‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Business & Economy

Regulators Order Kalshi to Pull Markets on the President's Words, Citing the Risk of Manipulation

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission told the prediction-market firm to stop trading contracts tied to what President Trump says in public, and Kalshi has until Dec. 11 to show its 'mention markets' can be policed.

By KENDALL PRICEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 17, 6:39 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: A presidential-style lectern with a microphone standing alone on an empty stage under warm spotlights, an American flag draped behind it, and in the foreground a glowing financial trading screen of abstract green and red…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Federal regulators have told one of the country's biggest prediction-market companies to stop letting customers trade on what the president of the United States will say.

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission ordered Kalshi to halt trading on contracts tied to the words President Trump uses at public events, Bloomberg reported Tuesday, calling it the latest sign that prediction markets face closer scrutiny after the midterm elections. Kalshi said it is complying with an order the commission issued on Friday, according to CBS News.

What Was Pulled, and Why

So-called mention markets let traders take positions on whether a public figure will say a particular word or phrase during a speech, interview or news conference. CNBC reported that some of the Trump-related contracts have now been taken down as the agency warns this type of contract carries a heightened risk of manipulation.

A CFTC spokesperson said the commission stayed the approval of the contracts because they may be susceptible to manipulation, a position the agency said matches a staff advisory it issued about two months ago, Quartz reported. That advisory warned that such markets are especially risky in part because their outcome can turn on conduct that cannot be independently verified, according to Quartz. Kalshi said the decision lines up with a September order that had already stayed approval of certain mention markets.

The concern is not abstract. Quartz reported that the order follows a July episode in which a White House teleprompter operator reportedly profited from Kalshi wagers tied to the president's public speeches. When the person who loads the speech can also trade on what the speech will say, the integrity problem is obvious to anyone.

This is not the first time Kalshi has trimmed its menu under pressure. The company earlier dropped sports-related mention markets after a CFTC review in August, Quartz reported. The Hill reported that the platform halted the Trump markets in response to the regulator's order.

Kalshi's Case

Kalshi has defended the contracts. The company argues that the individual words of prominent people can move billions of dollars across financial markets, so a market that prices those words has real informational value, according to Quartz.

There is something to the point that words move money. A single phrase from a Federal Reserve chairman or a president can swing stock, bond and oil prices within minutes. But that is exactly why the risk cuts the other way. The more a word is worth, the stronger the temptation for someone close to the speaker to cash in, and the harder it is for ordinary Americans on the other side of the trade to know whether the game is fair.

Not Done Yet

Kalshi has until Dec. 11 to answer the CFTC and show that its mention contracts comply with federal rules against manipulation, Quartz reported. A bipartisan group of lawmakers had already warned the agency that such markets are readily open to manipulation, according to the outlet. Similar contracts on the president's words remain available on rival platform Polymarket, Quartz noted.

The order lands as prediction markets have grown from a niche curiosity into a fast-growing industry that now touches elections, sports, the economy and politics. Bloomberg described the move as part of a broader tightening of oversight now that the midterm contest is over.

Why It Matters

For conservatives, this is a question of trust and of respect for the office. The presidency is not a casino table, and the words a president chooses in a speech to the nation should be weighed by voters, not wagered on by insiders. Free markets depend on rules that everyone can see and everyone must follow; a market that can be quietly gamed by those with a seat near the podium is not free in any meaningful sense.

Regulators have a duty to protect investors without smothering honest innovation. Asking a company to prove its products cannot be rigged, before it lets the public trade them, is the kind of common-sense guardrail that serves both goals.

What Comes Next

The next marker is Kalshi's Dec. 11 response. If the company cannot satisfy the commission, the halt could stay in place, and rivals offering similar contracts could face the same questions.

Sources

  1. Bloomberg: CFTC Orders Kalshi to Take Down Markets on Trump's Speeches (link)
  2. CBS News: Kalshi halts bets on what Trump will say at CFTC's request (link)
  3. CNBC: Kalshi takes down controversial Trump 'mention' markets at CFTC's request (link)
  4. Quartz: Kalshi paused Trump mention markets at CFTC's request over manipulation risk (link)
  5. The Hill: Kalshi halts Trump mention markets (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageTrump and Thailand Sign a Trade Statement in Manila, With…Turn the pageHome Depot Hands the Keys to a 21-Year Insider: CFO Richard…