Pushback
UC Students Rally to Keep the SAT Banned, but the Campus Math Crisis Makes the Case for Bringing It Back
As University of California students press regents to stay test-free in the name of equity, faculty reports of soaring remedial math needs show why an honest yardstick matters.
By REBECCA HARTMANStaff Correspondent · CALIFORNIA · Nov 19, 2:03 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
About 100 University of California students rallied Tuesday to urge the UC Board of Regents to keep the SAT and ACT out of admissions, according to The College Fix. The rally, organized by the UC Student Association, framed the question as one of equity, arguing that the exams shut out low-income students and students of color. The New York Post reported that the students made their case even as UC professors warn that many freshmen arrive unable to handle basic math.
UC dropped standardized test scores from admissions in 2020, citing those same equity concerns. Now a growing number of the people who teach UC students every day say the experiment has gone wrong, and the numbers suggest they have a point.
The students' concerns deserve a respectful hearing. Every parent wants a fair shot for their child, and nobody wants a single Saturday morning to decide a teenager's future. Test-free advocates also have researchers on their side, and scholars who doubt the value of the exams have made their case directly to the regents, EdSource reported.
Defenders of the current policy also point out that whatever is happening in entry-level math classes has not shown up in first-year grade point averages, retention or graduation rates, CalMatters reported. Those are fair arguments. But they do not answer what professors are seeing in their own classrooms.
What the professors are seeing
More than 600 UC professors have signed an open letter saying they have been forced to teach middle school math in calculus and other courses, the New York Post reported. The College Fix reported that the student rally was a response to faculty calls to bring the SAT and ACT back.
The most detailed evidence comes from UC San Diego. A report by the campus Senate-Administration Working Group on Admissions, released last November, found that the share of incoming freshmen who needed remedial math rose from 0.5 percent in fall 2020 to 11.8 percent in fall 2025, the UCSD Guardian reported. That is more than a twentyfold increase in five years. The remedial course was meant to fill gaps in high school and middle school coursework.
The working group's recommendations show how far the problem has spread. It called for holding math placement exams earlier in the summer, building a system of communication with California high schools to guard against grade inflation, and reducing admissions from a category of high schools the campus labels LCFF+ back to pre-2022 levels. In other words, without a common measure, the campus was left looking for other ways to sort out which transcripts it could trust.
The trouble is not confined to San Diego. A CalMatters analysis of first-year calculus at UC Berkeley before and after the test ban found that students struggled more in math, though not in other subjects.
Equity means telling students the truth
Here is the hard truth that the equity argument misses. When high school grades rise but skills do not, a 4.0 transcript stops telling anyone what a student actually knows. A standardized test is the one yardstick that measures every applicant the same way, whether they attended a wealthy suburban school or a struggling one. A strong score can also flag a gifted student at an overlooked school who might otherwise be missed.
The students hurt most by dropping that yardstick are the very ones the policy was meant to help: young people admitted to demanding programs without the preparation to succeed, who then spend tuition money and precious time on remedial classes. Parents who sacrifice to send a son or daughter to a UC campus deserve to know whether that child is ready. Telling a student the truth about his or her preparation is not cruelty. It is respect, and it is the first step toward real opportunity.
Who is pushing back, and what comes next
The pressure on the regents is coming from faculty across the system, and the board has heard from researchers on both sides of the question of whether the SAT should return, EdSource reported.
A final answer will take time. UC has said a decision on bringing back the SAT and ACT will not come until 2027, even as faculty push for change, CBS San Francisco reported. That leaves at least one more admissions cycle under the current test-free policy.
For California families, the coming months are a chance to speak up. Regents answer to the public, and parents, teachers and taxpayers who want UC degrees to mean something have every reason to tell them that honest measurement and genuine equity are not enemies. They belong together.
Sources
- New York Post: UC students rally to keep SAT banned even as profs warn freshmen can't do basic math: 'Second-rate university' (link)
- The College Fix: UC students rally to keep admissions test-free over 'equity' as math proficiency plummets (link)
- The UCSD Guardian: Admissions report finds academic preparedness deficiencies in incoming UCSD students (link)
- EdSource: Should admission to University of California require SAT exam? Researchers give competing views (link)
- CalMatters: The UC got rid of the SAT in admissions. Some faculty are pushing to bring it back (link)
- CBS San Francisco: UC says decision on bringing back SAT, ACT tests not coming until 2027 as faculty push for change (link)
— 30 —


