Sports
Hit in the Face, Then Twice on the Scoresheet: Gonzalo Tapia Leads Columbus Past 10-Man Inter Miami, 3-0, as Messi's Yellow Card Sparks a Debate
The Crew moved one win from knocking out the defending champions. Columbus' coach said Messi should have been sent off; the referee said the play didn't rise to violent conduct.
By ANDRE COLEMANStaff Correspondent · FLORIDA · Nov 22, 2:45 PM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Gonzalo Tapia took a ball to the face from Lionel Messi on Saturday night and answered the way a competitor should: on the scoreboard. Tapia scored twice as the Columbus Crew beat 10-man Inter Miami, 3-0, in Game 1 of their best-of-three MLS Cup playoff series, putting the defending champions one loss from elimination. The result was decisive. The argument afterward was about a yellow card.
A Throw-In That Became the Story
The moment came in first-half stoppage time. Messi took a quick throw-in that struck Tapia in the face from only a couple of feet away, ESPN reported. Referee Allen Chapman showed yellow cards to both players.
Columbus coach Laurent Courtois did not hide his view after the match. He said Messi should have been sent off, telling reporters that everyone knew the play deserved more than a yellow card, according to ESPN and Flashscore. The stakes of that decision were real: a red card would have suspended Messi for at least the next game, Al Jazeera noted.
Chapman explained his call to a pool reporter. He said the force involved was minimal and that the play "did not reach the level of violent conduct," according to the pool report cited by Al Jazeera.
Miami coach Cristian "Kily" González struck a similar tone, Al Jazeera reported, and put the focus on his own team, saying Miami handed Columbus its chances and didn't deliver the performance it wanted.
How Columbus Won It
The Crew were in control almost from the start. Tapia converted a penalty in the ninth minute, the Associated Press reported. Things got harder for Miami in the 36th minute, when Gonzalo Luján was sent off with his second yellow card, leaving the hosts a man down for most of the night.
Columbus took full advantage after halftime. Taha Habroune made it 2-0 in the 52nd minute, and Tapia scored his second goal in the 58th. Columbus goalkeeper Patrick Schulte made five saves to keep the clean sheet, and Messi was held off the scoresheet.
It was the kind of road playoff performance coaches dream about: an early goal, patience, and the discipline to punish a short-handed opponent without giving anything back.
Andre's Take: The Rule Book Should Read the Same for Everyone
I'll say this plainly. Messi is one of the greatest players the game has ever seen, and he has given American soccer fans moments they'll tell their grandchildren about. None of that changes the standard. A referee's job is to call the play in front of him the same way whether it involves a superstar or a rookie.
To be fair to Chapman, he explained his reasoning publicly. He judged that the force was minimal, and reasonable people can watch the same replay and see it his way. But a call like that will always draw scrutiny when the player involved is the most famous one on the field, and Courtois was right to ask the question. Fans deserve confidence that the biggest names don't get a different rule book.
The bigger lesson came from the player who got hit. Tapia didn't spend the night in a war of words. He went back to work and scored a second goal. And González deserves credit too. Instead of blaming the referee for a 3-0 loss, he pointed to his own team's performance. That's accountability, and young players watching could learn something from both men.
What Comes Next
The series moves to Ohio for Game 2 on Friday. Columbus can end Miami's title defense with one more win, while Inter Miami must win to force a deciding third game.
Expect Messi to be the most motivated player on the field. Champions don't like being one game from going home, and Miami will need its best players at their best to keep its season alive. Columbus, meanwhile, has every reason to believe. The Crew showed on Saturday that they can control a game against the league's most famous team, and they'll have their own crowd behind them on Friday.
Courtois' complaint led the New York Post's Sunday coverage of the game, and the debate over the yellow card will follow this series into Columbus. But the scoreboard has the final word, and on Saturday it said 3-0.
Sources
- Associated Press via ABC News: Tapia scores twice, Columbus beats Messi and Inter Miami 3-0 in Game 1 of best-of-3 playoff series (link)
- ESPN: Columbus coach says Messi should've got red card in Miami loss: 'Everyone knows' (link)
- Al Jazeera: Messi throws ball in opponent's face, avoids red card as Inter Miami lose (link)
- Flashscore: Columbus coach insists Messi should have seen red in Miami's thrashing (link)
- World Soccer Talk: Lionel Messi's Inter Miami fall to Columbus Crew 3-0 in Game 1, putting their title defense on the brink (link)
- New York Post: Columbus coach says 'everyone knows' Lionel Messi dodged red card after throwing ball into opponent's face in Miami playoff loss (link)
— 30 —


