‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

World News

An Article 5-Style Shield for Ukraine? The Hard Questions Behind Kushner's Berlin Claim

U.S. envoy Jared Kushner says Russia is comfortable with NATO-style security guarantees for Ukraine, and European leaders say they are united and ready to talk. Whether any promise can be enforced, and on whose terms, will decide whether a peace holds.

By DOMINIC KANEStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 19, 10:00 PM · 6 min. read

Illustration: The Brandenburg Gate in Berlin at dusk, its sandstone columns glowing warm gold against a deep blue winter sky, a long polished negotiating table set on the cobblestones in the foreground with rows of empty chairs on both…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

President Trump's envoys arrived in Berlin on Thursday carrying the boldest claim yet in the long search for an end to Russia's war on Ukraine. Fresh from Trump's three-way summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin, U.S. envoy Jared Kushner said he believes Moscow can accept security guarantees for a postwar Ukraine modeled on NATO's Article 5, PBS News reported, quoting him as saying Washington had "gotten the Russians comfortable with that concept".

If that proves true, it would be a genuine turn in a war now nearly five years old. But Americans who believe in peace through strength know that a promise is only as good as the power and the will standing behind it. The questions that follow will decide whether this moment produces a lasting peace or one more piece of paper.

What Kushner said in Berlin

Kushner and fellow envoy Steve Witkoff traveled to the German capital to reassure dozens of European leaders about the president's talks with Putin and Xi, according to the Associated Press report carried by PBS. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky joined the meetings, and Kushner said Trump himself phoned in after his session with Putin.

Kushner attached two conditions. Trump is open to an Article 5-style guarantee, he said, but it has to serve America's interest and it has to be part of a broader security package. He also said the president wants any deal with Russia to involve Europe, the BBC reported. The Berlin summit itself focused on winter support for Ukraine and on coordinating plans for upcoming multilateral peace talks, according to the Kyiv Independent.

The same PBS report supplied the necessary caution. It was not immediately clear what form the guarantees would take, or whether Russia and Ukraine would ultimately accept them, and the most recent round of talks in Abu Dhabi last week produced no major breakthrough. In plain terms, this is Kushner's reading of Moscow's position, not a signed commitment from the Kremlin.

What an Article 5-style promise would and would not mean

The phrase matters because Article 5 is the mutual-defense heart of the NATO alliance, and the guarantees Kushner described are, in the words of the PBS headline, NATO-like. The question is how much of that model would carry over.

Here is what it would likely mean. Zelensky said in late October that Ukraine was negotiating detailed guarantees with Washington modeled on Article 5, and that he wants them approved by Congress, the Kyiv Post reported. He described three layers meant to work together: NATO membership, bilateral American guarantees, and a European-led Coalition of the Willing backed by the United States. A guarantee modeled on Article 5 would fit that second layer, a commitment from Washington written to resemble the alliance's promise.

Here is what it would not mean. By Zelensky's own framework, a bilateral guarantee is not the same thing as joining NATO. That larger question remains open; in Berlin, French President Emmanuel Macron urged allies to revisit Ukraine's NATO membership, the BBC reported. Nor is the scope settled. Kushner's condition that any pledge serve American interests signals that Washington intends to define its own obligations carefully, and Secretary of State Marco Rubio has said the question of formalizing the guarantees had not yet been discussed in detail, according to the Kyiv Independent.

Why Ukrainians do not trust paper

Ukraine has been here before. Zelensky has said he wants a congressionally approved guarantee precisely so his country does not repeat the 1994 Budapest Memorandum, which he described as non-binding, the Kyiv Post reported. That arrangement traded Ukraine's nuclear arsenal for assurances rather than an enforceable defense commitment.

That history is why the word "assurance" stings in Kyiv, and why the difference between a pledge and a treaty is not a lawyer's quibble. Rubio did not rule out formalizing the guarantees in a separate agreement. If the United States is going to make a promise of this weight, it should be made the way the Constitution intends for serious commitments: in the open, debated by the people's elected representatives, and ratified, not improvised by envoys.

The recent record is not encouraging either. Zelensky said Putin has rejected every proposal put to him so far, the BBC reported, and the Abu Dhabi round ended without a major breakthrough.

Europe's united front and Trump's doubts

European leaders used Berlin to show resolve. They said they are ready for talks with Russia on ending the war, the BBC reported, and British Prime Minister Andy Burnham described a "clear, consistent and united negotiating position". German Chancellor Friedrich Merz called Moscow's maximalist demands unrealistic and said Europe would take up serious talks with Russia on wider European security only after a peace agreement with Ukraine, on terms acceptable to Europe and Kyiv. Macron pressed allies to give Ukraine the air defenses it needs.

There is an obvious obstacle. Putin has so far rejected any European role in the U.S.-led talks, according to the BBC. European governments, for their part, have tried to isolate Putin and have heavily sanctioned Russia's economy, and they fear being sidelined by Trump's direct dealings with him, PBS reported.

Trump brought his own hard question. Calling into the Berlin meeting from Air Force One after the Shenzhen summit, held on the sidelines of the APEC gathering, he insisted Putin was serious about peace negotiations and asked why the allies keep spending billions on military support for Kyiv, Euronews reported. That account traces to a Politico report based on four European officials briefed on the call, three of whom described his skepticism about further aid, and it rests on unnamed sources.

The president's question is a fair one for any taxpayer, and burden-sharing has long been a conservative principle. Europe is next door to this war, and it should carry the larger share of the load. But there is a difference between asking allies to do more and easing pressure on Moscow before it signs anything. Leverage spent before a deal is leverage lost.

The hard questions: enforcement, territory and trust

Enforcement comes first. Who would act if Russian forces crossed a new ceasefire line, and how fast? Kushner's conditions and the open questions about the form of the guarantees mean the answer has not been written. Rubio has also said any guarantee must be acceptable to Russia for it to work, while calling guarantees critical to Kyiv accepting a deal, the Kyiv Independent reported. There is realism in that view: a settlement Moscow rejects is no settlement at all. But a protection the aggressor helps design must be read line by line, because its weak points will be the ones Moscow chose.

Territory is the hardest knot. Merz's charge that Russia's demands are maximalist and the lack of a breakthrough in Abu Dhabi suggest the map, more than the guarantee, may be the real sticking point. Nothing reported from Berlin indicates that the two sides have agreed on where the lines would fall.

Trust sits underneath everything. Kushner says Moscow is comfortable with an Article 5-style shield, while the BBC reports that Putin still rejects a European seat at the table. Both positions cannot hold for long. The test is simple: will the Kremlin say yes in public, in writing, with Europe in the room?

Zelensky offered his own answer on leverage. After the Berlin talks, he told reporters that the United States and China could end the war by cutting off trade with Russia, and he argued that the chances of peace are high if Washington truly presses Putin, the Kyiv Independent reported. He added that a lasting deal depends partly on how much economic pressure is brought to bear on Moscow. That is a peace-through-strength argument, and it deserves a serious hearing in Washington, because economic pressure costs no American lives.

What comes next

The next step is the multilateral round the Berlin meeting was meant to prepare, with Kushner saying the president wants Europe involved. Three things are worth watching. First, whether Moscow confirms Kushner's account in its own words, since it remains unclear whether Russia will accept the guarantees. Second, whether any American guarantee goes to Congress, as Zelensky has asked. Third, whether European aid keeps flowing while the talks go on, despite the president's doubts.

Peace is worth pursuing hard, and the president deserves credit for pressing every party toward the table. Scripture says, "Blessed are the peacemakers." But a just peace for Ukraine has to be one that lasts, and that means a guarantee with teeth, approved in the open and backed by enough strength that Moscow never again doubts it.

Sources

  1. PBS News: Kushner says Russia is 'comfortable' with NATO-like security guarantees for Ukraine to end war after Trump talks with Putin (link)
  2. BBC News: Europe ready for talks with Russia on ending war in Ukraine, leaders say (link)
  3. Euronews: Trump questions Europe's billions in Ukraine aid during surprise call (link)
  4. Kyiv Independent: Zelensky tells world superpowers how they can end Russia's war against Ukraine (link)
  5. Kyiv Independent: Security guarantees for Ukraine must also be acceptable to Russia, Rubio says (link)
  6. Kyiv Post: Kyiv Seeks Congress-Backed US Security Guarantees, Not Another Budapest Memorandum (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Le Pen Vows Retirement at 60 for Early Starters

The National Rally leader's plan would undo Macron's move to 64, let long-career workers leave between 60 and 62, and add a mandatory savings account. A center-right rival is promising 65.

By GRACE WHITFIELDWorld News · Nov 19, 10:46 PM

FBI: Patel Was in the Field as His Deputy Testified

The FBI said its director was visiting offices in four states during the House Homeland Security Committee's worldwide threats hearing. The panel's Republican chairman said the job was Patel's.

By LAUREN PIERCEPolitics · Nov 19, 10:41 PM

Previous pageLe Pen Vows Retirement at 60 for Early StartersTurn the pageTaking Back the Road South: Haiti's Forces Storm Martissant…