Immigration & Border Security
DHS Says Detained Princeton Student Overstayed Since 2016
Homeland Security says the Chinese national's temporary admission ran out a decade ago; her lawyers say a pending asylum claim lets her stay, and a federal judge has ordered the government to answer by Nov. 25.
By COLE BRENNANStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 21, 2:40 PM · 2 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
The Department of Homeland Security says the Princeton graduate student its officers detained this week had been in the country unlawfully for a decade, after a temporary admission that ran out in 2016, as her lawyers fight the arrest in federal court.
Eva Yi Xie, a doctoral student at the Princeton Neuroscience Institute, was taken into custody on Thursday, Nov. 19, after attending the Society for Neuroscience's annual meeting in Washington, where she presented her research, according to The Daily Princetonian and The Guardian.
What DHS says
DHS told Newsweek that the arrest came during a targeted enforcement operation at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport, and it described Xie as "an illegal alien from China". The department said she was admitted temporarily in March 2016 and was required to leave that September, Newsweek reported. The Princetonian reported that DHS also says she never held student status, and The Times of India reported that the department's position is that she overstayed her visa.
DHS added that people without lawful status should not be flying domestically, and it noted that it offers those in custody a free flight home and $3,000 if they agree to leave on their own.
What her side says
Xie's lawyer, Kerry Doyle, says she is an asylum seeker with a pending application and an immigration court date in early 2028, the Princetonian reported. DHS has answered that a pending application does not confer legal status. Her faculty adviser, Carlos Brody, called the detention "wildly unfair," and Graduate School Dean Rodney Priestley said Princeton has arranged legal counsel for her.
Late Friday, U.S. District Judge Anthony Trenga ordered ICE not to move Xie out of the Eastern District of Virginia without a further order and to answer her habeas petition by 5 p.m. on Nov. 25. The order keeps her in Virginia for now, but it does not free her or decide the merits of her case. Until the court rules, she remains in ICE custody.
The bigger fight
Progressive outlets have seized on the case, with Common Dreams questioning whether a graduate student fits the administration's pledge to go after the "worst of the worst".
But the legal question is narrower than the outrage suggests. Federal immigration law expressly allows the government to arrest and hold a noncitizen while officials decide whether that person will be removed. A pending asylum claim gives Xie the right to have her case heard; in DHS's view, it does not erase an overstay that began ten years ago. And a federal judge is now reviewing the detention, which is how the system is meant to work: the executive branch enforces the law Congress wrote, and the courts check it.
Whether Xie ultimately stays will be decided by an immigration judge and the federal courts, not by a social media campaign. The government's answer to her petition is due Wednesday.
Sources
- Newsweek: Princeton PhD Student Detained by ICE (link)
- The Daily Princetonian: Judge orders ICE not to move Xie, a Princeton Ph.D. student and asylum seeker, out of Virginia (link)
- The Times of India: Princeton PhD student, Chinese-born neuroscientist, Eva Yi Xie detained by ICE at airport; DHS says she overstayed visa, lawyers challenge arrest (link)
- The Guardian: Princeton doctoral student reportedly detained by ICE on way back from conference (link)
- Common Dreams: 'Worst of the Worst?' ICE Blasted for Detaining 'Brilliant' Princeton Neuroscience PhD Student (link)
- Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute: 8 U.S. Code 1226 - Apprehension and detention of aliens (link)
— 30 —


