Critics object to how the enforcement surges he led were carried out, and protesters made that case loudly on Monday. Disagreement is what a free country runs on.

But a governor is not just another voice in the crowd. She is the chief executive of the state that runs Rutgers. When the official who appoints members of its governing board and signs the state budget that funds it publicly tells a student club it made the wrong decision, and promises state coordination with the school over the event, students hear more than an opinion. They hear that their choice of speaker is being watched from the top.

The Rutgers College Republicans called her remarks a threat to free speech. Bovino went further, accusing Sherrill of timing her statement in a way that could inspire political violence and challenging her to attend the event herself.

What the Constitution Requires

Rutgers is a public university, and the First Amendment's guarantee that government shall make no law "abridging the freedom of speech" applies to it. That protection does not depend on whether a speaker is popular on campus. It exists precisely for speakers who are not.

To its credit, Rutgers got the basics right. A university spokesperson said the College Republicans are a recognized student organization entitled to host guest speakers, and campus police were on hand to keep both attendees and demonstrators safe, according to Patch. Rutgers spokeswoman Megan Florance said the university is committed to protecting freedom of expression even when views are controversial.

More than 1,600 people signed a petition asking Rutgers to cancel the talk. The university did not cancel it. That was the correct call, and it is the one New Jersey's governor should have defended.

What happened inside the room is the real lesson for parents. A petition is free speech. A protest outside is free speech. Shouting down a speaker until he cannot be heard is something else. It hands the loudest people in the room a veto over what everyone else may hear.

Parents who send their children to a state university are paying for an education, and part of an education is learning to sit through an argument you dislike and answer it. A student who disagrees with Bovino could have asked him the hardest question in the room. That student would have learned more, and taught more, than anyone with a bullhorn.

Who Is Pushing Back, and What Comes Next

The College Republicans are pushing back, and Bovino has publicly challenged the governor to meet him face to face. Conservative outlets from Fox News to The Washington Times have spotlighted the clash.

The next test belongs to Rutgers and to Trenton. If the university applies its conduct rules evenly to anyone who disrupted an approved event, students of every political stripe will know the rules protect them, too. And if Sherrill wants to show she meant what she said about protecting students, she can start by saying clearly that the young Republicans who invited Bovino are students worth protecting as well.

Sources

  1. Fox News: Dem governor rips College Republicans for hosting ex-Trump Border chief, provokes fiery response (link)
  2. The Washington Times: Protesters at Rutgers shout down former Border Patrol chief Greg Bovino (link)
  3. Patch: Sherrill Criticizes Rutgers Republican Club For Inviting Border Patrol Head To Speak (link)
  4. The Post Millennial: NJ Dem governor 'disappointed' that state school Rutgers' GOP club set to host former Trump Border Patrol head (link)
  5. The Blaze: Greg Bovino accuses NJ governor of trying to foment political violence (link)
  6. Congress.gov Constitution Annotated: First Amendment (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageThe Facts Don't Back Up Ro Khanna's $1,700 War Check…Turn the pageA Watchdog Needs a Leader: The Constitution, Not a…