‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Sports

Richardson's Legs, Taylor's Workload and a Long Week to Plan: Abby's Fantasy Take on the Colts' Quarterback Change

Indianapolis cut Daniel Jones and handed the job back to Anthony Richardson Sr. Here is how to handle your Colts before their Nov. 29 date with the Giants.

By ABBY LAWSONStaff Correspondent · INDIANA · Nov 20, 4:50 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration: A fantasy football draft board scene in a cozy den at night: a large corkboard covered in blank colored index cards and pushpins, a laptop glowing with an abstract stat chart, a notepad with handwritten arrows and circles (no…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

The Indianapolis Colts made the quarterback decision for us. Less than a day after a 26-3 loss in Houston, the Colts released Daniel Jones and named Anthony Richardson Sr. their starting quarterback, NFL.com reported. Richardson's first start comes at home against the New York Giants on Nov. 29, according to OutKick.

That gives fantasy managers something rare in November: a full week and a half to think before the Colts play again. Let's use it.

What Changed in Indianapolis

Coach Shane Steichen announced the move less than 24 hours after another rough night for the offense, and Yahoo Sports reported that the Colts will use the rest of the season to find out whether Richardson fits into their rebuild. Jones leaves after leading the NFL with 13 interceptions, OutKick noted.

The New York Post framed this as what may be Richardson's last real chance to show the Colts, and the rest of the league, that he can be a starting quarterback. He lost the job to Jones in training camp last year, a competition CBS Sports covered closely at the time. Now he gets six games to rewrite that story.

One piece of the offense did not move. The Colts kept three-time Pro Bowl running back Jonathan Taylor through all of the roster shuffling, Fox Sports reported.

Abby's Plan for Richardson

Richardson has always been a different kind of fantasy quarterback. His appeal is in his legs and his big arm, not in completion percentage. A quarterback who can run for a touchdown gives you a floor even on days when the passing game sputters, and that is exactly the profile that wins weeks in fantasy.

Here is how I would handle him:

In one-quarterback leagues, he is a watch-list player, not a must-add. The Colts' offense has struggled badly, and I want to see one start before trusting him in a playoff push.

In superflex and two-quarterback leagues, put in a claim now. Starting quarterbacks with rushing upside are hard to find this late in the season, and the cost of adding him during a week when the Colts are idle is low.

In dynasty leagues, this is the most important stretch of his career. If he plays well, his value jumps. If he does not, the Colts will likely look elsewhere next spring, so sell any shares you can if a manager in your league is buying the redemption story.

Abby's Plan for Jonathan Taylor

Keep starting him. Taylor's value comes from volume, and a quarterback change does not take carries away from a three-time Pro Bowler.

There is one wrinkle worth knowing. A CBS Sports fantasy analysis from the 2025 preseason found that Taylor averaged 16.6 points per game in point-per-reception scoring across nine games with Richardson under center, but that he was largely absent from the passing game in those weeks. In other words, expect Taylor's production to lean on rushing yards and touchdowns rather than catches. In full-PPR formats that trims his ceiling a little, but his floor stays strong. A running quarterback can also open lanes for the back by forcing defenses to account for him on every play.

The Receivers and the Rest

The Colts sold off much of their supporting cast at the trade deadline while holding on to Taylor, and the passing game has been hard to trust all season. Until Richardson shows he can sustain drives, I am not chasing any Colts receiver in redraft leagues. If one breaks out against the Giants, we will talk about it in the waiver column the following Monday.

The Bottom Line

The Colts already played their Week 11 game on Thursday night, so there is no Colts lineup decision to make this Sunday. The work is all on the waiver wire and the trade market. Add Richardson where quarterbacks are scarce, keep Taylor in your lineup and be patient with everyone else.

As always, you can put these plans to work in the free Liberty Bell Fantasy games at /fantasy. I will be back with Week 12 start and sit calls once the Colts and Giants put out their first injury reports.

Sources

  1. NFL.com: Colts waive Daniel Jones, name Anthony Richardson new starting quarterback (link)
  2. Fox News: Indianapolis Colts cut NFL interception leader Daniel Jones and give starting QB job to Anthony Richardson (link)
  3. Yahoo Sports: Colts decide to make quarterback change and will release Daniel Jones as offensive woes continue (link)
  4. Fox Sports: That's A Wrap: Colts Coach Shane Steichen Reveals Team Cut Daniel Jones (link)
  5. New York Post: Anthony Richardson gets final Colts' chance after ominous NFL evaluation (link)
  6. CBS Sports: Fantasy Football: Daniel Jones named Colts starter and Jonathan Taylor is primed to benefit the most (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageSportsTurn the pageFive Arms, One Trophy: Arch Manning Joins CJ Carr, Gunner…