Sports
Pitch, Score, Go for Two: Rutgers Stuns Penn State, 25-24, on the Final Play for Its First Win in the Series Since 1988
Antwan Raymond flipped the ball to Ben Black III at the goal line as time ran out, and Greg Schiano passed on overtime to end an 18-game losing streak in State College.
By WADE MCALLISTERStaff Correspondent · NEW YORK · Nov 21, 11:20 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
For 38 years, the Penn State game was the one Rutgers could not win. On Saturday in State College, the Scarlet Knights finally won it, and they did it on a play few people inside Beaver Stadium will ever forget. Trailing 24-17 with the clock about to hit zero, running back Antwan Raymond turned a short pass into a desperate pitch at the goal line, receiver Ben Black III carried the ball into the end zone as time expired, and coach Greg Schiano sent his offense back onto the field to go for two. Quarterback AJ Surace and the Scarlet Knights converted, and Rutgers won, 25-24.
It was Rutgers' first win over Penn State since 1988, ending an 18-game losing streak in the series that stretched across 38 years, ESPN reported. It was also the program's first victory over the Nittany Lions since Rutgers joined the Big Ten in 2014.
How the Final Play Unfolded
The last snap began as a screen pass to Raymond. As Penn State defenders swarmed him and dragged him down just short of the goal line, Raymond flipped the ball backward to Black before he hit the ground, according to the Associated Press account carried by Fox Sports. Black stepped into the end zone with no time left on the clock, cutting the deficit to a single point. The New York Post called it a crazy lateral on the final play, and it was hard to argue with that description.
That left Schiano with a decision. A kick would have sent the game to overtime on the road, against a program that had beaten his team every year for nearly four decades. Instead, he kept his offense on the field for the two-point try, and Surace delivered the winning points with no time remaining. Accounts of the conversion differ slightly: ESPN and the AP described Surace getting into the end zone himself, while Yahoo Sports reported a short completion in the flat. Every outlet agrees on the only detail that matters to Rutgers fans: it was good.
The comeback did not begin on the final play. Rutgers scored the last 15 points of the game over the final 10 minutes and 19 seconds, a fourth-quarter surge that left the home crowd stunned. Raymond, who ran for 101 yards and two touchdowns, was at the center of it all.
A Long Wait, and a Near Miss Last Year
The streak very nearly ended a year ago. In November 2025, Penn State needed a late rally to beat Rutgers 40-36 in Piscataway for its 18th straight win in the series, with linebacker Amare Campbell returning a fumble 61 yards for the go-ahead touchdown with 7:27 to play. Raymond carried 29 times for 189 yards in that loss and was stopped for no gain on a critical fourth down late in the game. This time, with the season on the line in a different way, he got the last word.
The win carried extra weight for Schiano, who has had a hard season and whose future had been questioned. It came less than two weeks after Rutgers announced that he would return for a 19th season as head coach, the AP reported. ESPN's account described it as a "special" win for the program.
Wade's Take: Play Until the Whistle
In a sport increasingly shaped by the transfer portal and the biggest checkbooks, Saturday was a reminder of what college football is supposed to be about: young men who keep playing when the scoreboard says the game is over. Raymond could have gone down and accepted the result. Black could have stood and watched. Instead, both kept believing in the play, and in each other, until the last second ticked away.
Schiano deserves credit, too. Overtime would have been the safe call, and nobody would have blamed him for taking it. He trusted his players to cover three yards with everything on the line, and they rewarded that trust. There is a lesson in that for anyone who leads a team, a business or a family: courage is contagious, and people rise to the confidence you show in them.
For Rutgers fans, many of whom have waited their entire adult lives to see this, the result will be retold for years. For Penn State, it is a painful home loss to a rival it had owned for a generation, the kind of defeat that lingers long after the final whistle. Rivalries are only rivalries when both sides can win, and on Saturday, for the first time since 1988, Rutgers proved it still can.
Sources
- ESPN: Rutgers authors 'special' win, 1st at Penn State since 1988 (link)
- Fox Sports (AP): Raymond's heads-up pitch helps Rutgers beat Penn State 25-24, ending 38-year losing streak in series (link)
- Yahoo Sports: Rutgers beats Penn State for first time since 1988 with last-second lateral near goal line, 2-point conversion (link)
- New York Post: Antwan Raymond's crazy lateral on final play propels Rutgers past Penn State for first time since 1988 (link)
- CBS Sports: Penn State rallies to beat Rutgers 40-36 for the 18th straight time (link)
— 30 —


