Florida & Southeast News
Florida AG Uthmeier Says 2018 Bump-Stock Ban Violates the Second Amendment, Won't Defend Convictions
Attorney General James Uthmeier issued a formal opinion finding the post-Parkland bump-stock ban unconstitutional and said his office will no longer defend convictions under it, though the law stays on the books until lawmakers or a court act.
By TOMÁS ORTEGAStaff Correspondent · FLORIDA · Nov 16, 7:00 PM · 4 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier has concluded that the state's 2018 ban on bump stocks violates the Second Amendment, and he says his office will no longer defend convictions under it.
In a formal legal opinion issued Friday, Nov. 13, Uthmeier found the ban unconstitutional and said executive branch officials cannot lawfully enforce it, Florida Politics reported. CBS News Miami reported that his office will stop defending the law when people convicted under it appeal. According to WLRN, the opinion says the statute "imposes a categorical prohibition on an entire class of firearm components" that can increase a semiautomatic weapon's rate of fire.
Uthmeier stressed that the question is not academic. In his public statement, he said people are still being arrested and prosecuted under the law, Florida Politics reported. The Tampa Bay Times reported that he called the law overly broad as written and warned that it could expose lawful users of trigger enhancements to five years in prison.
The attorney general's reasoning
Uthmeier built his case on the U.S. Supreme Court's Bruen framework for Second Amendment cases. According to Florida Politics, the opinion treats bump stocks as arms covered by the plain text of the Second Amendment, which puts the burden on the state to show a historical tradition of similar bans. The opinion also rejects the argument that bump stocks are "dangerous and unusual" weapons.
He leaned as well on the Supreme Court's 2024 decision in Garland v. Cargill. In that June 14, 2024, ruling, the Court held 6-3, in an opinion by Justice Clarence Thomas, that a semiautomatic rifle fitted with a bump stock is not a "machinegun" under the National Firearms Act, because it cannot fire more than one shot with a single function of the trigger. The Court found that the federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives exceeded its authority when it classified bump stocks as machine guns, and Justice Sonia Sotomayor dissented.
Cargill turned on the wording of a federal statute, so the Florida opinion adds the Bruen history test. Florida Politics reported that Uthmeier relied on the finding that a bump-stock rifle fires one shot per function of the trigger, while noting that the state could still regulate devices that truly turn semiautomatic guns into machine guns. The Tampa Bay Times noted that after the high court struck down the federal ban in 2024, Florida's own prohibition remained in force.
Remembering Parkland, and the critics
The ban was part of the sweeping school safety and gun package lawmakers passed after the Feb. 14, 2018, shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland. That attack took 17 lives, including 14 children, and the same 2018 law raised the minimum age to buy a rifle from 18 to 21 and created a red flag law.
Any honest discussion of this law begins with those 17 lives and the families who still grieve them. Floridians of every political stripe share the goal of keeping schools safe. The attorney general's opinion does not question that goal. It asks whether one specific provision can be squared with the Constitution.
The 2018 package was never a simple party-line vote. WLRN reported that it drew bipartisan support but also divided lawmakers in both parties, with some Republicans opposing its gun provisions.
Critics have objected to this kind of move before. The Tampa Bay Times noted that Uthmeier took a similar step in 2025, when he declined to defend the state's ban on rifle purchases by adults under 21. House Democratic Leader Fentrice Driskell has argued that the attorney general's "job is to defend Florida law," the Times reported. The paper also noted that Florida statutes do not say the attorney general must defend every state law.
What happens next
For now, the ban is still the law. Florida attorney general opinions are advisory and do not bind courts, and the statute stays on the books unless lawmakers repeal it or a court strikes it down, Florida Politics reported. CBS News Miami likewise noted that neither a court nor the Legislature has struck the ban.
The practical effect falls on prosecutors and defendants. Townhall reported that state attorneys can no longer count on the attorney general's office for help prosecuting these charges. Townhall's writer also doubted that a repeal will come easily, given the Republicans who backed the post-Parkland laws.
The political ground may be shifting, though. WLRN reported that Gov.-elect Byron Donalds voted against the 2018 law as a member of the Florida House and has criticized its gun control measures on the campaign trail. That could set up a debate in Tallahassee over whether lawmakers should take the ban off the books themselves rather than leave it in legal limbo.
For law-abiding gun owners, the opinion is a significant statement that Florida's chief legal officer reads the Second Amendment as protecting more than the bare minimum. For the Parkland families, it is a painful reminder of a day the state will never forget. Both deserve a careful, constitutional answer from the Legislature and, if it comes to that, the courts.
Sources
- Townhall: Florida AG Declares State's Bump Stock Ban Unconstitutional, Says State Won't Enforce It (link)
- Florida Politics: James Uthmeier turns on bump-stock ban (link)
- Tampa Bay Times: Uthmeier says he won't defend Florida's ban on bump stocks (link)
- CBS News Miami: Florida AG calls state's bump stock ban unconstitutional, says office will no longer defend it (link)
- WLRN: Attorney General Uthmeier declares 'bump stock' ban dead (link)
- Ballotpedia: Garland v. Cargill (link)
— 30 —


