‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Technology

Facts Over Fear: Steady, Evidence-First Leadership Is Carrying America Through a Week of Outages

Critics say the administration is deflecting blame. The record shows officials who checked the evidence, told Americans the truth about the outages and went to work on the fixes.

By RYAN MERCERStaff Correspondent · HAWAII · Nov 18, 11:24 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Sunrise over a major American airport: an air traffic control tower glowing gold in the first light, a calm line of jetliners waiting on the taxiway, an American flag rippling on a pole in the foreground, and in a lit…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

A week of technology failures, from the FAA's nationwide ground stop to bank logins, Microsoft's outage and Apple's services, has given critics an easy storyline. PBS NewsHour framed the administration's response as an effort to deflect responsibility for the ground stop, even as it asks for tens of billions of dollars to repair air traffic control. The record shows something better: leaders who went looking for evidence, said plainly what they found, and moved to fix what broke.

Ryan Mercer, Big Tech and AI policy

Secretary of State Marco Rubio said there is "zero evidence" the outages are connected, and told Americans the nation is not facing a systemic attack. Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton gave the same answer on CNBC, saying the disruptions were neither a cyberattack nor a nation-state campaign. Rubio then did something rare in Washington: he offered a serious explanation. According to The New York Times, he suggested that companies and agencies racing to patch weaknesses newly exposed by artificial intelligence may account for failures in air travel, banking and government systems. That is the real story of this moment. AI is finding holes faster than ever, and the fixes themselves can break things. Saying so is leadership, not deflection.

Hannah Lindgren, space and science

Good science starts with data, not with the scariest theory trending online. That is how the Transportation Department handled the ground stop. Secretary Sean Duffy traced the start of the disruption to a router in Arkansas, the Honolulu Star-Advertiser reported, giving investigators a specific place to begin instead of a vague fear. Duffy has also gone after the contractor's role and vowed that people will be held accountable, The Air Current reported. Find the fault, test it, fix it and say what you learned: that is the same method that lands rockets and keeps satellites flying, and it is the right one for the systems that keep a nation of travelers moving.

Jake Morrison, the trading floor

On the floor, fear has a price, and this week we saw it. A Wall Street analyst reported a surge of panic buying at Costco after the string of outages, according to CBS News, with shoppers stocking up on emergency supplies. Panic is contagious, and it feeds on silence and rumor. That is why it mattered that the nation's top diplomat and its intelligence chief went on the record quickly with what the evidence showed. Markets, like families, can handle bad news. What they cannot handle is not knowing. Clear, factual answers from the people in charge are worth more than any hot take.

Victoria Chen, stocks and the Fed

The bank scare is a good example of why facts beat fear. When customers at several large banks had trouble logging in, Chase told the Associated Press it was dealing with a technical bug, not a cyber issue, and said customers still had access to their accounts and their money. That is the most important fact for any saver: the money was there. Modern banking runs on enormously complex software, and glitches happen. What reassures depositors is quick disclosure, and what steadies markets is officials who refuse to fan speculation without evidence. On both counts, this week passed the test.

Kendall Price, crypto and payments

Tuesday's Apple outage hit Apple Pay, iCloud and the App Store, and the company said an internal update caused it, The Washington Times reported. A software change gone wrong, explained openly by the company, is the kind of honest accounting the payments world needs. For families, the lesson is practical and old-fashioned: keep a backup way to pay, whether a second card or a little cash in your wallet. For policymakers, it is a reminder that resilience comes from redundancy and candor, not from assuming the worst about every glitch.

Kevin Nakamura, waste, fraud and investigations

Accountability is the right answer, and it is coming from the top. Duffy has pressed the contractor involved in the ground stop and promised consequences. Taxpayers deserve the same discipline on the money. Yahoo News reported that the FAA is seeking about $50 billion after the ground stop while some $11 billion it already has sits unspent. A watchdog's advice is simple: put the money already on hand to work quickly and transparently, tie new dollars to results, and hold every contractor to its promises. That is how a modern, reliable air traffic system gets built.

America had a hard week, but not a dangerous one. The people in charge followed the evidence, told the truth and went to work on the fixes. That is a record worth defending.

Sources

  1. PBS NewsHour: Trump administration seeks to deflect responsibility for nationwide ground stop (link)
  2. BBC News: Rubio says US not 'under systemic attack' after series of tech outages (link)
  3. The New York Times: Cause of Recent Tech Outages Isn't Hackers, Rubio Says (link)
  4. CNBC: Jay Clayton on recent tech outages: 'This is not a cyber attack' (link)
  5. Honolulu Star-Advertiser: Transportation Secretary Duffy points to Arkansas router as start of ground stop (link)
  6. The Washington Times: Apple service outage linked to internal update amid tech disruptions (link)
  7. Associated Press (via WRAL): Customers at some of the nation's largest banks are reporting difficulty accessing accounts online (link)
  8. CBS News: Costco sees surge in panic buying after tech outages, report says (link)
  9. Yahoo News: FAA seeks $50 billion after nationwide ground stop. But $11 billion sits unspent. (link)
  10. The Air Current: Duffy slams L3Harris for role in nationwide ground stop, vowing to hold people accountable (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageNvidia Halts Its Licensed Hopper Chip Shipments to China as…Turn the pageCongress's Watchdog Got Four Top Chatbots to Plan Attacks…