‹ BackThe Newspaper EditionFront PageExit to modern site ›
Liberty Bell Report

Pushback

The Constitution Wins as Court Permanently Blocks California's Mask and ID Rules for Federal Agents

A federal judge in Los Angeles has permanently barred California from enforcing its mask ban and ID mandate against federal officers, and the state has agreed not to appeal. The Supremacy Clause explains why.

By HAROLD WHITMOREStaff Correspondent · CALIFORNIA · Nov 19, 10:00 PM · 4 min. read

Illustration: The glass-walled, cube-shaped First Street United States Courthouse in downtown Los Angeles at golden hour, its folded glass facade glowing amber in the setting sun, an American flag lifting on a tall pole in the foreground…

Illustration · Liberty Bell Report

On Tuesday, Nov. 17, U.S. District Judge Christina Snyder signed an order permanently barring California from enforcing its mask ban and its identification mandate against federal officers, after the state agreed to stop fighting the case, South Shore Press reported. The Justice Department announced the result Thursday, saying the injunction, entered in the Central District of California, bars the state, Gov. Gavin Newsom and Attorney General Rob Bonta from enforcing those laws against the United States, its officers and its agencies, and serves as the final resolution of the federal lawsuit.

The outcome rests on one of the oldest rules in our constitutional order: a state may govern its own officers, but not the federal government.

What California passed and why

In September 2025, Newsom signed the No Secret Police Act, SB 627, making California the first state to ban federal agents from wearing masks while on duty, KTVU reported. The bill's author, state Sen. Scott Wiener, argued that President Trump had turned a rapidly expanding ICE into a secret police force that was frightening communities, particularly Latino communities, according to the station. Newsom directed his message at immigration agents themselves, asking them, "What are you afraid of?"

A companion measure, the No Vigilantes Act, SB 805, required officers to display identification showing their agency and a name or badge number, KTVU reported.

Those concerns deserve a respectful hearing. Americans have a real interest in knowing that the people making arrests are who they say they are. But a sincere goal does not hand a state a power the Constitution withholds.

How the Constitution answered

The Justice Department sued, arguing that the laws interfered with the ability of federal officers to protect their identities and carry out their duties. The courts agreed along two lines that together make up the doctrine lawyers call intergovernmental immunity.

The first line is discrimination. In February, Snyder blocked the mask ban as applied to federal agents because it did not also apply to California's own state law enforcement, which meant the state was placing on Washington a burden it spared itself, KTVU reported. At that stage she left the ID requirement in place and left room for a rewritten mask law covering every agency, and Wiener promised new legislation adding state police.

The second line is direct regulation, and it proved decisive. In October, a unanimous Ninth Circuit panel held that the ID mandate violates the Supremacy Clause and cannot be enforced against federal agents, Courthouse News reported. Judge Mark Bennett, a Trump appointee, wrote the opinion, joined by Judge Daniel Collins, also a Trump appointee, and Judge Jacqueline Nguyen, an Obama appointee. The panel reversed the lower court and directed it to enter an injunction against the identification rule.

That distinction matters for anyone hoping to revive the rules. If the defect is that a state is telling federal officers how to dress and identify themselves while doing federal work, then treating state police the same way does not cure it. The Supremacy Clause makes federal law supreme in its own sphere. It does not invite each state legislature to write its own dress code for agents enforcing laws passed by Congress.

Officer safety is not an abstraction. The Department of Homeland Security reported 238 assaults on ICE officers from Jan. 21 through Nov. 21, 2025, compared with 19 in the same stretch of the prior year, an increase of 1,153 percent, according to a Center Square report published by Just the News. Those are the department's own figures, and the starting number was small, but the trend is hard to ignore. It helps explain why Washington fought to keep decisions about protecting officers' identities in federal hands.

Who pushed back, and what comes next

The pushback came from the Justice Department, which brought the case; from the federal bench, where a district judge and a bipartisan appellate panel each found constitutional defects; and finally from California itself, which agreed to stop contesting the suit. Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward said the order confirms that states lack the authority to regulate the federal government or to dictate how federal officers do their jobs, according to the department.

The final order covers four provisions, Sections 7288 and 7289 of the California Government Code and Sections 185.5 and 13654 of the Penal Code, as they apply to federal officers and agencies. It binds the governor and the attorney general along with their successors, and the state has agreed not to pursue further appeals, South Shore Press reported. These laws will not be headed back to the Ninth Circuit or on to the Supreme Court.

Sacramento could still try again, as Wiener signaled after the February ruling. But the appeals court's reasoning on direct regulation suggests the trouble was never a matter of drafting. Any future bill dictating how federal agents identify themselves on duty would likely hit the same wall.

The lesson is old and sound. Our system gives states wide room to manage their own affairs and gives the national government room to do the work the Constitution assigns it. When one tries to run the other's officers, the courts step in. This week they did, and California accepted the result.

Sources

  1. KTVU: California becomes first state to ban federal agents from wearing masks (link)
  2. U.S. Department of Justice: Justice Department Secures Permanent Injunction Against California Laws Restricting Federal Law Enforcement Operations (link)
  3. South Shore Press: Judge Permanently Bars California From Enforcing Mask and ID Laws Against Federal Officers (link)
  4. KTVU: Judge blocks California's ban on federal agents wearing masks (link)
  5. Courthouse News Service: Ninth Circuit strikes down California 'No Vigilantes Act' as unconstitutional (link)
  6. Just the News: Number of assaults on ICE officers up 1,153% in 11 months: Homeland Security Department (link)

— 30 —

Read this story on the full website, with comments »

Also in Today’s Edition

Previous pageHinojosa's Charter Critique Overlooks the Nearly 70,000…Turn the pageA Ceiling Already Gave Way: Why the Kennedy Center Needs…