‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Media & Journalism

Seven 'Lucky Loser' Claims Survive: Inside Merryday's Ruling on the President's Case Against The New York Times

A federal judge in Tampa threw out two counts and 27 statements but found that seven claims about tax fraud and financial crimes plausibly alleged actual malice.

By HAROLD WHITMOREStaff Correspondent · FLORIDA · Nov 19, 6:39 PM · 5 min. read

Illustration: A wooden judge's gavel resting on a tall stack of folded newspapers with blurred unreadable print and a thick hardcover book with a plain unmarked cover, inside a stately federal courtroom with dark wood paneling, a brass…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

President Trump's $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times and the publisher Penguin Random House will move forward, after a federal judge in Tampa on Thursday refused to throw out the heart of the case, TheWrap reported.

U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday dismissed two of the complaint's six counts and ruled that 27 of the challenged statements are not actionable. But he found that the president had plausibly alleged actual malice in seven statements involving accusations of tax fraud and other financial crimes, including claims in the book "Lucky Loser".

Six of those seven statements come from the book, by Times reporters Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig, and concern the transfer of wealth from the president's father, Fred Trump, and the taxes around it. The seventh comes from a Times article about alleged Mafia ties and money-laundering findings, according to reports on the order.

The two sides saw the same ruling very differently. Trump's legal team welcomed it, saying in a statement quoted by Deadline that "These Defendants will now have to answer for intentionally and maliciously defaming President Trump". The Times has called the suit "a baseless attack on The Times" and on the rights of a free press.

How the Case Got Here

The lawsuit has already had a bumpy ride. Trump filed it in federal court in Florida in September 2025, naming the Times, several of its journalists and Penguin Random House, over the paper's reporting and the book about his finances. Within days, Merryday struck the 85-page complaint as improper, ruling that it did not meet the basic standard for a legal pleading, and ordered the president's lawyers to file a new version no longer than 40 pages within 28 days.

The judge's message then was that a complaint is supposed to state legal claims plainly, not serve as a platform for public argument. Trump's lawyers refiled. The Times asked the court to dismiss the case or move it to federal court in New York.

In July of this year, Merryday put off ruling on the Times' request and instead gave the president another chance to rework his complaint, setting an Aug. 27 deadline and giving the Times 21 days to respond after that, Bloomberg reported. Thursday's ruling addressed that second amended complaint: Merryday granted the motion to dismiss Counts III and IV and denied it for Counts I, II, V and VI.

What 'Actual Malice' Means

To understand why Thursday's ruling matters, start with a famous case that, fittingly, also involved The New York Times.

In New York Times Co. v. Sullivan in 1964, the Supreme Court held that a public official suing over criticism of his official conduct cannot win damages for a defamatory falsehood unless he proves the statement was made with "actual malice". The Court defined that as knowing the statement was false or acting with reckless disregard for whether it was true. The case arose from a newspaper advertisement supporting the civil rights movement and a lawsuit by a Montgomery, Alabama, city commissioner.

That standard is deliberately hard to meet, and it has been a fixture of American law for six decades. It protects honest mistakes and aggressive reporting, and it is the main reason most defamation suits by famous people never get far. A public figure cannot win just by showing that a story was wrong. He has to show that the people who published it knew it was wrong, or had serious doubts and published anyway.

That is what makes the seven surviving statements significant. At this early stage, a judge does not decide who is telling the truth. He asks only whether the complaint, if its factual allegations are taken as true, plausibly states a claim. Merryday concluded that for these seven statements, it does. The ruling does not establish that any of the reporting was false or defamatory.

What the Judge Cut

The other side of the ledger is just as real. Twenty-seven challenged statements will not go forward as claims of defamation published with actual malice, and two full counts are gone.

In defamation cases, judges routinely set aside statements that are protected opinion, that cannot be proven true or false, or that a plaintiff has not tied to evidence of what the writer knew. The practical effect of Thursday's order is a narrower lawsuit, focused on specific claims about the Trump family's taxes and finances rather than the sweeping complaint the president first filed.

For the Times, that is a partial win. For the president, the more important fact is that the case is still alive after two rounds of skepticism from the same judge.

Why It Matters Beyond This Case

Many conservatives will see the ruling as a long-overdue moment of accountability. Americans' trust in the news media hit a record low of 28% in Gallup's 2025 survey, and only 8% of Republicans said they trust the media, the first time that figure fell into single digits, The Washington Times reported. When that many citizens doubt what they read, the question of whether major outlets are careful with the truth is not a narrow legal matter.

At the same time, everyone who values a free press, conservatives included, has a stake in how this case is decided. The actual malice rule protects small conservative outlets, talk radio hosts and independent reporters just as it protects the Times. The right outcome is not a ruling that punishes a newspaper for being hostile to a president. It is a ruling that holds any publisher to the same standard: report hard, but do not publish what you know to be false.

That is the line Sullivan drew more than 60 years ago, and it is the line this case will now test with evidence instead of arguments.

For readers trying to make sense of the headlines, it helps to separate three questions. Was the reporting accurate? Did the authors believe it when they published it? And can the president prove they did not? Thursday's ruling touched only the last question, and only at the threshold. It said the president has alleged enough to try to prove his case, not that he has proved it.

What Comes Next

With four counts surviving, the defendants will have to answer the remaining claims, and the case will move toward discovery, the phase where each side can demand documents and take sworn testimony. In a defamation case built on actual malice, that can mean questions about what the authors and editors knew, what sources they relied on and what doubts they had when they published.

That stage is often where these cases are won or lost, and it is also where many settle. Even after discovery, defendants in defamation cases commonly ask the judge to rule that no reasonable jury could find actual malice on the evidence gathered. That would be a second hurdle the president must clear before any trial, and a far tougher one than Thursday's, because it turns on proof rather than allegations. Both sides have signaled they intend to keep fighting.

Merryday has shown twice that he expects discipline from the president's lawyers. Thursday he showed that he will also let a public figure's claims proceed when the complaint clears the bar the Supreme Court set. For a case that began as an 85-page broadside, that is a meaningful turn, and the next chapter will be written in depositions and documents, not press releases.

Sources

  1. TheWrap: Judge Denies NY Times Effort to Dismiss Trump's $15 Billion Defamation Lawsuit (link)
  2. Deadline: Trump Defamation Suit Against New York Times Moves Forward As Dismissal Fails (link)
  3. The Washington Post: Judge strikes down Trump's $15 billion suit against the New York Times (link)
  4. Bloomberg: Trump Allowed by Judge to Amend $15 Billion Suit Against NYT (link)
  5. Cornell Law School LII: New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, 376 U.S. 254 (1964) (link)
  6. The Washington Times: Gallup: Confidence in media hits new low of 28% (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageDozens Take CBS Buyouts; London Bureau Hit HardestTurn the pageBeijing Locks a U.S. Reporter Out of the Trump-Xi-Putin…