‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

The Referee Can't Pick a Team: Why Riverside County's Targeted Turnout Ads Deserve Every Bit of Scrutiny

A City Journal review of taxpayer-funded get-out-the-vote ads has drawn a letter from Rep. Ken Calvert. California's own Supreme Court has long said public money may not be spent to take sides in elections.

By SOPHIA REYESStaff Correspondent · WASHINGTON · Nov 20, 3:00 PM · 4 min. read

Illustration: A Southern California county government building at sunset framed by tall palm trees, a plain unmarked metal ballot drop box on the plaza in front, a smartphone resting on a stone bench glowing with an abstract blurred feed…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

Every county election office in America has one job that matters more than any other: to run elections that every voter, of every party, can trust. That is why a new report about Riverside County, California, deserves a hard look from Republicans and Democrats alike.

Here is what has been reported. Rep. Ken Calvert, a California Republican, sent a letter on Tuesday to Karen Spiegel, chairwoman of the Riverside County Board of Supervisors, raising concerns about the county's taxpayer-funded voter turnout effort before the 2026 midterms, the Washington Examiner reported. The Examiner described Riverside as a swing county and said the concerns grew out of an investigative report finding that election officials used public resources to turn out Democratic voters in particular.

That investigation came from City Journal, which reviewed a week of social media advertising placed by the election offices of Riverside and San Diego counties before the midterms. In fairness to the counties, neither responded to City Journal's requests for comment, and City Journal itself acknowledged that supporters of such outreach would say it is meant to reach citizens who might not otherwise vote. Encouraging people to vote is a legitimate public purpose, and reaching residents in Spanish is not partisan on its own. The question is whether the dollars were aimed evenly.

What the Ads Showed

According to City Journal, Riverside County's Registrar of Voters steered more than 10 percent of its Meta advertising dollars to a single ZIP code in downtown Riverside where Kamala Harris won an estimated 58 percent of the vote. During the week City Journal examined, the county directed more than 40 percent of its Meta ad spending to Spanish-speaking audiences. And the county paid for ads aimed at users whom Meta associated with interests such as African-American history and Native American studies, and the report's headline says the counties also aimed ads at users interested in gangsta rap.

None of that proves anyone in the registrar's office set out to help one party. But it does show a pattern worth explaining. A turnout campaign paid for by every taxpayer should be built to reach every kind of voter, the rancher in the high desert as surely as the renter downtown, the evangelical in Temecula as surely as the college student in Riverside. When the targeting maps neatly onto one party's strongest neighborhoods and cultural markers, the public is owed an account of why.

What California Law Already Says

This is not a new question in California, and the state's highest court answered it half a century ago. In Stanson v. Mott, decided in 1976, the California Supreme Court held that, absent clear and explicit authorization from the Legislature, a public agency may not spend public funds "to promote a partisan position in an election campaign". That case arose when the state parks director spent more than $5,000 in public money promoting a $250 million park bond, and the court drew a firm line between giving the public fair, balanced information and campaigning with tax dollars.

In 2009, in Vargas v. City of Salinas, the same court reaffirmed that the Stanson standard still governs and rejected the argument that a later statute had replaced it.

To be precise, both cases involved spending on ballot measures, and no court has ruled on Riverside's ads. But the principle at the heart of Stanson is neutrality: government may inform, but it may not take sides. A get-out-the-vote drive that reaches everyone honors that principle. One that pours a disproportionate share of its budget into the most partisan corners of the map invites exactly the suspicion the court warned against.

Common sense points the same direction. Imagine a registrar who spent a tenth of the county's ad budget in its most Republican ZIP code and targeted users interested in hunting, country music and Christian radio. The outcry would be immediate, and it would be right. The standard has to be the same no matter which party benefits.

Who Is Pushing Back, and What Comes Next

Calvert has now put the findings formally in front of the county's board of supervisors. The next move belongs to the board and the registrar. The simplest answer is also the best one: publish the full targeting criteria and spending for every taxpayer-funded voter outreach ad, explain how each audience was chosen, and show that the program reached rural, suburban and urban voters alike.

The advertising records City Journal reviewed came from Meta's public ad disclosures, which means any voter can check the work. That kind of openness should be the rule, not the exception. Election offices are the referees of our democracy. When a referee is accused of leaning, the answer is not silence. It is to open the books and let the people see for themselves.

Voters in Riverside County, and in every county that spends public money on turnout, should insist on it. Trust in elections is built one honest, even-handed decision at a time.

Sources

  1. Washington Examiner: California county under congressional scrutiny over taxpayer-funded voter turnout campaign targeting Democrats (link)
  2. City Journal: California Counties Targeted Get-Out-the-Vote Ads to Users Interested in “Gangsta Rap” (link)
  3. Supreme Court of California (Stanford SCOCAL): Stanson v. Mott (1976) (link)
  4. Supreme Court of California (Stanford SCOCAL): Vargas v. City of Salinas (2009) (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageFrance Wants to Put a Stopwatch on YouTubers. Americans…Turn the pageTexas Settled the Sanctuary Question in 2017. A New…