‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

Healey Is Right That Natural Gas Is Cleaner. Now Massachusetts Policy Has to Catch Up

After years of opposing pipelines, Gov. Maura Healey says the state needs more gas, and the price, reliability and emissions data say she should follow through.

By PRIYA DESAIStaff Correspondent · MASSACHUSETTS · Nov 16, 7:00 PM · 4 min. read

Illustration: A snowy New England town at twilight with white clapboard homes glowing with warm window light, a frost-covered natural gas meter on a house wall and a plain yellow pipeline marker post standing in fresh snow, a white church…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Massachusetts Gov. Maura Healey has finally said out loud what many New England families have known for years. Hot Air highlighted a commentary noting that in a gubernatorial debate this fall, Healey told voters the state needs more gas and all forms of energy, calling natural gas "a cleaner form of energy anyways". The same commentary pointed out that during her 2022 campaign she boasted of having stopped two gas pipelines from coming into the state.

What the governor said and did

The words have been matched by at least one deed. WBUR reported that on Oct. 1, Healey wrote to Energy Secretary Chris Wright urging the Trump administration to move with urgency on the federal review of Enbridge's planned expansion of the existing Algonquin gas pipeline system, known as the RARE project. The project would install wider pipe along sections of the line and add roughly 75 million cubic feet of capacity per day, with Enbridge targeting a 2028 in-service date. Her administration estimates it would save about 600,000 Massachusetts customers $40 million a year by reducing reliance on costlier imported liquefied natural gas.

To be fair to the governor, her office describes RARE as a targeted project that mostly upgrades infrastructure already in place, not a brand-new pipeline. She deserves credit for making the request. But the commentary's larger point stands: natural gas cannot be cleaner only on a debate stage while the state's net-zero roadmap, laid out on Beacon Hill about five years ago, still carries 2030 climate targets that steer policy away from it. The facts say gas should be treated as a partner, not a problem.

What the numbers say

Start with what families pay. According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, Massachusetts households paid an average of about 30.5 cents per kilowatt-hour for electricity in August 2026, above the New England average of about 28.3 cents and well above the national average. Even the governor's own office ties those costs to supply: its case for RARE rests on replacing pricier imported LNG with pipeline gas.

Next, reliability. ISO New England, which runs the region's power grid, projects enough resources this winter to meet a peak of about 20,500 megawatts in normal weather and nearly 21,500 megawatts in a cold snap. But the grid operator still plans around natural gas pipeline constraints on the coldest days, when some gas-fired plants may not be able to get fuel, and it counts on liquefied natural gas delivered through the Everett and Saint John import terminals to help fill the gap. The region already depends on gas when the weather is at its worst. The only question is whether that gas arrives through a pipe or by ship.

Finally, the emissions record the governor now acknowledges. EIA found that U.S. power-sector carbon dioxide emissions in 2019 were 32 percent lower than in 2005. Over that span, coal fell from half of the nation's electricity to 23 percent while natural gas rose from 19 percent to 38 percent. Of the roughly 819 million metric tons of annual reductions, EIA attributed about 65 percent to the switch from coal to natural gas, more than double the 30 percent credited to renewables. Natural gas did not hold back America's emissions progress. It was the biggest driver of it.

Common sense follows. A family in Worcester or Pittsfield cannot heat a home with a target. Caring for creation and caring for the household budget are not enemies; good stewardship asks for both, and the record shows natural gas has delivered both.

Who is pushing back, and what comes next

The pressure on the governor is coming from two directions. WBUR reported that some climate advocates see her support for RARE as a sharp turn from her record as attorney general, when she opposed two proposed pipeline expansion projects.

At the State House, the pushback runs toward the ratepayer. CommonWealth Beacon reported this year that Healey and House leaders were talking more about lower electric bills than about climate change, and that Sen. Mike Barrett, the Senate's lead on climate and energy, has long warned colleagues of a "ratepayer revolt". House energy chair Mark Cusack advanced a version of Healey's energy package that would weaken the state's 2030 climate targets, slow the required annual growth in utilities' clean-power purchases from 3 percent to 1 percent through 2033, and cap the Mass Save efficiency program, which is funded by a charge on utility bills, at $4 billion. Not everyone agrees; Sen. Ed Markey told the outlet that climate change and affordability cannot be separated.

What comes next is concrete. Enbridge said it expected to file its formal application for RARE with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission by the end of October, keeping the project in line for 2028. In the meantime, this winter will test the grid's gas supply once again.

Healey has conceded the argument. Massachusetts families now need her to finish it: more pipeline capacity, climate mandates that bend to what ratepayers can bear, and an honest acknowledgment that the cleaner, affordable fuel she now praises has done more than any other to cut power-plant emissions.

Sources

  1. Hot Air: Natural Gas Is “Cleaner” – But Only When Maura Healey Says So (link)
  2. WBUR: Gov. Healey asks feds to expedite review of proposed gas pipeline expansion in Mass. (link)
  3. CommonWealth Beacon: Ratepayer revolt: Has the affordability debate soured Mass. on climate commitments? (link)
  4. U.S. Energy Information Administration: Electric Power Monthly, Table 5.6.A: Average Price of Electricity to Ultimate Customers by End-Use Sector, by State (link)
  5. U.S. Energy Information Administration: Electric power sector CO2 emissions drop as generation mix shifts from coal to natural gas (link)
  6. ISO New England: Seasonal System Outlook (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageA Court Tossed One Expired Order. The Grid Still Needs…Turn the pageThe Constitution Gives Congress Subpoenas for Lawmaking…