Politics
Security First: Press Phones Collected on Flight Out of China
The President says the White House wanted to be careful after days on Chinese soil, as reporters call the move unusual and Beijing's own treatment of the press draws scrutiny.
By CLAIRE DONOVANStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 19, 12:43 PM · 2 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
White House officials collected the cellphones of the journalists traveling with President Trump on Air Force One after the plane left China on Thursday, the Daily Mail reported. Members of the press pool were told their phones would be held for security reasons during the flight and learned of the arrangement only after boarding, according to NBC News reporting cited by Mediaite and Editor & Publisher.
Asked about it, the President gave a short answer: "we want to be careful," ABC News reported.
Reporters call it unusual
NBC News chief White House correspondent Garrett Haake called the request very unusual, and The Independent's Andrew Feinberg noted that reporters normally give up their phones on Air Force One only when the President travels to a war zone. The first reports did not spell out the specific concern, whether the devices would be examined or when they would be handed back.
The move set off a wave of speculation online, with some outlets tying it to rumors of an unannounced stop or a possible meeting with North Korea's Kim Jong Un, which the White House has not confirmed.
The context critics leave out
The plane was leaving China after the President's summit meetings in Shenzhen with Chinese leader Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin. This is not the first time the White House has taken extra steps on the way out of China. When Air Force One left Beijing in May, staff and journalists were told to throw away China-issued lapel pins, credential badges and burner phones before boarding, a precaution TechCrunch reported was driven by security concerns.
Keeping devices quiet during a sensitive flight, or keeping a President's movements private until he is safely on the ground, is the kind of precaution Americans expect from those charged with protecting the commander in chief. Reporters are right to ask for an explanation, and the White House should give a fuller one once the trip is over. But a few hours without phones on an American plane is a security measure, not censorship.
Beijing's own record that day
The sharper press-freedom story of the trip came from the host government. Chinese officials blocked a Bloomberg reporter from covering the opening of the three-way meeting after she shouted a question to President Trump about former Nvidia chief executive Jensen Huang, The Hill reported, citing the White House pool report. Chinese officials had warned reporters that shouting questions during meetings would not be tolerated, according to the coverage.
That is what a government that controls the press looks like: a reporter removed from the room for asking a question. Americans who care about a free press should keep that contrast in mind as they weigh the complaints about Thursday's flight home.
Sources
- ABC News: Trump says phones were taken from press pool on Air Force One because 'we want to be careful' (link)
- Mediaite: Reporters' Phones Confiscated by US Authorities Aboard Air Force One as They Leave China (link)
- Daily Mail: 'Our phones are being taken away': White House seizes reporters' phones on Air Force One as Kim Jong Un meeting rumors swirl (link)
- Editor & Publisher: White House pool reporters told to surrender phones aboard Air Force One departing China (link)
- TechCrunch: US orders travelers on Air Force One to throw away gifts, pins, and burner phones after China trip (link)
- The Hill: China shuts out Bloomberg reporter for shouting questions at Trump (link)
— 30 —


