‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Sports

The Men Who Build Rosters Have Spoken: NFL Executives Make Joe Burrow Their Runaway Midseason MVP and Kyle Shanahan Their Coach of the Year

Sports Illustrated's poll of 27 league evaluators gave Burrow 22 MVP votes, put Jahmyr Gibbs atop the offensive ballot and named 49ers general manager John Lynch the executive of the year.

By DARNELL HAYESStaff Correspondent · OHIO · Nov 20, 7:55 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: A floodlit, empty professional football stadium at twilight seen from the sideline, a single brown leather football resting on the 50-yard line, and in the foreground a wooden clipboard holding a blank paper ballot with a pen…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Fans argue about awards on talk radio every week. The people who actually run NFL front offices usually keep their opinions to themselves. Once a year, at the midpoint of the season, Albert Breer of Sports Illustrated gets them to talk, and this year's answers came back with unusual clarity.

Breer surveyed 27 league evaluators, most of them general managers and senior personnel executives, on the season's major honors. On the biggest one, it was not close.

Burrow Runs Away With It

Cincinnati quarterback Joe Burrow received 22 of the 27 MVP votes. Athlon Sports noted that Burrow also owns the league's best grade from Pro Football Focus, a sign that the film and the box scores are telling the same story. According to Sports Illustrated's numbers, as cited by Newsweek, Burrow is on pace for a 5,279-yard, 51-touchdown season.

When roughly four out of five executives land on the same player in November, that is not a hunch. It is a consensus built by people who grade tape for a living.

Shanahan and Lynch Get Their Due in San Francisco

Coach of the Year went to the 49ers' Kyle Shanahan, who drew 15 votes. Jacksonville's Liam Coen finished second with 5.5 votes, and Cleveland's Todd Monken was third with four. Joe Brady and Brian Flores each received one vote, and John Harbaugh got half a vote.

Heavy noted that San Francisco was 8-1 when the ballots were cast. The front office was honored, too. General manager John Lynch was named the midseason Executive of the Year, and Jacksonville general manager James Gladstone tied for second with four votes, one behind Lynch.

Gibbs on Top, and a Pair of Browns Rookies Lead Their Class

On offense, Detroit running back Jahmyr Gibbs topped the Offensive Player of the Year ballot with 12 votes, ahead of Seattle receiver Jaxon Smith-Njigba with eight.

The rookie race had a distinctly Cleveland flavor. Browns receiver Denzel Boston was voted Offensive Rookie of the Year with 15.5 votes, and teammate KC Concepcion finished second with six. For a franchise that has spent years searching for answers, two rookie receivers finishing one-two in a poll of rival executives is the kind of news that gives a fan base hope.

Darnell's Take

Polls like this matter because of who is voting. These are the men and women who spend their weeks grinding through film, building rosters and deciding who gets paid. They have no reason to flatter anyone, and plenty of reason to be right, because their jobs depend on judging talent correctly.

What I like most about this ballot is what it rewards. Shanahan and Lynch have kept the 49ers near the top of the league by sticking to a plan: draft well, develop players, coach them hard and hold them to a standard. Coen and Gladstone drew real support in Jacksonville, and Monken's showing tells you executives have noticed what is happening in Cleveland. None of that is luck. It is the slow, unglamorous work of building something that lasts.

There is a lesson here for young players and the parents raising them. Not one of these honors comes from a highlight clip or a viral celebration. They come from the things coaches and scouts see every day when no camera is rolling: practice habits, preparation, accountability and how a man carries himself when things go wrong. That is the kind of character executives bet their careers on, and it is the kind worth teaching at every level of the game.

What Comes Next

Midseason polls are snapshots, not verdicts. Burrow's pace, Shanahan's 8-1 start and Gibbs' lead on the offensive ballot will all be tested over the final two months of the regular season, and injuries and late-season slumps have rearranged plenty of award races before.

For now, the people who know the game best have made their picks clear. Cincinnati's quarterback is the man to catch, San Francisco's coach and general manager have the respect of their peers, and Cleveland has two young receivers its rivals are already watching closely.

Sources

  1. Sports Illustrated: NFL Executives Vote on 2026 Midseason MVP, Coach of the Year, More Awards (link)
  2. Athlon Sports: Will Joe Burrow Be NFL MVP? Executives Give Bengals QB 22 of 27 Midseason Votes (link)
  3. Newsweek: NFL Executives Have One Player in Mind For MVP, And It's a No Brainer (link)
  4. Heavy: NFL Executives Send Clear Message to 49ers HC Kyle Shanahan (link)
  5. Yahoo Sports: NFL Executives Give Jaguars' Liam Coen, James Gladstone Votes in Midseason Awards Poll (link)
  6. Yahoo Sports: NFL Executives Pick Browns WR Denzel Boston for Midseason Offensive Rookie of the Year (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageSportsTurn the pageOwning the Mistake: Manon Fiorot Accepts a Three-Month…