‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

World News

Kim Wants His Nukes Recognized. The White House Won't Budge

A Wall Street Journal report says North Korea's demands sank a summit before the President's Asia trip; an administration official says no meeting was ever being arranged, and Washington's denuclearization goal stands.

By GRACE WHITFIELDStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 22, 6:34 AM · 2 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic, cinematic dusk scene at the Korean Demilitarized Zone: a long empty negotiating table inside a plain blue conference hut, two empty chairs facing each other, unused microphones, a small American flag on a…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

North Korea's price for a meeting with President Trump was recognition as a nuclear power, and Washington would not pay it, according to a Wall Street Journal report summarized Sunday by Korea JoongAng Daily, The Asia Business Daily and Aju Press. A Trump administration official disputed the account, telling the paper that no effort had been made to arrange a summit, and the White House said its policy toward Pyongyang had not changed.

What the Report Says

According to the Journal's account, U.S. officials explored a meeting with Kim Jong Un around the APEC summit in Shenzhen before the President left for Asia. Among the ideas reportedly weighed were a declaration formally ending the 1950-53 Korean War and a statement that would neither recognize North Korea as a nuclear-armed state nor require it to dismantle its program, in exchange for limits on nuclear and missile tests.

The effort stalled, the report said, because North Korea insisted on being accepted as a nuclear power and on an end to what it calls Washington's hostile policy. Kim never appeared in Shenzhen, and Pyongyang has made no public reply to the President's offers.

The President had openly floated a meeting as he set out on the trip, telling reporters on Nov. 16 that a sit-down with Kim in China could happen, The Washington Post reported. Days later, the United States publicly restated that its goal remains the complete denuclearization of North Korea, Seoul Economic Daily reported.

Talking Is Not Conceding

The record here matters more than the spin. Offering to talk to an adversary is not the same as giving him what he wants, and the line Washington drew is the right one: no stamp of approval on a nuclear arsenal built in violation of United Nations resolutions and paid for by a regime that lets its own people go hungry.

The end-of-war declaration is not a new idea. South Korea's government pressed the United States to adopt one in 2018, during the first round of summitry between the President and Kim, Al Jazeera reported at the time. Then, as now, the sticking point was whether Pyongyang would take real steps on its weapons.

This President has walked away from a bad deal with Kim before, in Hanoi in 2019, and the door to diplomacy stayed open afterward. Strength and patience, not concessions, are what bring a dictator to the table.

What Comes Next

The White House has not said whether it will make a new approach to Pyongyang, and North Korea has given no sign it will drop its demand for recognition. For America's allies in Seoul and Tokyo, the message from Washington so far is the one they wanted to hear: the goal is still a North Korea without nuclear weapons.

Sources

  1. Korea JoongAng Daily: Trump sought Kim summit before Asia trip, but North Korea's conditions blocked progress: Report (link)
  2. The Asia Business Daily: Trump Sought Summit with Kim Jong Un, Even Considering an 'End-of-War Declaration'; North Korean Demands Scuttled Talks (link)
  3. Aju Press: North Korean demands derailed Trump-Kim meeting (link)
  4. The Washington Post: Trump floats meeting with Kim Jong Un while in Asia (link)
  5. Seoul Economic Daily: U.S. Reaffirms Goal of North Korea's Full Denuclearization (link)
  6. Al Jazeera: Moon Jae-in urges US to declare end of war with North Korea (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous page'Brexit Is Done': Theresa May Tells Andy Burnham to Accept…Turn the pageFires, Funerals and a Planned Homecoming: Bangladesh Braces…