‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

A 25-Year-Old Network Isn't a Bargain: The Facts Behind the Fight Over Duffy's $50 Billion Air Traffic Plan

The New York Times says Congress shouldn't fund the request, and Pete Buttigieg says the Biden years already invested. The government's own auditors and the infrastructure law's fine print tell a different story.

By FRANK KOWALSKIStaff Correspondent · NEW YORK · Nov 18, 3:00 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic, cinematic interior of an aging American air traffic control equipment room at night: rows of old beige server racks, tangled copper telephone cables beside a bundle of new bright fiber-optic lines, a single…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

The New York Times opinion page has a message for Congress after last week's nationwide ground stop: do not hand Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy the $50 billion he wants for air traffic control. In a piece headlined "Do Not Give Sean Duffy $50 Billion," the Times argued that Duffy wants to pour more money into an obsolete structure, likening the plan to modernizing a Model T for highway driving.

Former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg joined in from a different direction. Appearing on MS NOW's Morning Joe, Buttigieg rejected Duffy's charge that the Biden administration failed to invest in the aging system, pointed to the 2021 infrastructure law and questioned why Duffy needs another $50 billion when some of that law's money has not yet been spent, The Hill reported.

Those are fair questions to ask about any request this large. But the record does not support the conclusion that America can afford to wait, or that the last administration already handled the problem.

The System Really Is That Old

Start with what failed on Nov. 13. A router installed for the Federal Aviation Administration destabilized communications data at 17 of the FAA's 22 en route centers, the facilities that guide planes between airports, Reuters reported. With engineers unable to find the root cause right away, the agency halted departures nationwide. Duffy said the routers being replaced are about 25 years old and were supposed to be swapped out in 2006, according to Reuters.

That is not a problem that began with this administration. In September 2024, before this administration took office, the Government Accountability Office found that of the FAA's 138 air traffic control systems, 51, or 37%, were unsustainable and another 54, or 39%, were potentially unsustainable, Nextgov reported. The watchdog said the agency had 64 investments underway to modernize most of those systems but had been slow to fix the most critical and at-risk ones.

In other words, the Times is right that the structure is old. That is exactly the argument for replacing it rather than patching it piece by piece, which is how the country ended up with equipment two decades past its replacement date.

What the Infrastructure Law Actually Bought

Buttigieg is correct that the 2021 infrastructure law was large. But a close look at the aviation money shows where it went. The law provided $25 billion for aviation over five years, according to the Congressional Research Service: $15 billion in airport infrastructure grants, $5 billion for a competitive airport terminal program and $5 billion for the FAA's own facilities and equipment.

That means only a fifth of the aviation money was aimed at the FAA's air traffic control facilities, and the CRS described that $5 billion as going to the physical condition of those facilities, including the backlog of repairs and replacements. New terminals are welcome, but they do not keep planes apart at 35,000 feet. The 2021 law did not buy the country a new air traffic control network, and last week proved it.

The unspent-money argument cuts both ways. If funds approved in prior years have moved slowly, that is a reason to demand a clear schedule and public progress reports, not a reason to leave 25-year-old routers in service. Conservatives who care about taxpayers should insist on both: a real plan with deadlines, and the money to carry it out.

Who Is Pushing Back, and What Comes Next

The modernization push did not start with the ground stop, and it does not belong to one party. When Sen. Eric Schmitt introduced the Modern Skies Act in September, a coalition of nearly 60 aviation organizations backed it, including Airlines for America, the Air Line Pilots Association, the National Air Traffic Controllers Association and the American Association of Airport Executives, according to the Transportation Department. The pilots who fly the planes and the controllers who guide them are asking for the same thing Duffy is.

There is room for honest debate about the details. Taxpayers are right to ask how much of any request goes to the screens, radios and networks controllers use every minute, and how much goes to buildings. Congress can fund the safety-critical pieces first and scrutinize the rest.

What Congress should not do is repeat the old pattern: blame the last administration, blame the current one, and then send the bill to the next Congress while the copper wire and the old routers stay in place. Millions of Americans will fly for Thanksgiving next week on a system the government's own auditors flagged two years ago. The critics have offered a slogan. The record calls for a fix.

Sources

  1. The New York Times: Do Not Give Sean Duffy $50 Billion (link)
  2. The Hill: Pete Buttigieg pushes back on Sean Duffy's Federal Aviation Administration infrastructure claims (link)
  3. Reuters (via Investing.com): US aviation shutdown blamed on L3 Harris installed router (link)
  4. Nextgov/FCW: Nearly 40% of FAA air traffic control systems need urgent updates, GAO reports (link)
  5. Congressional Research Service: Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act (IIJA) and Airport Funding (link)
  6. U.S. Department of Transportation: Trump's Transportation Secretary Sean P. Duffy, Modern Skies Coalition Applaud Senator Schmitt's $30 Billion Modern Skies Act (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageHochul Wants Answers on an ICE Site in Batavia. New York's…Turn the pageThe Measles Comeback Was Years in the Making. Fixing It…