Pushback
A Simple Label, a Dignified Rest: The Case for the Don't Flush Babies Act
Critics scoff, but the Supreme Court has recognized a legitimate interest in the proper disposal of fetal remains, and women deserve a plain warning before the pills do their work.
By ELENA VASQUEZStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 20, 11:25 PM · 4 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
When a pro-life bill lands in Washington, the ridicule usually arrives before the reading. The Don't Flush Babies Act, H.R. 10954, filed Nov. 5 by Rep. Sheri Biggs of South Carolina with Rep. Michael Cloud of Texas as cosponsor, is getting the full treatment. Set the jokes aside, though, and the bill asks for something modest: a clear warning on the box and a respectful way to lay the smallest human remains to rest.
What the critics are saying
Critics deserve to be heard accurately. Newsweek reported that the bill would deem abortion drugs misbranded unless their packaging warns against flushing the fetus or solid medical waste, and would require prescribers to supply a catch kit so remains can be returned for burial or cremation. Anyone who prescribes or dispenses the pills without the kit, or who tampers with one, could face up to five years in prison and fines of $20,000 to $150,000 per offense, according to Newsweek.
The Palmetto State Abortion Fund accused supporters of stoking fear, Newsweek reported, arguing there is no established wastewater crisis from fetal tissue and that catch kits are medically unnecessary, do not confirm an abortion is complete, and create privacy concerns and barriers to care. In March, HuffPost, in a piece syndicated on AOL, branded a similar bill from Rep. Mary Miller of Illinois "absurd" and reported there is no scientific evidence that abortion pills are polluting drinking water.
The answer: facts, law and common sense
Start with the water question, because honesty matters. Some supporters argue that drug residue and remains are reaching the water supply, while critics say the science does not show it. That evidence is debated, and the case for this bill does not need to rest on it.
It rests, first, on what the Food and Drug Administration itself tells women. The FDA's Medication Guide for Mifeprex says most women will pass the pregnancy within 2 to 24 hours after taking the second drug, misoprostol, at a location she and her provider plan ahead of time. Liberty Counsel Action, which helped draft the bill, estimates roughly 700,000 chemical abortions happen at home each year, a figure Newsweek noted includes pills prescribed through telehealth. Many women, then, will face that moment at home. Telling a woman plainly, in advance, what she may see and what she can do is not cruelty. It is informed consent.
Second, the courts have already spoken. In 2019, in Box v. Planned Parenthood of Indiana and Kentucky, the Supreme Court reversed a lower court and upheld Indiana's law requiring abortion providers to bury or cremate fetal remains rather than dispose of them as medical waste. The justices pointed out that the Court had acknowledged back in 1983 that a state has a "legitimate interest in proper disposal of fetal remains," and they held Indiana's law was rationally related to that interest. That case involved a state law, but its principle is plain: honoring human remains is a legitimate aim of government, not a stunt.
Third, labeling is exactly what federal drug law is for. The bill works through the 1938 Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act, so an abortion drug sold without the do-not-flush warning would carry the same penalties as any other misbranded drug. Liberty Counsel Action says the idea was inspired by the WIPPES Act, a proposal to require similar labels on non-flushable wet wipes. Its president, John Stemberger, argued that if baby wipes should not be flushed, "we certainly should not be flushing babies". Common sense agrees. If a wet wipe merits a warning, surely the pill that ends a pregnancy does.
Notice, too, where the penalties point. As Newsweek described the bill, its criminal provisions are aimed at those who prescribe or dispense the drugs without supplying the required kit. That places the legal responsibility on the abortion industry, where it belongs.
Who is backing it, and what comes next
Biggs called her bill a "necessary reality check" about the undignified treatment of unborn remains and the lasting consequences of at-home chemical abortions, Newsweek reported. Liberty Counsel Action worked closely with her office on the text. The bill has been referred to the House Energy and Commerce Committee and has not received a vote, and Newsweek noted it would not, by itself, create a national abortion ban.
It is not alone. Miller's Clean Water for All Life Act, introduced in March, would also require catch kits, though HuffPost predicted it was unlikely to pass. Last year, Rep. Brandon Gill of Texas and Sen. Jim Banks of Indiana introduced the Respectful Treatment of Unborn Remains Act to bar abortion providers from disposing of fetal remains in public water systems, presenting it as a matter of dignity.
Whatever happens in committee, the question before the country is simpler than the mockery suggests. A woman deserves to know what the pills will do before she takes them. A child, however small, deserves better than a flush. A plain label and a quiet place of rest ask very little of anyone, and they offer something mothers and the nation both need: the chance to grieve with dignity.
Sources
- HuffPost (via AOL): Republicans Introduce Absurd Bill To Stop 'Pollution' Of Drinking Water With Fetal Remains (link)
- Newsweek: What is Don't Flush Babies Act? Bill Introduces Abortion Catch Kits (link)
- Liberty Counsel Action: Press Release: Congresswoman Introduces "Don't Flush Babies Act" (link)
- Supreme Court of the United States: Box v. Planned Parenthood of Indiana and Kentucky, Inc. (per curiam, May 28, 2019) (link)
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration: Medication Guide: Mifeprex (mifepristone) tablets, for oral use (link)
- Office of Rep. Brandon Gill: Rep. Gill, Sen. Banks Bill Demands Dignity for Unborn Remains (link)
— 30 —


