‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Military & Defense

Standards Over Rank: Why Our Anchors Salute a Secretary Who Honored the Soldier Who Held the Line

A young Old Guard soldier enforced the rules on his own boss's entourage, and the boss pinned a medal on him. Six Liberty Bell anchors explain why that is leadership worth celebrating.

By DAN WHITAKERStaff Correspondent · VIRGINIA · Nov 12, 9:28 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: The Tomb of the Unknown Soldier at Arlington National Cemetery at golden hour: the white marble tomb on its plaza, the black guard mat stretching across the front, a single sentinel in Army dress blues seen only as a small…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

When an Old Guard sentinel called a group that included Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth to silence at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier on Veterans Day, much of the coverage framed it as a public scolding of an "embattled" Pentagon chief, in The Guardian's word. A day later, Hegseth brought the soldier to the Pentagon and pinned a medal on him. Our anchors answer.

Dan Whitaker, Pentagon and troops

Specialist Thomas Iglesias did exactly what the Old Guard trains its sentinels to do. He halted his walk, faced the steps and gave the standard command for silence and respect, the same command any visitor would get, no matter who was standing there. On Thursday, Hegseth welcomed members of the 3rd U.S. Infantry Regiment to the Pentagon and presented Iglesias the Joint Service Commendation Medal. "We love soldiers. We love standards. Well done, Specialist," he wrote afterward. That is a leader who understands that the chain of command runs on trust. Hegseth wore the uniform himself, leading a platoon at Guantanamo Bay and serving in Iraq and Afghanistan as an Army National Guard officer. Troops notice when the man at the top thanks the junior soldier who did his job instead of resenting him.

Grace Whitfield, world

This story traveled far beyond Washington. Britain's BBC reported on the award, noting that Iglesias was honored for the execution of his duties, and The Guardian covered the original moment at length. So the world saw both halves: a breach of decorum, and an American civilian leader publicly thanking a junior soldier for correcting his own party. That second half is the civilian-military bond free nations are built on. It matters at a site with deep international roots, too. The first Unknown, a World War I soldier brought home from France, was laid to rest at Arlington on November 11, 1921. Allies who fought beside him will recognize the respect shown this week.

Cole Brennan, border, crime and defense

Nobody needs to pretend the moment didn't happen. Laughter was heard as Hegseth's group broke up on the Tomb steps, ABC News reported, though the footage does not show who laughed, according to Military.com. What matters is how it was handled. The sentinel's words were the same command any visitor gets, ABC reported. An Old Guard staff sergeant said in a 2022 Army interview that sentinels respond to crowds two or three times a day, and federal cemetery rules require decorum from every visitor, official guests included, Military.com reported. Chief Pentagon spokesman Sean Parnell said the soldier "correctly and respectfully reminded everyone to maintain decorum". One standard, enforced without regard to rank, then backed from the top. That is what accountability looks like.

Ryan Mercer, Big Tech and AI policy

Online, a few seconds of video becomes a verdict before anyone asks for context. The clip of the sentinel's command spread fast, and the first headlines were all about the scolding. Yet the same footage does not show who laughed or whether Hegseth made any sound at all, Military.com noted. The platforms reward the takedown, not the ending. Hegseth used those same platforms to show the ending, posting photos on X of himself pinning the medal on Iglesias, ABC News reported. If the viral cycle is going to judge public officials by a clip, it ought to give the same reach to the moment that answered it.

Kevin Nakamura, waste, fraud and investigations

Some reporters have raised a fair procedural question. Military.com noted that the Defense Department's awards manual generally reserves the joint medal for troops in joint-duty posts, though exceptions are permitted, and that no citation or award orders had been released. The Associated Press added that the medal is not typically given to junior enlisted soldiers. Questions like that have a simple answer: publish the citation and let the record speak. The manual allows exceptions, and a sentinel who held his own chain of command to the Tomb's standard on Veterans Day, after the President's wreath-laying, is about as clear a case for one as you will find. Transparency, not suspicion, settles it.

Joe Redhawk, Native America

In Indian Country, honoring the warrior who keeps watch over the fallen is not politics. It is a sacred duty. The Smithsonian notes it has long been said that Native Americans serve at a higher rate in proportion to their population than any other group, though the military's records make it hard to prove, and that about 44,000 Native Americans served in World War II alone. Those families know what it means to bury a son, and what it means when a son never comes home. The marble at Arlington honors a soldier "known but to God". In this month set aside for Native American heritage, a young guard who protected that silence, and a secretary who thanked him for it, both deserve our gratitude.

Sources

  1. ABC News: Soldier who admonished Hegseth group at Arlington Cemetery awarded a medal (link)
  2. NBC Washington (Associated Press): Hegseth awards medal to guard who scolded him at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier (link)
  3. Military.com: Hegseth Awards Joint Medal to Tomb Guard Who Told His Group to Be Silent at Arlington on Veterans Day (link)
  4. BBC News: Hegseth awards medal to war memorial guard who reprimanded him and group (link)
  5. The Guardian: Hegseth and aides scolded by guard for laughing at Tomb of the Unknown Soldier (link)
  6. Arlington National Cemetery: Tomb of the Unknown Soldier (link)
  7. Smithsonian Torch: The Remarkable and Complex Legacy of Native American Military Service (link)
  8. Wikipedia: Pete Hegseth (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous page'An Open Seat at the Table': Melania Trump and Usha Vance…Turn the pageIran Claims Strike on Oman's Hormuz Lighthouse Island as…