‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Politics

FULL APPEALS COURT: PROXY-VOTE HOUSE BROKE THE CONSTITUTION

A divided Fifth Circuit says the House lacked a quorum when it passed the 2022 omnibus, keeping the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act off Texas's books for now.

By BENJAMIN STONEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 20, 10:32 PM · 2 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic, cinematic wide shot of the empty chamber of the U.S. House of Representatives at dusk, rows of vacant blue seats and an unattended speaker's rostrum, a wooden gavel resting on an old parchment document with an…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

A closely divided full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled Friday that the House of Representatives did not have a constitutional quorum when it passed the year-end spending package of December 2022, NBC News reported. The members physically present fell short of a majority, and the court held that votes cast by proxy for absent members could not make up the difference.

The full court split 9-8, The Gateway Pundit reported. The ruling upholds a lower-court order that bars the federal government from enforcing one piece of that package, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, against the State of Texas.

What the Court Decided

Texas, led by Attorney General Ken Paxton, sued after Congress folded the pregnancy law into the roughly $1.7 trillion omnibus bill. The case is State of Texas v. Bondi. A federal district court in Texas sided with the state, but a three-judge Fifth Circuit panel reversed in August 2025, concluding that the Constitution's quorum rule contains no requirement that members be physically present. The full court reheard the case and has now restored the district court's order.

Article I, Section 5 of the Constitution says a majority of each chamber constitutes a quorum to do business. The proxy system at the center of the case was adopted in 2020 under then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi as a pandemic measure.

A Narrow Order, a Wide Shadow

On paper, the relief is limited: it blocks enforcement of one law, against one state. Legal commentators say the reasoning reaches much further. A post at Reason's Volokh Conspiracy argued that the court, while offering narrow relief, "places a bullseye on broad legislation". Election Law Blog warned that the same logic could put other laws in the package at risk, including the Electoral Count Reform Act, the 2022 overhaul of how Congress counts presidential electoral votes.

The pregnancy law itself requires employers with at least 15 workers to make reasonable accommodations for pregnancy, childbirth and related conditions. The sharpest fight over it has been about enforcement: regulations the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission issued in 2024 counted abortion among the covered conditions, which drew objections from pro-life groups, religious employers and several states. Texas's lawsuit, however, attacked how the law was passed, not what it says.

It was not immediately clear whether the Justice Department would ask the Supreme Court to review the decision.

Why It Matters

The quorum rule is not a technicality. The Framers wrote it so that laws binding every American would be passed by a working majority of the people's representatives, gathered in one place and answerable for their votes. An emergency can justify many things, but it does not suspend Article I. Proxy voting turned the House floor into a place many members never had to stand, and a $1.7 trillion bill moved through with much of the chamber elsewhere.

Whatever the Supreme Court eventually says, Friday's ruling sends a plain message to Washington: if you want to make the law, show up. The Constitution asks no less of the men and women Americans send to Congress, and the rest of the country is entitled to expect it.

Sources

  1. NBC News: House unconstitutionally passed spending bill in 2022, appeals court rules (link)
  2. Reason (Volokh Conspiracy): En Banc Fifth Circuit Declares House COVID Proxy Voting Rule Unconstitutional (link)
  3. The Gateway Pundit: JUST IN: Fifth Circuit Rules Pelosi's Covid-Era Proxy Voting Scheme Violated the Constitution (link)
  4. Election Law Blog: En banc 5th Circuit decision threatens to hold Electoral Count Reform Act (among other laws) unconstitutional (link)
  5. Justia: State of Texas v. Bondi, No. 24-10386 (5th Cir. 2025) (link)
  6. Wikipedia: Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Razor Wire Stays: Texas Locks In 30-Year Border Deal

A settlement with federal immigration agencies bars agents from cutting the state's wire in the Del Rio Sector, and it binds the next governor too.

By COLE BRENNANImmigration & Border Security · Nov 20, 10:37 PM

Previous pagePoliticsTurn the pageHACKERS BREACHED USDA FARM PAYMENT SYSTEM, SOURCES SAY