‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Sports

Mayfield Sits, Gibbs Rolls: Abby's Fantasy Plan for Buccaneers at Lions While Tampa Bay Waits on Friday

Line up a backup quarterback now, keep Bucky Irving in, bench Emeka Egbuka and start Detroit's stars without a second thought.

By ABBY LAWSONStaff Correspondent · FLORIDA · Nov 19, 3:50 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration: Photorealistic cinematic still life on a wooden kitchen table at dawn: a leather football beside a rolled athletic ankle wrap and an ice pack, a clipboard with hand-drawn X's and O's, a steaming mug of coffee and a notebook…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Wednesday is the first real practice report of the fantasy week, and the most important name on it for Sunday's Buccaneers-Lions game in Detroit was the one who did not practice at all. Here is where things stand for Tampa Bay's quarterback room, how to handle the Bucs' skill players and why Detroit's backfield remains the easiest call on your roster.

Mayfield: Don't Count on Him Yet

Baker Mayfield sat out Wednesday's practice with the foot injury that has dogged him in recent weeks, NFL.com reported in its daily news roundup. Coach Todd Bowles struck a hopeful tone, saying the quarterback has "made a lot of progress," but he added that the team will make its decision on Friday, Yahoo Sports reported. NFL Network's Ian Rapoport reported that Mayfield is trending toward missing Sunday's game with a foot strain, according to NFL.com.

With Mayfield out of practice, rookie Jalon Daniels worked with the first-team offense on Wednesday. Tampa Bay has been stocking up at the position all week, moving Easton Stick to the active roster and adding veteran Cooper Rush to the practice squad.

The Buccaneers are 3-6 and the Lions are 7-2 with five wins in a row, which tells you something about the game script I expect: Detroit ahead, Tampa Bay throwing to catch up.

My advice: if Mayfield is your starter, line up a replacement today and do not wait for Friday's announcement. With byes and injuries piling up, decent quarterback options are scarce, and the good ones on the waiver wire will be gone by the weekend. If he somehow practices in full Thursday and Friday, you can always swap him back in. In two-quarterback leagues, Daniels is a speculative add, but a rookie making a road start against a playoff-caliber team is a risk I would only take if I had no other choice.

Irving Stays in, Egbuka Takes a Seat

Whoever is under center, Bucky Irving remains the Buccaneers' workhorse. 4for4 noted that in Week 9, Irving out-snapped Kenny Gainwell 47 to 26, ran more routes, 18 to 11, and out-carried him 20 to five. That is the kind of volume that keeps a running back in your lineup even in a tough spot. If a backup quarterback is starting, I would expect Tampa Bay to lean on Irving even more, both on the ground and on short throws.

Emeka Egbuka is a harder call. Sports Illustrated pointed out that the receiver has been a fantasy disappointment this season, topping 11.3 points in only two games, and that his outlook dims further if Daniels is the quarterback. I agree. Unless your bench is bare, Egbuka belongs on it this week.

Gibbs Is the Easy Call

On the other side, there is no reason to overthink Jahmyr Gibbs. He leads the NFL with 1,000 rushing yards and 11 rushing touchdowns, according to NFL.com. Buccaneers linebacker Alex Anzalone described him as being "from a different planet," and said Tampa Bay must stay disciplined in its gaps to slow him down. 4for4 noted that Gibbs leads all flex players in expected fantasy points per game, and Sports Illustrated ranks Amon-Ra St. Brown third among its wide receivers this week.

Start both, and do not blink. When the opposing coaches are publicly worried about your player, that is the best scouting report you can get.

What About the Lions' Defense?

Detroit's defense is the trickier question. The Lions are adjusting to life without star pass rusher Aidan Hutchinson, whose injury in Munich cost him the rest of the season and dropped Detroit in several power rankings this week, Pride of Detroit noted. Losing a player of his caliber hurts the pass rush, and fantasy defenses live on sacks and turnovers.

Even so, if a rookie quarterback is starting on the road in a loud building, the Lions' defense is a reasonable streaming option this week. If Mayfield plays, I would look elsewhere. Make the call once Tampa Bay announces its quarterback on Friday.

Abby's Bottom Line

Start: Jahmyr Gibbs, Amon-Ra St. Brown, Bucky Irving. Sit: Emeka Egbuka. Wait: Baker Mayfield, with a backup quarterback already on your roster. Stream: the Lions' defense, but only if Daniels gets the start.

Fantasy football rewards the managers who plan a step ahead. Make your backup moves now, check the Friday report, and you will not be scrambling on Sunday morning. And if you want a fresh start this week, the free Liberty Bell Fantasy games are waiting for you at /fantasy.

Sources

  1. NFL.com: NFL news roundup: Baker Mayfield sits out Buccaneers practice; Geno Smith limited (link)
  2. Yahoo Sports: Todd Bowles: Baker Mayfield's made progress, decision on playing to come on Friday (link)
  3. Sports Illustrated: Week 11 Start 'Em, Sit 'Em Wide Receivers (link)
  4. NFL.com: Alex Anzalone: Buccaneers must prepare for 'from a different planet' Jahmyr Gibbs in Week 11 (link)
  5. 4for4: Fantasy Football Week 11 Start 'Em, Sit 'Em: Every Game Previewed (link)
  6. Pride of Detroit: NFL Week 11 power rankings: Detroit Lions fall after Aidan Hutchinson injury (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageSportsTurn the pageNine Straight, Then a Cold Night: Keyonte George's 30 Lead…