‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

A Watchdog Needs a Leader: The Constitution, Not a Commission That Never Met, Decides Who Runs the GAO

Democrats say President Trump skipped Congress' process by naming Eric Ueland comptroller general. The text of the law, the empty calendar of that commission and the Constitution tell a different story.

By BENJAMIN STONEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 16, 10:00 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: An antique leather-bound copy of the U.S. Constitution open on a polished mahogany desk beside a brass magnifying glass and a stack of federal audit ledgers, warm lamplight, the Capitol dome softly visible through a tall…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

President Trump on Monday formally nominated Eric Ueland, the No. 2 official at the Office of Management and Budget, to be comptroller general of the United States, the head of the Government Accountability Office, Federal News Network reported. The job carries a 15-year term.

Democrats were quick to object. The Washington Post reported that the nomination was criticized as failing to follow proper congressional process. Government Executive reported that Democrats say Republican leaders never convened the bipartisan congressional commission that recommends candidates for the post, and that the commission has not interviewed a single candidate. Sen. Gary Peters of Michigan, the top Democrat on the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, said the pick would compromise GAO's role as a watchdog that serves Congress and roots out fraud, waste and abuse, according to Federal News Network.

Those are serious charges about a serious office. They deserve a serious answer, and the answer starts with the Constitution.

What the Constitution Says

The Appointments Clause is plain. The President "shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint" the officers of the United States. The power to choose belongs to the President. The power to confirm or reject belongs to the Senate. No statute can move the first power to a committee of congressional leaders.

The law that governs the comptroller general's office follows that design. It says the comptroller general is appointed by the President with the advice and consent of the Senate. It sets up a 10-member commission of House and Senate leaders to recommend at least three individuals, and it lets the President ask the commission for more names. The commission advises. The Constitution decides.

A Process Democrats Helped Leave Empty

The commission Democrats now say was skipped is not a Republican body. Under the statute, it includes the Speaker, the Senate president pro tempore, the majority and minority leaders of both chambers, and the chairmen and ranking members of the two committees that oversee government operations. Democratic leaders hold seats on it.

Yet by Democrats' own account, it never met and never interviewed anyone. Meanwhile, GAO has been run on an acting basis since Gene Dodaro stepped down, with Orice Williams Brown serving as acting comptroller general. A 15-year post charged with auditing the federal government's books should not sit in acting hands indefinitely because a commission could not find a date on the calendar.

When Republicans moved, Democrats called it rushed. Government Executive reported that Sen. Rand Paul, the committee's chairman, asked commission members to submit candidates within 24 hours. That is a short window, but it was an invitation to put names forward, not a door slammed shut.

Independence Is Built Into the Law

The deeper worry, that a White House aide cannot be an independent auditor, misses how the office works. Once confirmed, a comptroller general serves 15 years and can be removed only by impeachment or by a joint resolution of Congress for specific causes such as permanent disability, neglect of duty or a felony. The President who nominates him cannot fire him. Neither can the next three Presidents.

That design is the reason the confirmation process matters, and it is exactly where the questions about Ueland belong. Senators who doubt his independence can ask him under oath, examine his record at OMB and vote no. That is the system working as the Framers intended.

Who Is Pushing Back, and What Comes Next

House Oversight Committee Republicans have accused Democrats of playing politics with the nomination. The Senate homeland security committee will hold a hearing on Ueland's nomination Thursday, Federal News Network reported. Government Executive described the timing as tied to the coming change in power, with Democrats set to take control of Congress in January.

Washington has argued for decades about the balance between Congress and the President. This fight should not be hard. A watchdog needs a leader. The President has nominated one. The Senate should hold its hearing, ask its questions and vote. That is advice and consent, and it is all the Constitution requires.

Sources

  1. The Washington Post: Trump picks nominee to head watchdog agency (link)
  2. Government Executive: Trump taps OMB deputy to lead GAO amid rushed selection process (link)
  3. Federal News Network: OMB deputy nominated to lead GAO (link)
  4. House Committee on Oversight: Democrats Play Politics With GAO Comptroller Nomination (link)
  5. Cornell Law School LII: 31 U.S. Code 703: Comptroller General and Deputy Comptroller General (link)
  6. Congress.gov Constitution Annotated: Article II, Section 2, Clause 2 (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageLet the Students Listen: Why Rutgers Republicans Had Every…Turn the pageA Court Tossed One Expired Order. The Grid Still Needs…