Faith & Religion
Faith Shouldn't Cost a Tax Break: A Minnesota Pastor and a Vermont Catholic Family Challenge Religious-Education Exclusions
A pastor and a father of six say Minnesota's K-12 tax benefit shuts out families who teach the faith, while a Vermont family is suing after the state cut Catholic schools from town tuition.
By MARGARET CALLAHANStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 22, 7:00 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Two Christian fathers in Minnesota say their state is willing to help families pay for their children's education in nearly every way but one: if the lessons are about God, the help disappears. Now they are asking a court to end that exclusion.
Nathan Colestock, a pastor with four children, and Joseph Osburn, a father of six, both of Washington County, have sued Minnesota Revenue Commissioner Paul Marquart in Minnesota Tax Court, The Christian Post and Alpha News reported. They are represented by Alliance Defending Freedom and the Upper Midwest Law Center.
Their case is one of two recent lawsuits, in Minnesota and Vermont, brought by families who say they are being penalized for choosing a faith-based education for their children.
A Tax Break With a Religious Asterisk
The program at the center of the Minnesota case is the state's K-12 Education Subtraction and Credit, which helps parents offset the cost of tutoring, textbooks, instructional materials and enrichment classes. The fathers say their families qualify in every respect except one: the education their children receive is religious.
According to the lawsuit, Colestock qualifies for both the credit and the subtraction but has not claimed either, because the curricula, materials, academies and cooperatives his family uses are Christian. Osburn qualifies for the subtraction and has likewise held back, because claiming it would conflict with his beliefs about his children's religious schooling.
The complaint argues that the exclusion violates the First and Fourteenth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution and the conscience guarantee in the Minnesota Constitution, and it asks the court to declare the religious exclusion unconstitutional. ADF is asking the court to let the families pursue a Christian education without being shut out of the same tax benefits their neighbors receive. The reports did not include a response from the Department of Revenue.
An Old Rule Meets a New Supreme Court
Minnesota's education tax break has been to the Supreme Court before. In Mueller v. Allen in 1983, the justices upheld the state's deduction for parents' educational expenses, reasoning that the benefit went to parents rather than putting the state's stamp of approval on religious schools. Even then, the law carved out instructional books and materials used to teach religious tenets, doctrines or worship.
Today's lawsuit targets two provisions of state law that, the fathers say, keep families from claiming the benefits for religious education. They argue those limits cannot survive the Supreme Court's more recent decisions. In 2020, in a case from Montana, the high court ruled that a state that offers support to private-school families cannot exclude religious schools simply because they are religious, as SCOTUSblog explained in its analysis of the ruling. The principle is straightforward: once the government opens a public benefit to everyone, it may not single out people of faith for worse treatment.
If that rule applies to scholarships for religious schools, the fathers say, it should apply to a Bible-based curriculum bought for the kitchen table.
A Vermont Family Without a High School
In Vermont, the fight is over tuition. Greg and Carrie Bishop live in the Barstow Unified Union School District, which has no high school of its own, so the family chose to send their daughter to Mount St. Joseph Academy, a Catholic school, PJ Media reported. After a brief stint at a public high school for vocational coursework, she was denied town tuition funding when she returned to Mount St. Joseph, and the family is now paying out of pocket.
The reason, according to the family, is Act 73, Vermont's 2025 education law, which removed religious schools from the town tuition program. The Bishops filed a federal lawsuit on Oct. 27 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Vermont, arguing the policy violates their First Amendment rights.
Why It Matters
These are not cases about special favors. Minnesota and Vermont have chosen to help families with the cost of education. The only question is whether parents who teach their children about their faith must give up that help to do it.
Scripture tells parents to impress God's commands on their children, talking about them at home and along the road. For millions of American families, a religious education is how they keep that charge. The Constitution's promise of free exercise means a state should not make those families pay a penalty for keeping faith.
The Minnesota case now goes before the Tax Court, and the Vermont case before a federal judge. Both will test how far the Supreme Court's recent religious-liberty rulings reach, and both could shape how other states with similar exclusions write their education benefits in the years ahead.
Sources
- The Christian Post: Minnesota fathers sue state for barring religious education from K-12 tax benefit (link)
- Alpha News: Minnesota fathers sue state for 'excluding religious education' from certain tax benefits (link)
- Alliance Defending Freedom: Colestock v. Marquart (link)
- PJ Media: Their Town Has No High School, but Vermont Won't Fund Their Catholic Choice (link)
- Britannica: Mueller v. Allen (link)
- SCOTUSblog: Opinion analysis: Court rules that religious schools cannot be excluded from state funding for private schools (link)
— 30 —


