Pushback
The Facts Don't Back Up a $20 Federal Minimum Wage: What Washington's Own Scorekeeper Found When the Ask Was $15
Sen. Bernie Sanders plans to use his coming committee gavel to push a $20 national wage floor. The Congressional Budget Office's work on a smaller raise, and California's real-world $20 experiment, show who would pay.
By EVELYN HARTStaff Correspondent · CALIFORNIA · Nov 22, 10:40 AM · 3 min. read

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report
Fresh off his party's midterm victories, Sen. Bernie Sanders has made his next goal plain. In an interview with the Associated Press, the Vermont independent said he intends to use his expected return to the chairmanship of a powerful Senate committee in January to push for raising the federal minimum wage from $7.25 an hour to $20, alongside the PRO Act union bill and a four-year transition to Medicare for All. Sanders called the current $7.25 floor badly out of date, and on that narrow point plenty of Americans would agree: the federal minimum has not moved since 2009.
But a better question than whether the number is old is what a $20 national mandate would do to the very workers it is meant to help. On that, the record is sobering, and much of it comes from Washington's own nonpartisan scorekeeper, the Congressional Budget Office.
What CBO Found at $15
In 2019, CBO studied a bill to raise the federal minimum to $15 by 2025. Its median estimate was that 1.3 million workers would lose their jobs, and it said the number could run as high as 3.7 million. The same report found about 17 million workers would get a raise and about 1.3 million people would be lifted out of poverty. That is the honest trade-off: higher pay for many, and no job at all for a large number of others, usually the youngest, least experienced and least skilled.
When CBO scored a $15 bill again in 2021, it projected 1.4 million jobs lost, about 900,000 fewer people in poverty, and a $54 billion increase in federal deficits over ten years. Those deficits matter to working families too, because every dollar the government borrows is a dollar that eventually shows up in higher taxes or higher interest rates.
Sanders is now asking for $20, a third higher than the $15 figure CBO studied. Nothing in the agency's work suggests the costs shrink as the mandate grows.
California Already Ran the Experiment
Americans do not have to rely only on projections. In April 2024, California required large fast-food chains to pay at least $20 an hour. The research on what followed is split, and fairness requires saying so. Economists at the University of California, Berkeley, reported that pay in the industry rose and found no reduction in employment, with menu prices rising by a few percent. But a study by economists Jeffrey Clemens, Olivia Edwards and Jonathan Meer, summarized by the Cato Institute, found that fast-food employment in California fell about 2.7 percent relative to the rest of the country after the law took effect, which works out to roughly 18,000 jobs.
Even the most favorable reading of California's law describes a single industry in one of the highest-cost states in the nation. Sanders' proposal would apply the same wage floor to a diner in rural Mississippi, a family farm stand in Iowa and a hardware store in small-town Ohio, places where rents, wages and prices look nothing like Los Angeles or San Francisco.
The Common-Sense Case for Restraint
The Constitution gives Congress the power to regulate interstate commerce, but whether a power exists and whether it is wise to use it are separate questions. The better path is the one federalism already provides: let states and cities, which know their own costs of living, set wage floors that fit their own economies, as many have chosen to do, rather than having Washington force one number on every corner of the country.
There are also better tools for helping low-wage families that do not price the least experienced workers out of a first job. The earned income tax credit, for example, rewards work without putting the cost on the small employers who hire entry-level workers.
Who Is Pushing Back
Sanders' plan faces long odds. Anything the next Congress passes would still need President Trump's signature to become law, the AP noted. Business groups and economists are already warning about smaller increases. In Pennsylvania, where Gov. Josh Shapiro wants a $15 state minimum, the Employment Policies Institute, a pro-business research group, estimated the hike could cost about 80,000 jobs.
A first job at a modest wage is how millions of Americans learned to show up on time, serve a customer and earn a promotion. A mandate that makes that first rung disappear is not compassion. It is a closed door, and the government's own numbers say so.
Sources
- AP via WOWT: Bernie Sanders unveils his plan to push Medicare for All when Democrats take power (link)
- NPR: $15 Minimum Wage Would Boost 17 Million Workers, Cut 1.3 Million Jobs, CBO Says (link)
- NPR: $15 Minimum Wage Would Reduce Poverty But Cost Jobs, CBO Says (link)
- Cato Institute: Did California's Fast-Food Minimum Wage Reduce Employment? (link)
- UC Berkeley IRLE: New study analyzes impact of California's $20 minimum wage for fast food workers (link)
- The Washington Times: Report estimates Pennsylvania could lose 80,000 jobs from $15 minimum wage hike (link)
— 30 —


