Politics
House Democrats Step Back From a Christmas Shutdown Over Iran as Four Senators Hold Their Line Before the Dec. 11 Deadline
With control of the House six weeks away, Democrats there see little upside in shutting the government now. In the Senate, Van Hollen, Bennet, Sanders and Duckworth say they will oppose any stopgap that does not restrict money for the war.
By AVA STERLINGStaff Correspondent · VIRGINIA · Nov 19, 9:30 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
House Democrats appear to be backing away from using next month's government funding deadline to force an end to the war with Iran, Semafor reported Thursday, concluding that they will have far more control over the process once they take the majority in January. Incoming House Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Gregory Meeks argued that without more leverage, nothing moves until Democrats hold the gavel, and Semafor found little appetite in the caucus for risking a shutdown now.
That is a sensible retreat. It also leaves the Senate's anti-war wing increasingly on its own.
The Senate Holdouts
Sens. Chris Van Hollen of Maryland, Michael Bennet of Colorado, Bernie Sanders of Vermont and Tammy Duckworth of Illinois said in a joint statement that they will oppose any short-term spending package that keeps providing billions of dollars for what they call President Trump's war of choice, unless it includes language restricting the administration from using appropriated funds to continue the war. Sen. Tim Kaine of Virginia told reporters he would not support a short-term continuing resolution unless it blocks money for the war, The Hill reported.
The deadline is Dec. 11, when current funding runs out. Senators in both parties told The Hill that a deal is being drafted to fund the government past that date, though the talks could be upended if Republicans move extra Pentagon money through a separate budget process. Democratic congressional leaders had yet to decide whether to risk a shutdown over the issue, according to coverage of the standoff.
The fight is complicated by the administration's request for hundreds of billions of dollars more for the war, which The Hill reported is weighing on the negotiations. The Washington Times put the Democrats' dilemma simply: they want to block funding for the war, but they do not want to be blamed for shutting down the government. Semafor noted that, still in the minority for the next month and a half, House Democrats have only limited ways to shape the Republican majority's funding plans.
The Republican Case
Republicans have been preparing for a regular-order budget. Senate Appropriations Committee Republicans have released all 12 of their full-year funding bills, the Senate Republican leader's office noted. Their argument is that the country's business, from paychecks for troops to air traffic controllers, should not be held hostage to a policy fight that has its own proper venue.
They have a point. The Constitution gives Congress the power of the purse, and lawmakers who oppose a war are free to use it. But the honest way to do that is a straight vote on the war itself, debated in the open, not a threat to close national parks, delay paychecks and furlough federal workers at Christmas. Americans who serve in uniform should never wonder whether Washington will keep their families paid while they are deployed.
The Politics Inside the Democratic Caucus
The split also tracks the fight over who will lead Senate Democrats in the new majority. Van Hollen is challenging Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer for the top job, and his stand on war funding has sharpened the question of what his leadership would mean for the party. House Democrats, meanwhile, are focused on organizing their incoming majority, and Semafor reported they see more to gain from waiting than from forcing a confrontation now.
For voters, the contrast is worth noting. The same party that campaigned on lowering costs is now debating whether to risk a shutdown over a foreign policy dispute, two weeks before Christmas.
What Comes Next
The next three weeks will tell whether a short-term bill can pass the Senate with enough Democratic votes to clear a filibuster, or whether the four holdouts can draw others to their side. Watch for whether Schumer commits either way, whether Republicans offer any language on war funding to win votes, and how the White House frames its request for war spending.
The responsible path is clear: keep the government open, keep the troops paid, and let the new Congress take up the war debate in January, out in the open, on its merits.
Sources
- Semafor: Democrats seem to back away from shutdown over Iran war (link)
- Office of Sen. Michael Bennet: Bennet, Sanders, Van Hollen, Duckworth Release Joint Statement Opposing Spending Package that Funds Trump's War on Iran (link)
- The Hill: Senate Democrats weigh December funding deadline to force an end to Iran war (link)
- The Washington Times: Democrats debate how to block Iran war funding without causing government shutdown (link)
- Senate Republican Leader: Are Democrats Going to Send the Government Into a Year-End Shutdown? (link)
- The New Republic: What Would Democrats Look Like Under Van Hollen's Leadership? (link)
— 30 —


