Politics
Midterms Over, No Lasting Ban: Judge Turns Down a Long-Term Order Against the Administration's DHS-Funded TV Ads
A federal judge in New York said critics failed to show ongoing harm now that the Nov. 3 elections have passed, handing the administration an incremental win while a parallel Democratic Party case waits in Washington.
By LAUREN PIERCEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 21, 2:03 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
A federal judge in New York on Friday declined to impose a long-term ban on the Trump administration's taxpayer-funded television ads, ruling that the groups suing over the spots had not shown they were still being harmed now that the midterm elections are over, the Associated Press reported.
U.S. District Judge Jennifer Rochon wrote that the urgency behind the earlier requests to halt the ads had centered on the Nov. 3 midterm and state elections. "Those elections have now passed," she wrote. The coalition, led by the watchdog group Common Cause, had not convincingly shown the ads were still causing imminent and irreparable harm, she found.
The ruling keeps the lawsuit alive, but it removes the threat of a lasting court order in this case, and the AP described it as an incremental victory for the administration.
How the Fight Began
The ads began airing in September and were paid for at least in part by a $20 million Department of Homeland Security contract, the AP reported. The White House has defended them as public service announcements. The groups suing argued they amounted to illegal, government-sponsored campaign messaging aired weeks before Election Day.
Common Cause and its partners, including a union local, filed suit in early October. On Oct. 11, Judge Rochon issued a temporary restraining order telling the administration to stop the ads immediately and barring Homeland Security from spending any more of the $20 million set aside for the campaign, CNBC reported. By then, about $19 million had already been spent, according to CNBC.
The Justice Department had told the court a restraining order was unnecessary because the ads were already set to end, and it did not argue the deeper question of whether the spots were lawful, according to the AP. Some ads kept running after the judge's deadline, CNN reported. The Justice Department later acknowledged the airings, apologized to the court and said the government was in compliance with the order, The Washington Sun reported. Common Cause has said the ads ran roughly 570 times after the original ruling.
The AP also reported that one of the spots showed the President promising Americans $5,000 if Republicans won the elections, a feature that critics seized on.
Why the Judge Stepped Back
Courts generally reserve long-term injunctions for situations where a party faces ongoing, serious harm that money cannot repair. With the elections finished and the ad buy largely spent, Judge Rochon concluded that standard was not met.
That is a sensible reading of the law. Whatever one thinks of the ads, a court order meant to protect an election loses its purpose once the votes are counted. The administration had already said it would stop buying the spots, and the remaining dollars were frozen by the earlier order.
The Bigger Picture
Every administration in modern memory has used taxpayer-funded campaigns to tell Americans about government programs, from health insurance enrollment to border safety, and every opposition party has objected when it believed the message crossed into politics. Conservatives have long argued that public money should never be used to campaign for either party, and that principle should apply evenly no matter who holds the White House.
The White House's position is that these were informational announcements. Its critics say the timing and content made them campaign messages. That legal question has not been decided, and it will now be fought out elsewhere.
What Comes Next
The future of the ads now rests largely with a different federal judge in Washington, D.C., who is overseeing a similar lawsuit brought by the Democratic National Committee. That judge held a hearing earlier this week on the DNC's request for a preliminary injunction and has not yet ruled, according to the AP.
The Common Cause case remains open in New York. Liberty Bell Report will report on the Washington ruling when it comes.
Sources
- Associated Press via News4Jax: Judge declines long-term ban on Trump's taxpayer-funded ads that aired during the midterm elections (link)
- Business Standard: US judge declines long-term ban on Trump admin's taxpayer-funded ads (link)
- The Washington Sun: Federal Judge Declines to Extend a Block on Taxpayer-Funded Trump Ads (link)
- CNBC: Judge orders Trump administration to immediately stop taxpayer-funded TV ads (link)
- CNN: Taxpayer-funded ads aired hundreds of times after judge ordered Trump to halt the push (link)
— 30 —


