Overnight on From the Bench with Margaret Callahan
A Christmas Greeting Is Not an Established Church: Why USDA Is Right to Fight the Ruling on Rollins' Holiday Messages
A federal judge says the Agriculture secretary's Christmas and Easter emails likely crossed a line. History, the Supreme Court's own test and the government's workplace rules point the other way, and USDA is weighing a prompt appeal.
Filed November 20, 2026 · 📍 Supreme Court, DC 20543
Were you there? Share your story
Key points
- Judge Trina Thompson issued a preliminary injunction finding Brooke Rollins' Christmas and Easter emails likely violated the Establishment Clause.
- USDA called the order an unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet secretary and is weighing a prompt appeal.
- The order still lets Rollins discuss her faith with interested colleagues and leaves her personal capacity untouched.
- The Supreme Court's 2022 Kennedy v. Bremerton ruling tells courts to judge religious expression by the nation's history and tradition.
The Agriculture Department is fighting back. After a federal judge on Thursday ordered Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins to rein in the religious messages she has sent to employees from her official email account, the department called the ruling a "completely unprecedented attempt to muzzle a Cabinet Secretary" and said it was weighing all of its options, including a prompt appeal, the Associated Press reported [2]. The Jerusalem Post, carrying the Reuters account, reported the same response [4].
What the Judge Ruled
U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson granted a preliminary injunction in a lawsuit brought by USDA employees and their union, the National Federation of Federal Employees, who argued that Rollins' messages violated the First Amendment's Establishment Clause, the AP reported [2]. NBC News reported the judge's finding under the headline that the emails were unconstitutional [1].
It is worth being precise about what the judge actually found, because many headlines were not. The Hill reported that Thompson found the secretary's religious holiday messages likely violated the First Amendment, a preliminary finding rather than a final ruling [3]. The messages at issue were tied to Christmas and Easter [3]. In explaining her order, the judge pointed to Rollins' position of authority, her use of an official account and language suggesting that Christianity was the shared faith of the department's workforce, according to the AP [2].
The order itself is narrower than the coverage suggests. Rollins must stop sending religious messages to a colleague who asks her to stop, and she may still talk about her faith with interested colleagues in appropriate conversations, the AP reported [2]. Those terms were drawn from a workplace religious-expression policy that Rollins herself adopted at USDA [2]. The judge also dismissed the employees' claims under the Administrative Procedure Act and said the ruling expresses no view on what Rollins may do in her personal capacity, The Hill reported [3].
The Answer: History, the Constitution and Common Sense
Start with the calendar. Christmas has been a federal holiday by law since 1870. Every federal employee, including every employee who sued, gets that day off. A Cabinet secretary who says why the day matters to her is not establishing a national church. She is explaining a holiday the government already observes.
Then look at history. George Washington's first Thanksgiving proclamation in 1789 called on Americans to give thanks to Almighty God. Abraham Lincoln did the same in the middle of the Civil War. Congress has opened its sessions with a chaplain's prayer since the First Congress. American leaders have spoken of faith in public life from the founding to today, and the Republic has never had an established church.
The Supreme Court has said that history is the right guide. In Kennedy v. Bremerton School District in 2022, the Court sided with a high school football coach who prayed on the field, set aside the old Lemon test and told lower courts to read the Establishment Clause in light of the nation's historical practices and understandings, the Christian Science Monitor reported at the time [6]. Holiday greetings that invoke Christmas and Easter fit comfortably within that tradition.
The federal government's own rules point the same way. In July 2025, the Office of Personnel Management issued guidance to protect religious expression in the federal workplace, affirming that employees may discuss their faith with co-workers, display religious items and wear religious symbols, so long as the conduct does not become harassment [5]. The judge's order, by borrowing USDA's own policy, quietly concedes much of the same ground: faith conversations at work are allowed, and colleagues who are not interested can say no [2][5].
There is a fair concern on the other side, and it deserves an honest answer. A boss's words carry weight, and no employee should feel pressure to share a supervisor's religion to keep a job. That is a reason for a clear opt-out, which USDA's own policy already provides. It is not a reason to treat a Christmas message as a constitutional violation.
Who Is Pushing Back, and What Comes Next
The department has signaled it may take the case to a higher court quickly [2][4]. An appeal would ask a basic question: does the First Amendment, written to protect religious liberty, require a Christian public servant to scrub her faith from a holiday greeting?
The employees and their union have every right to make their case in court. But millions of Americans of faith, including many who work for the federal government, will see in this ruling a familiar pattern: a public official punished not for coercing anyone, but for saying out loud what Christmas and Easter mean to her.
Scripture tells believers to always be ready to give an answer for the hope that is in them, with gentleness and respect. Nothing in the Constitution asks Christians in public service to do less.
Sources
- [1]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [2]KSAT (Associated Press)Judge says agriculture secretary's religious emails were unconstitutionalOpens in a new tab ↗
- [3]Opens in a new tab ↗
- [4]The Jerusalem PostJudge orders US agriculture chief to stop sending religious emails from official accountOpens in a new tab ↗
- [5]U.S. Office of Personnel ManagementOPM Issues Guidance to Protect Religious Expression in the Federal WorkplaceOpens in a new tab ↗
- [6]Christian Science MonitorPrayer on the 50-yard line: Supreme Court reshapes church-state relationshipOpens in a new tab ↗
Have you ever been censored or shadow-banned on social media?
- Yes
- I think so
- No
- I'm not on social media
Were you there?
If you were at the scene, or this story touched your life, tell us what you saw and what it was like.



Discussion 0
Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.
No comments yet. Start the discussion.