Politics
Freed by Trump, Oath Keepers Founder Now Turns on Him
Stewart Rhodes, whose seditious-conspiracy sentence the President commuted, blames the Iran war and the Epstein files. Senate Republicans and the midterm polling tell a different story.
By CLAIRE DONOVANStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 21, 11:30 AM · 2 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Stewart Rhodes, the Oath Keepers founder whose 18-year seditious-conspiracy sentence President Trump commuted, now says he has broken with the man who set him free, the Associated Press reported Saturday in an interview carried by ABC News. Rhodes told the AP he considers the President a traitor, calling him "one of the very worst in our nation's history". The Independent and The Washington Times also reported the break, with Rhodes saying he is "absolutely done" with Mr. Trump.
Rhodes walked out of prison because the President commuted his sentence, but he was not pardoned, the AP noted. The Daily Beast reported that Rhodes has been seeking a full pardon.
What Rhodes Says Changed
According to the AP, Rhodes listed three grievances. He argues the war with Iran breaks Mr. Trump's promise to keep America out of foreign conflicts. He objected when the President brushed off backers who pressed for the release of the Jeffrey Epstein files by calling them past supporters. And he blames the President for alienating the base, which he believes cost Republicans in this month's midterms, especially in Texas.
The split did not come out of nowhere. Before Saturday's interview, Rhodes had already said on Alex Jones's program that he was leaving the MAGA movement over Iran, The Daily Beast reported.
The Washington Times noted that while he was in prison, Rhodes got a tattoo of Mr. Trump's defiant face after the President survived the assassination attempt in Butler, Pennsylvania. Rhodes told the AP he has plans for that tattoo but did not say what they are.
The Record Tells a Different Story
Rhodes speaks for himself, and the record on his biggest complaints looks different from his telling.
On Iran, Senate Republicans have not wavered. On Thursday, the Senate rejected Sen. Tim Kaine's latest war powers resolution 48-51, the first such vote since the election, with no new Republican defections, CBS News reported. The President's party in the Senate looked at the same war Rhodes condemns and chose to stand with the Commander in Chief.
On the midterms, voters themselves pointed somewhere else. A Vandenberg Coalition poll of 1,000 voters found that grocery prices and the cost of living outweighed Iran and U.S. policy toward Israel as factors in the 2026 midterms, Newsroom America reported. That finding is hard to square with Rhodes's claim that a foreign-policy betrayal drove the Republican losses. It points instead to the kitchen-table worries both parties will be judged on in 2028.
And on clemency, the facts are plain. A man serving 18 years for his role in Jan. 6 is free today because this President chose to commute his sentence. That act of mercy was never a loyalty contract, and the conservative movement, millions of ordinary Americans who care about faith, family, prices and safe streets, has never been defined by any one militia leader's approval.
Why It Matters
Some will read Rhodes's turn as a sign of cracks on the right. Our readers should weigh it for what it is: one man's falling-out, set against a Senate caucus that held firm this week and a voting public that said its top worry was the price of groceries.
Sources
- ABC News (Associated Press): Oath Keepers founder and Jan. 6 leader Stewart Rhodes is 'absolutely done' with Trump (link)
- The Independent: Oath Keepers founder 'absolutely done' with Trump (link)
- The Washington Times: Oath Keepers founder and Jan. 6 leader Stewart Rhodes is 'absolutely done' with Trump (link)
- The Daily Beast: Far-right leader Stewart Rhodes, seeking Jan. 6 pardon, dumps MAGA over Donald Trump's Iran war (link)
- CBS News: Iran war powers measure again falls short in Senate (link)
- Newsroom America: Poll: Cost of Living, Not Iran or Israel, Drove Republican Midterm Losses (link)
— 30 —


