Science & Space
Girl, 6, Dies in Chinese Gene-Editing Trial; Scientist Fired
Shanghai authorities removed the lead researcher and banned him from research after a probe into a child's death that went unmentioned in his published paper.
By HANNAH LINDGRENStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 20, 4:35 AM · 2 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
A 6-year-old girl died after receiving an experimental gene-editing treatment in China for a condition that was not life-threatening, and the scientist who led the work has been fired, CBS News reported, citing Chinese state media.
An official investigation in Shanghai found the child died last year after the experimental therapy, according to CBS News. The lead researcher, neuroscientist Zilong Qiu, lost his job and was handed a five-year ban from research, Malay Mail reported. Science magazine reported that more than one member of the research team was dismissed after the probe.
A Death Left Out of the Record
The girl had Snijders Blok-Campeau syndrome, a rare developmental disorder, and her family helped pay for the research into a treatment, according to reporting by Science and Retraction Watch. The South China Morning Post described the procedure as the world's first attempt to edit genes in the human brain.
The case first came to light in July, when a joint investigation by Science and Retraction Watch revealed that a paper Qiu's team published in the journal Nature on the research did not mention the child's death. That reporting prompted both the journal and Qiu's university to open inquiries, Retraction Watch reported. Investigators later pointed to failures in safety testing, ethics review and disclosure, according to coverage of the findings.
An Old Warning, Ignored Again
This is not the first time a Chinese gene-editing experiment has crossed a bright line. In 2018, researcher He Jiankui announced the birth of twin girls whose genes he had edited as embryos, and his university later fired him, CBC News reported at the time.
Medical research on children is held to the highest standard for a reason. A child cannot weigh the risks for herself, so every safeguard, from animal testing to independent ethics boards to full public disclosure, exists to protect her. In this case, the reporting shows, those safeguards failed, and the public learned of her death through reporters' digging rather than from the researchers.
Why It Matters
Gene editing holds real promise for families facing terrible diseases, and many American parents of children with rare conditions pray for exactly this kind of breakthrough. But promise is no excuse for treating a little girl as an experiment. Scripture teaches that every child is fearfully and wonderfully made, and medicine that forgets that loses its way.
The case also raises hard questions for American institutions weighing research ties with China. Regulators and journals should demand full disclosure of every serious harm, and they should be wary of research from systems where a child's death can stay hidden until outsiders uncover it.
Retraction Watch reported in July that Nature had added an editor's note to the paper, a step it said was not a retraction.
Sources
- CBS News: Scientist fired after 6-year-old girl dies in gene-editing trial (link)
- Science: Chinese gene therapy researchers fired after probe into child's death (link)
- South China Morning Post: Chinese scientists fired after child dies in world's first brain gene-editing attempt (link)
- Retraction Watch: Journal, university investigations launched into gene-editing death following Science-Retraction Watch reporting (link)
- Malay Mail: Chinese scientist loses job, gets five-year research ban over girl's death in gene-editing trial (link)
- CBC News: Chinese scientist behind gene-edited babies fired by university (link)
— 30 —


