‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Sports

Two Arms for the Mountains: The Rockies Land Luis Castillo and Davis Martin From the White Sox for Rookie Sean Sullivan

Colorado takes on a three-time All-Star's salary and adds a 28-start right-hander, while Chicago adds youth two days after agreeing to terms with Dustin May.

By CONNOR MAGUIREStaff Correspondent · ILLINOIS · Nov 20, 7:35 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: A clean white baseball resting on the pitching rubber of an empty mountain ballpark at golden hour, a worn brown leather glove beside it, snow-capped Rocky Mountain peaks glowing pink in the distance beyond the outfield…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

The hot stove finally reached Denver. The Colorado Rockies acquired right-handers Luis Castillo and Davis Martin from the Chicago White Sox on Thursday, sending rookie left-hander Sean Sullivan and minor-league catcher Douglas Veliz the other way, the New York Post reported.

ESPN's Jeff Passan was first to report the deal, according to MLB Trade Rumors. For a franchise that has spent years searching for pitchers who can hold up over a full season at altitude, the message is clear: the Rockies want innings, and they are willing to pay for them.

What Colorado Gets

Castillo is the bigger name. The veteran is a three-time All-Star, but 2026 was a rough year. He opened the season in Seattle, where he carried a 5.06 ERA over 99 2/3 innings before the Mariners sent him to Chicago at the trade deadline in a four-player swap that brought right-hander Seranthony Dominguez, outfielder Nolan Jones and catcher Boston Smith to Seattle, according to theScore.

The change of scenery did not help. Reports on Thursday's deal said Castillo posted an 8.42 ERA in nine appearances for the White Sox. Colorado is still taking on his full salary, which MLB Trade Rumors put at $22.75 million.

Martin is the steadier piece. The right-hander made 28 starts for Chicago in 2026, going 9-8 with a 3.95 ERA over 146 innings, per MLB Trade Rumors. His season came in two very different halves: Fox Sports noted he was 9-4 with a 3.41 ERA in an All-Star-caliber first half before going 0-4 with a 5.12 ERA after it.

What Chicago Gets

For the White Sox, the deal turns two veteran arms into a rookie left-hander and a catching prospect. It also comes two days after Chicago agreed to a three-year, $52.5 million contract with right-hander Dustin May, according to the Chicago Sun-Times, a sign that the front office is reshaping its rotation rather than simply shedding salary.

The Post described Sullivan as a rookie left-hander, and Colorado is giving him up to make the move. For a club that needs every arm it can develop, that is a real cost, and it shows Colorado's front office believes two proven starters are worth more right now than one promising one.

Connor's Take

I like this trade for Colorado more than the box scores suggest. Pitching at altitude wears staffs down, and a rebuilding club cannot develop its young hitters if its bullpen is warming up in the fourth inning every night. Martin took the ball 28 times last season, and durability is its own kind of talent in Denver. Even his rough second half came after what Fox Sports called an All-Star-caliber first half.

Castillo is the gamble. A pitcher who has made three All-Star teams does not forget how to pitch overnight, but a season that began with a 5.06 ERA in Seattle and got worse in Chicago is a warning sign, and the Rockies are paying a premium salary to find out which version shows up. If he finds his old command, Colorado has a veteran who can show young pitchers how to compete every fifth day. If not, it is an expensive lesson.

There is something old-fashioned about the bet, and I mean that as a compliment. Plenty of rebuilding teams treat the major-league roster as an afterthought while they wait on prospects. Colorado is saying its fans deserve competitive baseball now, and that young players learn best when the veterans around them set a professional standard.

For the White Sox, it is a sensible piece of business. They add youth at two positions and clear room days after committing to May. Rebuilds are won by stacking young talent and spending wisely when the window opens, and Chicago did a little of both this week.

What Comes Next

The Rockies now have two new veterans for their 2027 rotation, and the next question is whether they add a left-hander after shipping one out. The White Sox, meanwhile, have made two significant pitching moves in three days, and the market for starting pitching is just getting started. Both clubs moved early. The rest of the league is on notice that this winter's shopping season is already underway.

Sources

  1. New York Post: Rockies acquire pair of pitchers in major trade with White Sox (link)
  2. MLB Trade Rumors: White Sox Trade Davis Martin, Luis Castillo To Rockies (link)
  3. Denver7: Rockies acquire three-time All-Star Luis Castillo, Davis Martin in trade with White Sox (link)
  4. Fox Sports: Grading MLB's Biggest Offseason Deals, Including Maikel Garcia To Mariners (link)
  5. theScore: White Sox land Castillo from Mariners in 4-player trade (link)
  6. Chicago Sun-Times: White Sox sign Dustin May to $52.5 million deal to bolster starting rotation (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Brexit Reset Sealed in Brussels as Farage Cries Betrayal

Prime Minister Andy Burnham signs food, carbon-market and youth deals with the EU a decade after Britain voted to leave. Tuition fees are still unsettled, and the Brexit fight is back.

By GRACE WHITFIELDWorld News · Nov 20, 8:32 AM

Previous pageFifteen Cases on File: Police Records Back Deion Sanders'…Turn the pageOne Game, Then the Bench: LSU's President Orders Will Wade…