Markets
Wednesday, November 18, 2026Updated 8:48 PM ET

Conservative news from the nation’s capital

Investigations & Special Reports

Tonight on Deep Dive with Kevin Nakamura

NIH Asks Nature Medicine to Investigate Who Really Shaped the 2020 Paper That Sidelined the Lab-Leak Theory

NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya wants the journal to examine whether Fauci, Collins and Farrar played undisclosed roles in 'Proximal Origin,' and whether the paper should be corrected or retracted.

Were you there? Share your story
Illustration: Photorealistic, cinematic night scene inside a quiet research archive: a tall stack of printed scientific manuscripts with red-pen margin marks on a worn wooden desk, a laboratory microscope and a glass vial rack beside them…
Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Key points

  • NIH asked Nature Medicine to investigate whether Fauci and Collins helped draft the 2020 'Proximal Origin' paper without credit.
  • The letter asks the journal to consider a correction or retraction and to lay out a review plan within 30 days.
  • The authors have long said their conclusions were their own, and Fauci has said he did not edit the paper.
  • A 2024 House report found Fauci 'prompted' the paper; the journal now decides what happens next.

The National Institutes of Health has formally asked the journal Nature Medicine to investigate whether two of the most powerful federal health officials of the pandemic, Dr. Anthony Fauci and Dr. Francis Collins, helped draft one of the most influential scientific papers of the COVID-19 era without their names ever appearing on it, the New York Post reported Wednesday after obtaining the agency's letter [1].

The paper, "The Proximal Origin of SARS-CoV-2," appeared in Nature Medicine in March 2020 and argued against a laboratory origin for the new coronavirus [5]. NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya is asking the journal to examine whether the paper's byline and acknowledgments reflect everyone who substantively contributed to it, and to consider whether it should be corrected or retracted, according to Yahoo News [2].

The research-information organization CASRAI reported that the NIH is seeking a "formal, independent investigation" into allegations of ghostwriting and undisclosed contributions [3]. The paper's acknowledgments credit support from the NIH and Britain's Wellcome Trust, CASRAI noted, but they do not name Fauci, Collins or Jeremy Farrar, who then led the Wellcome Trust [3]. The letter gives the journal 30 days to lay out the scope and timetable of a review, Yahoo News reported [2].

It is worth being precise about what the NIH did and did not say. CASRAI reported that the letter itself does not declare the paper fraudulent, and that the request follows an advisory opinion from the Department of Health and Human Services on disclosing contributions to research, an opinion that specifically referenced this paper [3].

A paper that framed the debate

Five scientists are listed as the authors: Kristian Andersen, Andrew Rambaut, W. Ian Lipkin, Edward Holmes and Robert Garry [2]. Fauci and Collins were not among them. But congressional investigators later obtained communications showing that both men received drafts and took part in discussions about the work, Yahoo News reported [2]. Fauci has said he received drafts but did not edit the manuscript [2].

According to CASRAI's account of the record, the drafting grew out of a February 2020 meeting tied to Farrar, who later offered comments on the manuscript and helped ease its path to publication [3]. That sequence, from a private call among top officials and virologists in the first weeks of the outbreak to a published paper weeks later, has been at the center of the dispute ever since.

House investigators later concluded that the paper was used early in the pandemic to advance the natural-origin explanation [4]. The NIH's letter is, in effect, a request to find out who was in the room when that answer was written.

What Congress found

In December 2024, the House Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic released a 520-page final report after a two-year investigation [4]. The panel said it had sent more than 100 investigative letters, conducted more than 30 transcribed interviews and depositions, held 25 hearings and meetings, and reviewed more than a million pages of documents [4].

The Republican-led subcommittee concluded that the virus most likely emerged from a laboratory in Wuhan, China, pointing to the virus's biological characteristics and to illnesses among researchers at the Wuhan Institute of Virology in the fall of 2019 [4]. On this paper in particular, the report found that Fauci "prompted" it [4].

The panel's findings reached well beyond one article. Its final report was sharply critical of the federal public health response to the pandemic as a whole, the Associated Press reported, and its conclusion on the virus's origin, reached by the Republican-led panel, has been disputed by other agencies and by scientists who favor a natural origin [6]. That split is one reason a review by the journal itself, under its own publishing rules, could carry weight with readers who have tuned out Washington's version of the fight.

What the authors and Fauci have said

The scientists have defended their work, and their side belongs in this story. At a July 2023 House hearing, Andersen and Garry told lawmakers their views changed as evidence came in, including data on features the virus shares with coronaviruses found in nature, Science reported [5]. Andersen testified that there was no connection between the paper's conclusions and a later NIH grant he received, and the authors told Democratic investigators that Fauci and Collins did not lead, oversee or influence the drafting, according to Science [5].

Fauci, appearing before the subcommittee in June 2024, repeated that he did not edit the study or help suppress the lab-leak theory, the Associated Press reported [6].

The underlying scientific question has not been settled either. The AP noted that the U.S. intelligence community has remained split, that the Energy Department assessed a lab leak with "low confidence," and that some researchers have gathered circumstantial evidence pointing to a natural spillover at Wuhan's Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market [6]. Honest people still disagree about where the virus came from. The NIH's letter does not ask the journal to settle that. It asks who helped write a paper that told the world the matter was closed.

Why the byline matters

I spend my days following money and paperwork, and the lesson is always the same: disclosure is not a technicality. In science, a byline tells readers who stands behind a claim. An acknowledgments section tells them who helped and who paid. Readers weigh a paper differently if officials who oversaw federal research funding helped shape its conclusions, and they have a right to know.

That is especially true here. Fauci and Collins were two of the government's top health officials at the time, and NIH money is taxpayer money [2]. When officials at the agencies that fund research may have helped shape a paper that went on to frame a national debate, the public is entitled to the full picture, and the scientific record should show it.

This is not a call to punish scientists for being wrong, or for holding a view many of their peers still share. Plenty of researchers argue for a natural origin in good faith. Accountability is narrower and more important than that: it means the record shows who contributed, so readers can judge the work with all the facts. Journals enforce those rules every day for ordinary researchers, from graduate students to department chairs. The same rules should apply to the powerful, perhaps most of all to them, because their names carry the most weight with the public.

It also matters that the NIH chose the slower, more careful route. Rather than declaring the paper fraudulent, the agency is asking the publisher to run its own independent review under its own standards [3]. That is how a scientific institution should correct the record: openly, in writing, with a deadline, and with the people involved able to respond.

What happens next

The next move belongs to Nature Medicine. CASRAI noted that the journal could open an investigation, attach an editorial notice, issue a correction or leave the paper as it stands [3]. Researchers who have long considered a lab leak more likely have previously asked the journal to retract the paper, according to Yahoo News [2].

Watch for three things in the coming weeks. First, whether the journal answers within the 30 days the NIH requested [2]. Second, whether the five authors respond publicly to the new request, beyond the positions they laid out in 2023 [5]. Third, whether the HHS advisory opinion that preceded the letter is released in full, so the public can read the reasoning for itself [3].

Americans paid a heavy price during the pandemic, in lives, in livelihoods and in trust. Rebuilding that trust will not come from slogans on either side. It will come from records that are complete, from institutions willing to look at their own work, and from a willingness to follow the evidence wherever it leads. A complete account of who shaped this paper would be a good place to start.

Sources

6 reports this article drew on
  1. [1]Opens in a new tab ↗
  2. [2]Opens in a new tab ↗
  3. [3]Opens in a new tab ↗
  4. [4]Opens in a new tab ↗
  5. [5]Opens in a new tab ↗
  6. [6]Opens in a new tab ↗
🗳️ Member poll

Should Florida investigate foreign money in American political groups?

  1. Yes, every state should
  2. Only with hard evidence
  3. Leave it to federal authorities
Join free to vote and see results

0 member votes · Share · All polls

Were you there?

If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.

Members only. Sign in or join free to tell us you were there or share your experience.

Discussion 0

Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.

No comments yet. Start the discussion.