Overnight on Fantasy Huddle with Abby Lawson
Montgomery's 26 Carries, Stroud's Three Scores and a Colts Offense to Avoid: Abby's Fantasy Fallout From Thursday Night in Houston
The Texans' 26-3 rout settled Houston's backfield, rewarded defense streamers and left Jonathan Taylor managers looking at a 21-yard night and a Colts quarterback question.
Filed November 20, 2026 · 📍 Houston, TX 77002
Were you there? Share your story
Part of our continuing coverage: Home at Last: C.J. Stroud's Three Touchdowns and a Smothering Defense Carry the Texans Past the Colts, 26-3
Key points
- David Montgomery returned from a four-game absence and carried 26 times for 107 yards: start him as an RB2
- C.J. Stroud threw three touchdowns on 27 passes; Nico Collins scored from 42 yards out on a light-volume night
- Houston's defense allowed 167 yards and recorded a safety, two sacks and an interception
- Jonathan Taylor was held to 21 yards and Shane Steichen will evaluate the quarterback spot: avoid Colts pass catchers
Thursday night told fantasy managers a lot, and most of it was good news if you roster Houston players. The Texans rolled past the Indianapolis Colts, 26-3, at home, winning in their own building for the first time this season and snapping an 0-4 home skid, according to Fox News [5]. Houston improved to 4-6 and Indianapolis fell to 3-8 [2]. Here is what the box score means for your lineup the rest of the way.
Houston: Trust the Quarterback and the Returning Back
C.J. Stroud was efficient rather than spectacular, completing 21 of 27 passes for 194 yards with three touchdowns and one interception [1][2]. That is three touchdown passes on just 27 throws, and in most scoring formats that is a strong night even without big yardage. He spread the scores around: Nico Collins caught a 42-yard touchdown, Kayshon Boutte caught two passes for 40 yards and a score, and rookie tight end Marlin Klein added a 13-yard touchdown [2][5].
The bigger fantasy story may be David Montgomery. Back from a four-game absence with a groin injury, he carried 26 times for 107 yards, and NFL.com credited him with putting life back into Houston's running game [1]. Twenty-six carries is a workhorse load. Earlier this week I told you he was cleared to play; now we know what his role looks like. Montgomery is a confident RB2 going forward, and he moves up in a big way if Houston keeps playing with leads. If you have been holding Woody Marks, watch the practice reports closely this week before you decide which Texans back to start.
Collins is the one Houston player who might leave you wanting more. He caught three passes for 58 yards [2]. The touchdown saved his night, but the volume was light because Houston did not need to throw. Do not overthink it. Collins remains the top target in this offense and a weekly starter, and blowouts like this one are not the norm.
The Texans Defense Was the Best Play on the Board
If you streamed the Houston defense, you were rewarded. The Colts managed just 167 yards of offense and one field goal, a 34-yarder by Spencer Shrader [2]. Will Anderson Jr. sacked Daniel Jones in the end zone for a safety, Jadeveon Clowney added another sack, and Kamari Lassiter came up with an interception, according to NBC Sports [3]. Houston's defense stays on the streaming radar against weak offenses.
One sad note for IDP leagues and for everyone who loves the game: Texans linebacker Chris Braswell was carted off after a leg injury on the opening kickoff, Fox News reported [6]. We will keep him in our prayers and pass along any update.
Indianapolis: Time to Lower Expectations
This is where Thursday got ugly. In my lineup lock earlier this week I told you to trust Jonathan Taylor and bench Daniel Jones. One of those calls held up. Jones completed 12 of 27 passes for 144 yards with an interception and was sacked twice [2][3]. Taylor, meanwhile, was held to 21 yards on 11 carries [3].
That Taylor line stings, and I own it. But context matters. A running back cannot do much when his offense cannot stay on the field and the scoreboard keeps pushing his team toward the pass. Taylor is still the best player on that offense and the one Colts piece I would keep starting, but he is no longer a set-and-forget RB1 while this offense is this broken. Treat him as a high-end RB2 with a lower floor than you are used to.
The quarterback picture is a bigger worry. Coach Shane Steichen said afterward that he would "evaluate everything," per Colts.com [4], and NBC Sports reported that Anthony Richardson came in for Jones late in the fourth quarter [3]. Until Indianapolis settles on a starter, I would keep every Colts pass catcher out of my lineup unless I had no other choice. Uncertainty at quarterback is poison for receivers.
Abby's Bottom Line
Start Stroud as a QB1 and Montgomery as an RB2. Keep Collins in your lineup without a second thought. Stream the Texans defense when the matchup is right. Lower your expectations for Taylor, avoid the Colts passing game, and keep an eye on the Indianapolis quarterback decision this week.
And if you want a little extra fun before Sunday's kickoffs, our free Liberty Bell Fantasy games are waiting at /fantasy. Set your lineup, invite a few friends and enjoy the rest of Week 11.
Sources
Should athletes keep politics out of the game?
- Yes, just play
- They can speak off the field
- They have every right to speak out
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.