‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Immigration & Border Security

A Third Trip to the Justices: Administration Says a San Francisco Judge Defied Two Rulings on Venezuelan Migrant Protections

The Justice Department says a San Francisco judge's order reviving Temporary Protected Status for hundreds of thousands of Venezuelans defies two earlier Supreme Court rulings and the law Congress wrote.

By LAUREN PIERCEStaff Correspondent · CALIFORNIA · Nov 19, 2:03 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: The marble facade and columns of the U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington at dusk, warmly lit against a deep blue sky, with an American flag stirring on a nearby pole. On the empty plaza steps sit a closed leather…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

The Trump administration went back to the Supreme Court on Wednesday for the third time in the same case, asking the justices to stop a federal judge's order that would restore Temporary Protected Status for hundreds of thousands of Venezuelans living in the United States.

The Justice Department's emergency application asks the court to put on hold a ruling by San Francisco-based U.S. District Judge Edward Chen, who found that officials lacked the authority to end the protections granted under former President Joe Biden, Al Jazeera reported. Chen's order was due to take effect Friday unless an appeals court or the Supreme Court suspended it.

What the government is asking for

Solicitor General D. John Sauer asked the justices to block the lower court's ruling keeping the program in place, a decision the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit had upheld, according to SCOTUSblog. Sauer called the filing a remarkable third trip to the court in the same case, and he argued that the justices had already weighed the competing harms twice and found that they favored the government.

The administration warned that restoring the program would cause "severe and immediate harm," Al Jazeera reported. According to the filing as described by Al Jazeera, reinstatement would block the government from carrying out up to 332 removal orders and would require it to issue work permits to TPS holders. The Epoch Times reported that Sauer said authorities could be forced to release about 1,800 Venezuelans from immigration detention, and that the Department of Homeland Security would have to revive the status after a gap of roughly 19 months.

Lawyers for the Venezuelan TPS holders see it differently. The Epoch Times reported that counsel for the plaintiffs accused the government of trying to "jump the line" to the high court while lower courts are still working through the case. The challengers also told the justices that since the court last intervened, TPS holders have been detained, separated from U.S.-citizen children, deported to Venezuela and even sent to third countries where they have no ties, according to Al Jazeera.

Two earlier wins, and who decides

The justices have sided with the administration on this program twice before. In May 2025, the court allowed the government to move ahead with ending the status for about 350,000 Venezuelans covered by the 2023 designation, and in October 2025 it paused Chen's ruling again, Al Jazeera reported. The Washington Times noted that the October 2025 order came over the dissent of the court's three Democratic appointees. Before leaving office, the Biden administration had extended TPS for about 600,000 Venezuelans through October 2026.

At the heart of the dispute is the text Congress wrote. The TPS statute leaves the decision to designate a country, or to end a designation, to the homeland security secretary, and the government argues it bars courts from second-guessing those determinations. Sauer told the justices they had already conclusively settled that question in a June decision the government calls Doe, which involved protections for Haitians and Syrians, SCOTUSblog reported. That ruling allowed the administration to end TPS for hundreds of thousands of Haitians and Syrians, according to Al Jazeera. The Washington Times reported that the June decision held that courts should generally stay out of these executive branch decisions, with constitutional claims as the exception.

After the June ruling, the Supreme Court sent the Venezuela case back to the 9th Circuit for another look in October, SCOTUSblog reported. A short administrative stay entered by the 9th Circuit was set to expire Nov. 20. The Washington Times reported that the 9th Circuit had declined to extend that pause.

What happens next

Hours after Sauer filed at the Supreme Court, however, the 9th Circuit agreed to keep the program paused until seven days after it rules, The Hill reported. That step puts off the need for the justices to act right away, The Hill noted. The government's application remains pending before the justices, who can still act on it at any time.

The legal fight is unfolding as Venezuela itself has changed dramatically. Nicolás Maduro was seized in a U.S. military operation in January, and acting President Delcy Rodríguez has since moved to rebuild ties with Washington, CNN reported. Deportation flights to Venezuela increased after Maduro's removal, and in August the United States sent back more than 100 Venezuelans on the first such flight since deadly earthquakes struck the country in late June, according to CNN.

Those changes are likely to shape the debate over whether conditions in Venezuela still justify a temporary program that has now lasted years. For now, the question before the justices is narrower: whether a single district judge can keep the protections alive after the high court has twice allowed the administration to end them.

Sources

  1. Al Jazeera: Trump makes third Supreme Court bid to end Venezuelan migrant protections (link)
  2. SCOTUSblog: Trump administration asks Supreme Court to block lower court ruling keeping protected status in place for Venezuelan nationals (link)
  3. The Epoch Times: Trump Asks Supreme Court to End Protected Status for Venezuelans (link)
  4. The Washington Times: DHS asks Supreme Court to block deportation amnesty for thousands of Venezuelans (link)
  5. The Hill: Lower judges act after Trump administration pressures Supreme Court on TPS (link)
  6. CNN: US deports Venezuelans for the first time since deadly earthquakes in June (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageImmigration & Border SecurityTurn the pageJudge Throws Out the Administration's Four-Year Limit on…